How realistic is this show ??

moderngirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Hey Y'all,

Well, I think we've had plenty of post discussing how good Sinndoor is and numerous amounts of posts on character analysis but I don't think anyones ever had a discussion how how realistic this show has been. Well, as realistic as a "Show" gets anyway! But you get my drift, right??

Was the very begining of the show realistic where DhruVed were first married and Ved mentally ill?? Or what about the time when We found out Viren had had relations with another owman aside from Kavita?? When we thought Dhruv had come back as karan?? or even now when Vedika dies and the killer is till unknown??

What are your opinions. Is Sinndoor as realistic as any show can get or has it gone past "realistic" to a point where it's just not believable??

Share your views here. Iam curious to know...

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

890

Users

5

Frequent Posters

hydrogurl001 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
well yeah i pretty much agree...but all shows are like that 😆 directors dont think at all about being realistic, only about being entertaining 😕 ...Sinndoor isnt what id call the MOST unrealistic serial...but it is VERY unrealistic

i mean...the beginning of the show wasnt too bad but its getting more unrealistic every day 😕 , but it still is getting more entertaining 😛

sree thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Wow!! A very good post, i must say.. 👏👏👏

Yes, i agree that Sinndoor has gone a bit unrealistic, in the fact that many important characters have gone missing , all of sudden.. Even when the small kid Parth is lost, nobody in the family is tkaing the pain to search for the kid. No attempt is being made to search. Same thing with Uma. Uma is the mother of Ved and Nih, she was in coma. But nobody ever goes to the hospital to have a look at her... These are few things where the touch of reality is missing in the story line..

But, when i think about the positives, i would say that there has been some good realistic tracks too shown in Sinndoor. It will not be fair if i compare Sinndoor to any other serial and argue. But, there are many serials shown even today, where nothing shown is realistic.

While in few serials, the death of a main character is shown, they show that the family members dress up and behave as normally as ever, even if it means that it is harldy few days since the passing off of that character.. When we compare this to Sinndoor, we can say that Sinndoor has always shown the right balance of emotion and fun and happiness.

Story tracks like Dhruv marrying a mentally ill Ved just for his mother, to get back him mother's love was realistic enough.. Dhruv and Ved falling in love as days passed, was realistic enough. The change of shades to good and bad in both Ant and Nih's characters have definitely been good to watch.. They both always trying to score over another, has been convincing enough. Rudr coming into the Raizada family, to take revenge, then changing into a good son, after knowing the fact was really good.. The presumed death of Dhruv, the entry of Karan , the way in which the story evolved between Alisha, Karan, Dhruv and Ved was fine, there was nothing that was not realistic in it.. Raizada family going thro a sad phase, living in chawl was also portratyed very realistically. They having to struggle for every penny was indeed realistic. The pain, the agony, the suffering all went thro at that stage was rightly shown. The turning point where ant plans to get back everything thro Shivam was also good and interesting..The entry of Arpita into Raizada family was also acceptable, knowing the nature of Dhruv, knowing how emotional his character has always been.. The situations that force Dhruv to marry Arpita was again, acceptable, i would say, again, bcos of the soft, loving and emotional character that Dhruv has always been..

Yes, this is purely my viewpoint, anyone can feel free to argue and debate.. I am ready to do that. 😳I agree that few things were shown that were not realistic. But overall, i do feel that there are more unrealistic serials that are on air than Sinndoor, so i would not take away the credit from the good screenplay in Sinndoor, the great acting performance that all the stars in Sinndoor deliver each day.. So i would say that Sinndoor gets a grace mark from me as far as realistic story plots are concerned.. 😳
DivyaD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: sree

Wow!! A very good post, i must say.. 👏👏👏

Yes, i agree that Sinndoor has gone a bit unrealistic, in the fact that many important characters have gone missing , all of sudden.. Even when the small kid Parth is lost, nobody in the family is tkaing the pain to search for the kid. No attempt is being made to search. Same thing with Uma. Uma is the mother of Ved and Nih, she was in coma. But nobody ever goes to the hospital to have a look at her... These are few things where the touch of reality is missing in the story line..

But, when i think about the positives, i would say that there has been some good realistic tracks too shown in Sinndoor. It will not be fair if i compare Sinndoor to any other serial and argue. But, there are many serials shown even today, where nothing shown is realistic.

While in few serials, the death of a main character is shown, they show that the family members dress up and behave as normally as ever, even if it means that it is harldy few days since the passing off of that character.. When we compare this to Sinndoor, we can say that Sinndoor has always shown the right balance of emotion and fun and happiness.

Story tracks like Dhruv marrying a mentally ill Ved just for his mother, to get back him mother's love was realistic enough.. Dhruv and Ved falling in love as days passed, was realistic enough. The change of shades to good and bad in both Ant and Nih's characters have definitely been good to watch.. They both always trying to score over another, has been convincing enough. Rudr coming into the Raizada family, to take revenge, then changing into a good son, after knowing the fact was really good.. The presumed death of Dhruv, the entry of Karan , the way in which the story evolved between Alisha, Karan, Dhruv and Ved was fine, there was nothing that was not realistic in it.. Raizada family going thro a sad phase, living in chawl was also portratyed very realistically. They having to struggle for every penny was indeed realistic. The pain, the agony, the suffering all went thro at that stage was rightly shown. The turning point where ant plans to get back everything thro Shivam was also good and interesting..The entry of Arpita into Raizada family was also acceptable, knowing the nature of Dhruv, knowing how emotional his character has always been.. The situations that force Dhruv to marry Arpita was again, acceptable, i would say, again, bcos of the soft, loving and emotional character that Dhruv has always been..

Yes, this is purely my viewpoint, anyone can feel free to argue and debate.. I am ready to do that. 😳I agree that few things were shown that were not realistic. But overall, i do feel that there are more unrealistic serials that are on air than Sinndoor, so i would not take away the credit from the good screenplay in Sinndoor, the great acting performance that all the stars in Sinndoor deliver each day.. So i would say that Sinndoor gets a grace mark from me as far as realistic story plots are concerned.. 😳

I have absolutely nothing left to say after that brilliant post Sreedi...😕

I aggree with you 222%😆

gimzy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
hi 2 all!!!

hmmm 4 me personnally wen sindor was first aired z story abt a boy who loves his mum n bro so much zat he agrees to marry a mentally challenged person when he culd hav marry z gal he loved(aartee) was just too gud..... it was realistic enough!!!!! zen from zat to develop wat now is known as Dhruv ki Vedika n Vedika ka Dhruv relationship was just perfect. n zen z way sindoor explore relationships like zat bet sisters(ved& nih) n bro (ant & Dhruv) was quite nice also...

wat became unrealistics were z way faulty ppl were always forgiven n given a plave back in raizadas house.... here im pointing 2 ANTARISK 😡 😡 n zen z way they make 1 protagonist marry so many times is absolutely absurd!!!!!! in zis show no 1 has been spared most of them has marry 2 or more times........... also to introduce new characters n zen to eliminate them without a second thought is totally unrealistic here im thinkin of alisha, aartee, ayush, parth, ved's mom, tara, titli mami's husband, n many more

hmmm in fact now zat ive started writin many more realistic n unrealistics things r coming to my mind but z msg will be too long 😆 😆 😆 so better end it here

DivyaD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: gimzy

hi 2 all!!!

hmmm 4 me personnally wen sindor was first aired z story abt a boy who loves his mum n bro so much zat he agrees to marry a mentally challenged person when he culd hav marry z gal he loved(aartee) was just too gud..... it was realistic enough!!!!! zen from zat to develop wat now is known as Dhruv ki Vedika n Vedika ka Dhruv relationship was just perfect. n zen z way sindoor explore relationships like zat bet sisters(ved& nih) n bro (ant & Dhruv) was quite nice also...

wat became unrealistics were z way faulty ppl were always forgiven n given a plave back in raizadas house.... here im pointing 2 ANTARISK 😡 😡 n zen z way they make 1 protagonist marry so many times is absolutely absurd!!!!!! in zis show no 1 has been spared most of them has marry 2 or more times........... also to introduce new characters n zen to eliminate them without a second thought is totally unrealistic here im thinkin of alisha, aartee, ayush, parth, ved's mom, tara, titli mami's husband, n many more

hmmm in fact now zat ive started writin many more realistic n unrealistics things r coming to my mind but z msg will be too long 😆 😆 😆 so better end it here

Hey... yeah, we all loved Sindoor in the beginning when they showcased Dhruv and Vedika's love... was really sweet!

When you say the protagonist to marry so many times is absurd, I think they do that because the programme is called Sindoor, and therefore, they always have to come back to marriage, whether it different people's or the saem persons. They show the different shades of Sindoor, how people can make mistakes in who they choose to wear Sindoor for, etc....

Also, all those people you metioned that were eliminated, they all, collectively, a very large impact on what Sindoor is today, If Dhruv wasn't involved with Arthi, his mlove with Vedika wouldn't have seemed as sweet, if Ayush wasn't around, how would Vedika have gotten a job to help with the finances when they were all kicked out of the house by Niharika, If Alisha wasn't around, Vedika wouldn't have had the chance to mother that beautiful child before she passed on...Uma supported Vedika and Nih so much, of course the 2 main female roles have to have some family, etc, etc... there are so many intricate threads that involve extra characters in these serials, not only Sindoor that makes it so interesting...

Please understand that this post is not directed at you and I am most definitely not attacking you, I am just addressing the points that you have brought up - because for me, it is all these reasons why I love Sindoor and am so sad that people want it to end... You, through bringing up all these people's names have reminded me of how much I love Sindoor... thanks for that!! 🤗

gimzy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
😉 no problem dear in fact i apreciate zat u read my reply!!!!!!!! i was just statin wat me i think is realistic or unrealistic in sindoor...... its just a matter of opinions!!!!!! 😳 😳

in fact to some extent i do agree zat many characters zat i pointed out were important ones n without zem sindoor would not hav wer it is today but wat i wanted to voice out was zat it would hav been nice to keep more ppl in sindoor so zat it add more spice to z show...... at z present we got important characters left but z story is goin round round between zem..... with more ppl z show can get more entertainin 😉 😉

hope u understand my point 😳 😳
sree thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: gimzy

😉 no problem dear in fact i apreciate zat u read my reply!!!!!!!! i was just statin wat me i think is realistic or unrealistic in sindoor...... its just a matter of opinions!!!!!! 😳 😳

in fact to some extent i do agree zat many characters zat i pointed out were important ones n without zem sindoor would not hav wer it is today but wat i wanted to voice out was zat it would hav been nice to keep more ppl in sindoor so zat it add more spice to z show...... at z present we got important characters left but z story is goin round round between zem..... with more ppl z show can get more entertainin 😉 😉

hope u understand my point 😳 😳



I defo agree, with what you are saying.. Characters like kavitha, sundari and Alisha did give impetus to the story line.. I would like to see Sundari and Alisha get back, that will be another nice twist to the tale.. 😳 Infact, i miss Karan too.. 😆bcos, he too was really nice , even if he was a full and full negative character.. 👏 Can we forget Sachin's superb portrayal as Karan? 😳
gimzy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sree



I defo agree, with what you are saying.. Characters like kavitha, sundari and Alisha did give impetus to the story line.. I would like to see Sundari and Alisha get back, that will be another nice twist to the tale.. 😳 Infact, i miss Karan too.. 😆bcos, he too was really nice , even if he was a full and full negative character.. 👏 Can we forget Sachin's superb portrayal as Karan? 😳




😃😃 Zats exactly wat i was tryin 2 say...... even though zes r "bad" charcters according 2 us (karan, alisha, SUNDARI) z storyline is sumthg else wiz them!!!!!!!!!! 😳😳

N btw z return of rudra was too gud..... though 2 portray shivam as a vilain now is heartbreakin😭😭 lol we quite enjoy his entry n really i was bettin zat ved's death will be solved wiz z participation of shivam!!!!!! zer goes all my hopes......... another chance 2 show how well sindoor team is zer to surprise us n keep us glued 2 zis serial😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".