Would have been better if dhrishti had mauli's role. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.6k

Users

19

Likes

139

Frequent Posters

VidushiSingal thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Nandy141


Let's be honest .. Nandini is partially hated for what is she is and also the way it's being enacted by the actress
Her expressions are simply blant. During her emotional turmoil nor the dialogues she delivers about how she is ready to sacrifice her so called true love , the audience are not able to connect with the character ( At Least most of the people in the Forum are not able to )

Mauli is being loved for the way Aditi enacts it nor for Aditi
The others including me who commented- Nandini will be loved if it's done by Aditi
Meaning: Aditi will express the turmoils of Nandini in such a way, people will be able to connect to the character and really understand the emotional trauma Nandini is going through

I think drashti played domestic victim very well .She potrayed the pain of woman who was badly treated by husband very well.And i m new member here but read this forum posts silently .I felt that i should also make conversations with ppl to know their mindset.I will say i will agree to disagree here .I don't think the way the character is written any actor could hv generated sympathy for nandini.That is my opinion on this topic even itv best actress would hv played nandini ppl still would hv hated the way her character is potrayed.And i don't find actress playing nandini expression blunt.She is doing fine job if not the best.
Edited by Metis - 6 years ago
_innocent_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#12
I wish the makers had given Nandini more shades. She is a grey character, ie she is behaving like any human being would...her happiness overrides everyone else's kinda behavior. If the makers had made it clear that its a grey character instead of trying to show her as mahan, it would have been a perfect role for DD. Nandini as a character is not well scripted but I still feel DD is better off playing Nandini than Mauli as she fits that role more.
Edited by Metis - 6 years ago
Y12345 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#13
why?
Why DD should have all the glory? Why everything has to mould up to suit her benefit?

She chose that role so let her bear the consequences

The reason why they didnt cast her as mauli is because let's face, she couldn't have played M better than Aditi




Edited by Y12345 - 6 years ago
Nandy141 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: VidushiSingal

I think drashti played domestic victim very well .She potrayed the pain of woman who was badly treated by husband very well.And i m new member here but read this forum posts silently .I felt that i should also make conversations with ppl to know their mindset.Why ppl here can't express opinion without referring to other forum members others can speak 4 themselves.I will say i will agree to disagree here .I don't think the way the character is written any actor could hv generated sympathy for nandini.That is my opinion on this topic even itv best actress would hv played nandini ppl still would hv hated the way her character is potrayed.And i don't find actress playing nandini expression blunt.She is doing fine job if not the best.


Your opinion about how well Nandini is being portrayed completely personal so i won't argue over . I hate the way Nandini is being enacted and you love it. Just a difference of opinion and personal liking

since u 've quoted my answer and directed a question I 've marked in read I am answering it

I answered a fellow IF who has made a comment on how ppl say so and so
So i replied it appropriately

Btw, New Member welcome to the Forum . There are so many examples on negative characters being liked by ppl more than positive characters.
We are on the Silsila Threads and Rajdeep is a best example of it
The way Abhinav is enacting it has earned him many fans
I personally like him for the way he shows his cruel and shameless side making me fear him and at the same time delivering funny one liners
VidushiSingal thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Nandy141


Your opinion about how well Nandini is being portrayed completely personal so i won't argue over . I hate the way Nandini is being enacted and you love it. Just a difference of opinion and personal liking

since u 've quoted my answer and directed a question I 've marked in read I am answering it

I answered a fellow IF who has made a comment on how ppl say so and so
So i replied it appropriately

Btw, New Member welcome to the Forum . There are so many examples on negative characters being liked by ppl more than positive characters.
We are on the Silsila Threads and Rajdeep is a best example of it
The way Abhinav is enacting it has earned him many fans
I personally like him for the way he shows his cruel and shameless side making me fear him and at the same time delivering funny one liners

Thanks 4 welcoming me
You don't like her acting fine your opinion respect it but don't generalise for other ppl there are ppl beyond this forum too i hv seen comments on SM where ppl said they still love drashti and like her acting but they don't want to play her nandini.That means there are still audience who love her acting but don't want her to play nandini another woman.Any actress who will play a other woman will get backlash no matter how good the actress will be that is mindset of society they will blame woman more than man for breaking home.This is fact no matter what ppl here keep on denying this.Secondly,Rajdeep and mauli are pure black and pure white characters they will be either hated or loved.But nandini has shades of grey but writers didn't explore that area properly that is why ppl are irritated and thus this backlash.
Farheein thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#16
I'm sorry I can't see Drashti playing the role of Mauli and doing it justice like Aditi. Aditi is perfect for this role.
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#17
Honestly- problem is not in casting, problem is with script.
How could they expect anyone to not hate the one who backstabbed her savior/best friend? Even if Madhuri Dixit comes and play Nandini, there won't be any acceptance.


Just imagine the situation- actors are told that, your character will sleep with a married man who is actually husband of your bestie, but you have to express in such a way that audience should feel you are a victim. How to give that non existing expression?


They should have worked on script.
akashnanda thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...

If role reversal happened,i think i would have never connect with Mauli and i think i would have connect with Nandini 😆

that s d impact wat Aditi has left in our hearts ..
VidushiSingal thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: White..Magic

Honestly- problem is not in casting, problem is with script.

How could they expect anyone to not hate the one who backstabbed her savior/best friend? Even if Madhuri Dixit comes and play Nandini, there won't be any acceptance.


Just imagine the situation- actors are told that, your character will sleep with a married man who is actually husband of your bestie, but you have to express in such a way that audience should feel you are a victim. How to give that non existing expression?


They should have worked on script.

Exactly dear i agree with your every line
sweet_tania thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#20
Aditi is so great artist that she has added her own charm and flavors beautifully in mauli's character. I can't forget her acting in confrontation scene in my entire life and can't imagine anyone else in place of aditi .

If we talk about role reversal than what drashti had done in mauli's character is like she had added flavor of 2 bottle glycerin and hand shivering while asking questions to kunal in confrontation scene . Can you imagine it !!! I can't .

Drashti has stardom and superficial fan following but for me , when it comes to acting, Aditi is powerhouse. Drashti is telly world's Katrina kaif and Aditi is telly world's Kajol . This is just my opinion and every one is entitled to their own opinion.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".