JoonBai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
Mauli doesn't deserve an ounce of all the suffering she is going through, and my heart goes out to her. But there are many posts about her plight on this forum, so I won't write more. Just because I wrote less about her, please don't think that I'm undermining her grief.
BUT...

Kunal and Nandini are also human-beings. They made mistakes, big ones. But are their crimes so unforgivable? I understand that most of you support Mauli, but why does that have to translate to so much of hatred for KuNan? I read about lynching activities where crowds kill petty thieves for crimes such as robbing a wallet. Say the wallet contains the entire monthly income for a family. So yes, hand over the thief to the police and return the wallet to the family. If the money's gone, try to raise money for them. But killing a person over it isn't right. What's happening to KuNan now is pure moral lynching. It is the compulsive need of masses to label something as white or black; grey is totally unacceptable and considered even worse than black. KuNan betrayed Mauli, so let them lose their friendship with her and their relationship with their close friends and family. But once they face their punishment, they have a right to be happy with each other; their love and relationship deserves respect and a place in society, as much as Kunal and Mauli's did.

If Kunal chooses to be with Nandini, he will lose his entire family and probably may lose the chance of being a father to his own child. If he leaves Nandini, he will have to stay in a loveless marriage. Both ways, some part of him is going to be unhappy, and he knows it. But his love for Nandini has stayed strong and probably will for life. What is wrong with that?

Nandini found love after 7 yrs of marital abuse, but she receives worse treatment than Kunal. The term 'marital abuse' has become nothing but a term that contains two words. Doesn't matter if this includes rape, physical and mental bruises, forced abortions, frequent cheating and so on. 7 is also just a number. Doesn't matter that this translates to 2555 days of torture that she faced alone. The fact that she found what she had yearned for every single one of those days cannot seem to supersede the fact that she found it in her best friend's husband. Also, she slept with him; she did, because that was the first intimate contact she ever had that involved real love, and it happened when she was feeling vulnerable and Kunal comforted her. When you love someone, it happens. She didn't think of Mauli at each and every step of her relationship with Kunal, but she did think of her many times, and she did step away. Ultimately, her love for Kunal overpowered her friendship with Mauli, and she gave in. Is that so wrong? Now she is probably going to sacrifice her love for Mauli's child. Still, her actions are being viewed as evil. Everyone chides her for falling for Kunal, but would they have done so if he wasn't married? So, being married makes Kunal a different person? She fell for Kunal, not Mauli's husband. She cannot fall in love like a normal person, because the one she loves, and who loves her back, is married? She is supposed to subdue her feelings and suffer? Why, just to fulfill societal norms?

The worst part is some people saying that Rajdeep is far better than KuNan. He has become a comedy character for viewers now, and they have forgotten all his crimes - rape, marital abuse and so on, just because they want to hate KuNan so much. It's a new low.

Many members of this forum call Kunal's feelings for Nandini lust. If it was lust, why is he putting so much at stake to be with her?

Also, why is it so difficult to believe that Kunal's feelings for Nandini began to evolve once he saw her dancing in the rain? Most of the people in our previous generation got married only after seeing each other, or sometimes just each other's photographs, once. There are many people who fall in love at first sight. Are these also examples of lust? Or is lust only applicable when married individuals fall for someone other than their spouse? Now, what if Kunal wasn't married? Would that still count as love or would it still be lust? Would the divine symbolism linked to KuNan still be mocked?

Now comes the question - Why did Kunal fall for Nandini when he was happily married to Mauli? Or, was he? I think their marriage was unrealistically perfect, even for a reel couple. Maybe it was perfect for Mauli. But it wasn't for Kunal, even though he thought it was. He was so in awe of Mauli that he made her idea of a perfect marriage his. I always found him a little too happy and chirpy about everything when he was with Mauli. Also, he was over-the-top in declaring his love for her and did it all the time in public too, which was kind of annoying, and also felt as if he was telling it to himself more than anyone else. He didn't share any common interests with Mauli. I'm married and I know for sure that if all I could talk to my husband was about romance, our son, and finances, I'd go crazy. I believe that a marriage should have the right mix of similarity and differences. Kunal and Mauli were too different to be life partners. The spark stayed for sometime, but wasn't meant to be a lifelong partnership. Yes, they definitely shared a bond and planned a future together. And yes, Kunal didn't live up to his end of the commitment. But did he even know that he wasn't really happy with Mauli? If he did, maybe he would've ended his marriage first, and then thought about being with someone else. But he didn't have the time, as his feelings for Nandini unraveled even before he could realize what was happening. When Kunal met Nandini, he saw what he was missing out, and eventually realized that he was married to the wrong person. A homely saree-clad woman who cooks well and shares many of his interests is his lady love. So? This doesn't mean that he is against independent women, women who don't wear sarees, or women who can't cook. He always supported Mauli and he did so genuinely, but deep inside, he wanted someone who could spend more time with him and discuss common interests. He never complained about not getting all that, but it was there in him, and without him realizing, Nandini entered in the form of everything that was missing from his life, and only then he knew. Is it wrong for a woman to voluntarily be a homemaker; isn't she as strong and significant as a salaried woman? And is it wrong for a man to fall for such a woman?

The manner in which the entire incident happened was ugly, but Kunal and Mauli would've parted ways eventually anyway, when Kunal would realize the truth of his marriage. Nandini coming into their lives was more like a catalyst.

Coming back to the characters...

Kunal and Nandini are grey, and to me, are the most relatable ones. They're real people with good hearts, but bad timing. Everything is getting ugly, including Kunal's behavior towards Mauli. It's not right, I agree. KuNan are and will continue to pay the price for it, together or apart. But if their love triumphs and Mauli moves on happily with her life (and child), I think KuNan deserve to get their happiness too. All this shouldn't have been for nothing.

Mauli was too white for me. She was put on this pedestal and almost all the viewers have been worshiping her. When Mauli does something good, KuNan automatically become scum. When Kunal or Nandini do something good, they become dirtier scum because they cheated Mauli, so nothing good they do matters, and Mauli somehow becomes even greater in the eyes of the viewers. I am glad to see Mauli's human side, desperate to get her husband back and blaming Nandini more than Kunal, because that brings some reality to her character. But, that doesn't undo the fact that the makers spent too much time in painting her white while simultaneously painting KuNan grey. Making Mauli grey now isn't going to matter anymore because KuNan haters will continue to hate them and love Mauli. Anything "wrong" that Mauli does from now on will always be weighed against KuNan's mistake, and whatever that wrong thing is, viewers will find a way to say that KuNan is worse.

I do not know why the three main characters were portrayed so differently, but it gave me a chance to see a disturbing truth about people in general. As long as characters remain 100 percent good or bad, they are acceptable. But grey characters are not, because people cannot digest the fact that a woman who falls in love with her friend's husband can sacrifice her love for that same friend. People cannot accept the fact that both these traits are equally real. They want to label the woman as bad, so any good she does is misinterpreted and twisted. When a married man falls for someone, he too becomes this evil being who can never do right. Adultery becomes the ultimate crime and nothing else matters.

And this is something I have seen in real life too. Speaks a lot about the society we live in. That's why people prefer to stay in loveless marriages rather than breaking free and taking a second chance. They try so hard to make marriages work that they forget themselves. And to me, that's not a life worth living. I do not agree with everything KuNan have done, but I am truly proud of them for owning their love.
Edited by JoonBai - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

4.1k

Users

23

Likes

354

Frequent Posters

llMinHoll thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
I didn't read the full topic as I know it contains all the baseless justification that have been repeated many times by DD and SA fans.

I'm a fan of DD myself and since her first scene on telly (DMG) but I don't support her actions or character in Silsila. It's poorly written and Nandani is selfish and tbh it's quite disgusting and puke worthy how their so called love doesn't get past dressing up and blushing.

Kunal there's nothing you can say about him; he can love or lust all he likes but he needs to stop being such a jerk and heartless p*ick.
Migraine thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
Wow. 1st such a mesmerising title. 2nd such a shorttt post?
Whoever would read this full hats off to them
But troll alert from my side. 🤣
Itna kaun padega bhai? Show hi itna pakau boring hai rofl
shamil thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#4
TM you can continue writing essays after essays justifying Kunan but the truth remains that majority of the viewers understand that these two are responsible for breaking a woman.
Pls don't give us gyan on nandu's sacrifices. Her promises always seem to have an expiry date which is less than 24 hours.
She fell in love with him fully knowing he was mauli's husband. So u can't just ignore the mauli factor.
Don't know about real lives but in reel life we want to see justice for mauli and these two need to suffer.

People who have done similar kaands in life might agree with ur views , we unfortunately can never feel u make sense abt Kunan being all goody goody.and genuine
sweet_aditi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
Ohk..
Sorry i dont agree with you..
Kunal is as***** jerk and Nandini is backstabber.
Having said that i just wish no one should get friend like Nandini and husband like Kunal in real life.

As you said if Nandini has suffered marrital abuse then whatever Mauli is suffering is nowhere less.

If u have suffered that is also because of your own wrong decision you wont get license to behave in a same with way to others.

441597 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6
A lot of points you've mentioned are valid.
While I despise Kunal and Nandini for their thoughtlessness towards Mauli, it certainly does not make them worse than a hell-monster like Rajdeep. This has been a source of many stormy arguments in the forum.
akashnanda thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#7
Dear kunan lover ..sry couldn't read it full but the line ..mauli s too white caught my attention..here I m talking about her character not her complexion ...just like mauli are we not independent woman who r happily married n does everything in our house ..manage both profession n home...after doing all the chores I still manage my daughter her studies n extra classes everything by myself like a superwoman ..don't we help our friend when she s in pain ? How come d character s unreal ..many women in India r just like mauli ...who manage both work n home without d help of anyone..my husband has never touched my gal's books projects anything ..everything s handled by me alone ..
For me nandini s unreal ..how come a person like nandhini chart her bestie..in dis way..we saw mauli in bad condition in front of mauli but all nandhini cares s about Kunal love n dinner date getting ready..she was on abusive realtionship for seven years so push someone to that pain for their entire life ...she has move on coz the great kunan s in love n kuanl ordered ...she can't coz she has given her life in his hands but this bas***d destroyed it in a minute...n u find dat character real n connectable..great keep it up ..m not even able to write anymore it gives so much pain to me when I write about these two ..killed a beautiful love full soul for their so called pyaar..ab laash bachi hai ek fin nandini n Kunal would bhi kha lenge ...
Migraine thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: llMinHoll

I didn't read the full topic as I know it contains all the baseless justification that have been repeated many times by DD and SA fans.

I'm a fan of DD myself and since her first scene on telly (DMG) but I don't support her actions or character in Silsila. It's poorly written and Nandani is selfish and tbh it's quite disgusting and puke worthy how their so called love doesn't get past dressing up and blushing.

Kunal there's nothing you can say about him; he can love or lust all he likes but he needs to stop being such a jerk and heartless p*ick.

Yes. Even i didn't read this kundini chanting post. Itna patience kiske pas hai? That too on delusional things. By repeating same delusion things don't become fact right?
Even me as a dd fan I don't get how can dd take up on this role. It's such a dimwit character with worst possible show.
Shakti? He was an okay actor but now he is below average who ran out of expressions and as overrated as dd. 🥱
looseseal thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#9
Okay first thing first i didnt read the entire post so forgive me if i say sth thats not what TM said.
I hate KuNan from the day they romanced in Mauli's house during ganesh chaturthi (i think). They found no other place to do their ras leela? Nandini had so little thought about her so called friendship and Kunal so little about his wif. That episode showed these two not only never loved Mouli but they never even cared for her, forget respect.

But also i want to ask question toall those saying MauNal marriage was too perfect thats why Kunal left...ugh how is KuNan roman any more realistic than MauNal marriage? I mean all KuNan does is go on dates. Which part of theoir romance is realistic? Atleast MauNal happy marriage made sense, two succesful people, seemingly in love each other in financial and enmotional stable relationship are happy...whats so crazy about it? How can you see that as unrealistic but see divine love between abuse victim who is still being turtoredo by the abuser, and her bffs hubby because tjey keep going on dates after dates as realistic?

And your argument that nandini has haq on happiness because she was abused for 7 years...thats just f**ked up. She does deserve to be happy but she doesnt get the license to romance a married man and then turn around and demand forgiveness.


Yezabel thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#10
Wow love your words. Exactly my thoughts! But few people will understand you and will reply without mocking you just bc they dont like the story. Yes they will continue to hate everything what Kunal and Nandini are doing. Agree they put Mauli on a pedestal even when she would make something evil they will continue to whorship her.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".