Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1k

Users

9

Likes

29

Frequent Posters

chirpyhapibird thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: aaliya14

Main part of rant is in red. So feel free to skip if you want.

So i don't watch the show regularly because i hate the whole " other woman" concept. I hated the movie
'Bajirao mastani' for the same reason but after the uproar on twitter against Kunal and Nandini i wanted to give my two cents.

First of all i am not justifying their act or EMA's in general. I hate what mauli's condition has come too and i hate Kunal and Nandini for doing this to her BUT why is most uproar against Nandin? Why is the opinion so biased with Kunal. Just because you like how mauli and Kunal look together?
Infact i think Kunal is more at fault because i believe Nandini is psychologically unstable and who wouldn't be after living with Rajdeep? I feel like even if she had gotten kidnapped and the guy cared for her she'd develop stockholm syndrome. Does that make her the victim or act justified? No!

Coming to Kunal , the perfectly sane man who should have had enough wit being a doctor to not make his wife go through the humiliation she had to. If he was so " in love" with Nandini he should have had the decency to divorce Mauli first.

And even when psycholocally unstable Nandini came to sense and decided to leave, Kunal stopped her with some melodrama knowing how emotional and vulnerable she is.

So, both are at fault. In my opinion kunal more than Nandini.

P.s: i hate what Kunal and Nandini did, but just for the record the society had NO RIGHT to cover her face with tar.



Kunal 100 times more responsible.
Nandu even in unstable state tried to leave the city.
Kunal actually used Nandu.
arshi_asya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: chirpyhapibird


Kunal 100 times more responsible.
Nandu even in unstable state tried to leave the city.
Kunal actually used Nandu.


Yeah right. 😆

She could try leaving city in unstable state, she could have sex in unstable state, she could even murder someone in unstable state & still be blamed less because she was in unstable state & the victim was at fault to even come in touch with her. As per this show, she will always be in unstable state & do everything because she suffered an abusive relationship for 7 years which technically should have made her fear relationships & man completely with such intimate relations. Sex should have been a big no for a woman who lost her child in such terrible ways. (Trauma is very real).
Kunal used Nandu & Nandu was a tissue paper who couldn't even speak or talk to him in skeptical manner.

All she couldn't do was just think about a friend in her unstable state. Someone give me tissues, my eyes are getting welled up with laughing. 😆
chirpyhapibird thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: arshi_asya


Yeah right. 😆

She could try leaving city in unstable state, she could have sex in unstable state, she could even murder someone in unstable state & still be blamed less because she was in unstable state & the victim was at fault to even come in touch with her. As per this show, she will always be in unstable state & do everything because she suffered an abusive relationship for 7 years which technically should have made her fear relationships & man completely with such intimate relations. Sex should have been a big no for a woman who lost her child in such terrible ways. (Trauma is very real).
Kunal used Nandu & Nandu was a tissue paper who couldn't even speak or talk to him in skeptical manner.

All she couldn't do was just think about a friend in her unstable state. Someone give me tissues, my eyes are getting welled up with laughing. 😆

Its quite possible with an abused victim.
People behave in abnormal ways/all wrong ways.
When i see Nandini i feel she is psycho.

wow123 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#14
Well we are assuming that Nandini is unstable and its not shown in series.

Blame is on both Kunal n Nandini not because they fall in love but for their betrayal to Mauli.

Yesterday Mauli said in very simple that " tum kahi mahino se mujhe dhoka dete huye mere saath rehte rahe".

I know show is all about EMA but one thing which i don't like is getting betrayal from ur own ppl. So I m basically against that betrayal.

I think most of ppl don't want Kunal n Mauli unite ( both side of hater including)
shamil thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#15
I think the topic has been discussed umpteen times.
U just have to surf thru the previous pages to know that
By the way I am yet to find any Maunal Shippers after his khaand here.
Nobody is going "aww omg they lsizzling chemistry, hence they must get together " kind of emotion

But yes there are many Kunan shippers and Nandini fans mainly becoz its DD who is doing the role. I am sure there would have been no nandini lover if it were some other actress.
aaliya14 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: arshi_asya


Yeah right. 😆

She could try leaving city in unstable state, she could have sex in unstable state, she could even murder someone in unstable state & still be blamed less because she was in unstable state & the victim was at fault to even come in touch with her. As per this show, she will always be in unstable state & do everything because she suffered an abusive relationship for 7 years which technically should have made her fear relationships & man completely with such intimate relations. Sex should have been a big no for a woman who lost her child in such terrible ways. (Trauma is very real).
Kunal used Nandu & Nandu was a tissue paper who couldn't even speak or talk to him in skeptical manner.

All she couldn't do was just think about a friend in her unstable state. Someone give me tissues, my eyes are getting welled up with laughing. 😆

I think you haven't read about mentally unstable abuse victims. Thats why you are being so insensitive about the subject. I'm not justifying her cheating on mauli but her psychological state shouldn't be taken lightly. Her self reassurances and over the top shivering are symptoms of her disorder. Coming to your point why she didn't think leaving again. I think the writers have planned for that to happen. She needs a psychiatrist.
aaliya14 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: shamil

I think the topic has been discussed umpteen times.

U just have to surf thru the previous pages to know that
By the way I am yet to find any Maunal Shippers after his khaand here.
Nobody is going "aww omg they lsizzling chemistry, hence they must get together " kind of emotion

But yes there are many Kunan shippers and Nandini fans mainly becoz its DD who is doing the role. I am sure there would have been no nandini lover if it were some other actress.


Don't know what was wrong with her to take this role. There is not even one silver lining to the character.
arshi_asya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: aaliya14

I think you haven't read about mentally unstable abuse victims. Thats why you are being so insensitive about the subject. I'm not justifying her cheating on mauli but her psychological state shouldn't be taken lightly. Her self reassurances and over the top shivering are symptoms of her disorder. Coming to your point why she didn't think leaving again. I think the writers have planned for that to happen. She needs a psychiatrist.


Dear madam,
I have about 20 posts on this forum solely dedicated to psycho analysis of each character of this show especially Nanadini and the behavioral pattern associated with each of them. You must not be that active member here. One was made on this Saturday only with the title " Psychology lessons from SBRK". I have made a huge list of multiple personality disorders of Nandini that are overlapping thus making her a severe case who needs immediate psychiatric help.
Many have been doing that for months in this forum talking about all possible prospects of psychology that mist concern this show.
But makers aren't interested to discover that at all. Had they been interested, there would have been some discussion about it in the show. But no, makers just want to show juzzbat in the show that too solely for heart and not human brain.
All ITV can do is land a prospective psychological case directly in the mental asylum.
Safe to assume, ITV will never touch this subject in near future. So, the whole psychological brainstorming is useless for this show, since most audience as well as the writers of the show doesn't even understand clinical details of this subject except for one or two words thrown around very casually.
You are being too hopeful if you think psychological part will be dealt now. They didn't do it in the stage where only Nandini needed it after leaving that hell hole but now as per this track every character in the show needs that help considering the phase they are going in to clear out their heads and be a little clear and decisive about what they really want.

I am not being insensitive but it's funny how many are brainstorming here when makers clearly don't want to go that lane at all and rather choosing to go for simple way which involves hating the character for what they are. Even Kunal is a case who needs psychiatric help as well as Rajdeep and Mauli too. Going by that we can actually bring every character to almost same level of psychological studies. So, the lecture on senstivity was the last thing I needed here when clearly there has been no attempt by the makers to earn that for their characters.

Wanna see shows actually dealing with psychological aspects of a lead character-watch Bates Motel, the good doctor and so many english series which have actually dealt with them. ITV won't do that. Take my words.
arshi_asya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: chirpyhapibird

Its quite possible with an abused victim.
People behave in abnormal ways/all wrong ways.
When i see Nandini i feel she is psycho.


Definitely not a psycho. Doesn't even remotely fit that bill.
There is a whole list of personality disorders she has and that doesn't involve her being a psycho. Rajdeep would more clearly fit the bill of a psycho man.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".