Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

2.6k

Users

15

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

fazilat786 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
unfortunately Rano's attitude made me angry especially her anger toward BM. Rano has forgotton that if it was not for Bm guidance Ishaans marriage would not have lasted, Suhana was a rich pampered laadli daughter not a middle class girl that adjustment is huge but Suhana has managed, I know its difficult to get everyone to go on one track when u live in a joint family but there are times when compromises have to be made for the betterment in the long run. I hope not to long winded.
Fazilat😊
Somi thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: fazilat786

unfortunately Rano's attitude made me angry especially her anger toward BM. Rano has forgotton that if it was not for Bm guidance Ishaans marriage would not have lasted, Suhana was a rich pampered laadli daughter not a middle class girl that adjustment is huge but Suhana has managed, I know its difficult to get everyone to go on one track when u live in a joint family but there are times when compromises have to be made for the betterment in the long run. I hope not to long winded.
Fazilat😊


EXACTLY! if it wasn't for BM, Ishan would have been divorced a long time ago. I believe Rano never put herself in the position to be taken seriously. She let others make all the decisions... But if she now suddenly wants to be heard and is not, it's not really Suhana or BM's fault... They havent changed.. Rano has.. And if she now wants more say in matters, then that's something she should discuss with the adults of the house as a separate issue and not mix it in with Suhana's work issues..

Sorry if I offended anyone.. Been a silent member for a while - first time posting on this forum...
Edited by Somi - 13 years ago
iViews thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: zackey_boy

Rano bashing Suhana is not that important as compared to the last scene of the episode...Rano simply kept a point in front of Badi Maa which do have some weightage and this would probably tell why Rano is so mad at Suhana...

According to Rano, its time for Suhana to take her seriously.. Interestingly everyone is talkiing about a scenario where they question that would Rano would have acted the same way if Ishaan was doing a TV serial...In counter I have a question too- would Suhana have done the serial if Badi Maa said no ( for whatever reason)? I guess the answer is no because she takes Badi Maa's word seriously but that's not the same with Rano...

I guess the whole reason for Rano's anger is not related much to Suhana's job but more about her position in Kashyap's house...It should be Alok and Rano who should have the last say in matters involving Ishaan, Suhana or Ishika and by doing this I don't think would cause any kind of insult to Badi Maa.

This is the best analysis ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I read 👏👏
566912 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: zackey_boy

Rano bashing Suhana is not that important as compared to the last scene of the episode...Rano simply kept a point in front of Badi Maa which do have some weightage and this would probably tell why Rano is so mad at Suhana...

According to Rano, its time for Suhana to take her seriously.. Interestingly everyone is talkiing about a scenario where they question that would Rano would have acted the same way if Ishaan was doing a TV serial...In counter I have a question too- would Suhana have done the serial if Badi Maa said no ( for whatever reason)? I guess the answer is no because she takes Badi Maa's word seriously but that's not the same with Rano...

I guess the whole reason for Rano's anger is not related much to Suhana's job but more about her position in Kashyap's house...It should be Alok and Rano who should have the last say in matters involving Ishaan, Suhana or Ishika and by doing this I don't think would cause any kind of insult to Badi Maa.

I so loved your analysis... 👏👍🏼 a Perfect question to the situation 😊
Please come often to discuss... I like reading your posts😃
Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: zackey_boy

Rano bashing Suhana is not that important as compared to the last scene of the episode...Rano simply kept a point in front of Badi Maa which do have some weightage and this would probably tell why Rano is so mad at Suhana...

According to Rano, its time for Suhana to take her seriously.. Interestingly everyone is talkiing about a scenario where they question that would Rano would have acted the same way if Ishaan was doing a TV serial...In counter I have a question too- would Suhana have done the serial if Badi Maa said no ( for whatever reason)? I guess the answer is no because she takes Badi Maa's word seriously but that's not the same with Rano...

I guess the whole reason for Rano's anger is not related much to Suhana's job but more about her position in Kashyap's house...It should be Alok and Rano who should have the last say in matters involving Ishaan, Suhana or Ishika and by doing this I don't think would cause any kind of insult to Badi Maa.

first of all great analysis and I do agree with you to some extent, I do agree that it is time that Rano and BM share responsibilities

But my question is that IF ultimately Rano does have a problem with BM then why did she let her be the family's pillar for all these years. From the start we have seen that Rano has always said to BM, that BM is better at handling the family than she is, Rano has always accepted that so why should she change her mind now?? I know that she is Ishan's mom and Suhana's MIL and she does have a bigger right to them than BM but if she was so bothered with it then why give BM the authority to have a say in her kids lives?? Rano should have made a clar point in the beginning that BM can handle everything but not her children's lives.

This may be the BM-Suhana shipper in me saying this but of the biggest reasons for me watching this show is BM-Suhana's relationship. First of all Suhana listens to BM because BM is the only one who understood her apart from Ishan, Ishan and BM (and to some extent Radha bua) are the only ones who saw Suhana's innocence and naive nature rather than judging her as a spoilt brat that everyone else assumed her to be, even Rano is guilty of this. Also I agree with Suhana when she said that this time she cannot forget this, Rano not only insulted herself BUT Suhana as well. I've always said this that Suhana should not quit her job that she is good at just because she has a complain box for a MIL




What I don't understand is that the main culprit is that loser Elesh yet NO ONE says anything to him and everyone is on a blaming spree for Suhana (THANK GOD Alok recognized that in Mondays episode)
Edited by Tani91 - 13 years ago
MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Tani91

first of all great analysis and I do agree with you to some extent


But my question is that IF ultimately Rano does have a problem with BM then why did she let her be the family's pillar for all these years. From the start we have seen that Rano has always said to B, that BM is better at handling the family than she is, Rano has always accepted that so why should she change her mind now?? I know that she is Ishan's mom and Suhana's MIL and she does have a bigger right to them than BM but if she was so bothered with it then why give BM the authority to have a say in her kids lives?? Rano should have made a clar point in the beginning that BM can handle everything but not her children's lives. I don't think Rano has ever explicitly said she is fine with BM handling everything. Actually, I think in all the earlier years Rano has been accepting of BM's decisions because even she finds the decisions acceptable. But now that she is against them, she is voicing her opinions out. Also, Rano might have let herself be sidelined many times int he beginning because she probably also felt guilt due to BM's situation concerning BP and so let her have a far greater role in the household and thus undermining hers as a compensation for BM's loss. Even though the compensation is not something Rano should or had to fill but she did to make BM feel like this is her home.

This may be the BM-Suhana shipper in me saying this but of the biggest reasons for me watching this show is BM-Suhana's relationship. First of all Suhana listens to BM because BM is the only one who understood her apart from Ishan, Ishan and BM (and to some extent Radha bua) are the only ones who saw Suhana's innocence and naive nature rather than judging her as a spoilt brat that everyone else assumed her to be, even Rano is guilty of this.

I'm not as fond of BM...she may have shown understanding in the past but right now she kinda needs to back off a little in only the issue of letting Rano make decisions too. However, I also agree with you below...Ilesh is the main culprit and the Kashyaps should recognize that more than anything at this point because he was the start of the mess.


What I don't understand is that the main culprit is that loser Elesh yet NO ONE says anything to him and everyone is on a blaming spree for Suhana (THANK GOD Alok recognized that in Mondays episode)

x.Henna.x thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
abhi786 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: venture

To add on the above points ...if Panna would be in Suhana,s place and her MIL and Roanak would have problem with her working in a serial ...I bet BM would have said " do as your MIL and husband says" ...

I have a lot of respect for BM , she is a remarkable person but her partiality towards Ilaish made him the guy he is today, and partiality towards Suhana causing rift between not only Rano but also Disha and Rajni, Suhana is not fault at this, she came with the blank mind and what is being written by BM stays there.



Sheema di, BM will tell to panna listen to your saas and husband... But here circumstances are different... All kashyaps know that how is Panna relationship with her saas... BM also know, only rounak is supporting her..., She taunts panna and kashyaps .. So BM want panna to listen to her husband and saas.. Going against their wishes may create rift between rounak and panna itself, where her saas taunts her and rounak simply can't support her wife allways.. Just like yesterday rano scholded ishaan for supoorting suhana, evn though that time all family members were present there...

There will be no other family members to supoort panna and rounak...BM from the beginning saying take care of your saas, as she wants panna to get the love and respect,from her saas, as panna can't share every problem with them... BM wants panna and her saas relationship becomes maa-beti and panna gets all motherly love from her saas..


But in suhana case it is different, none of the kashyaps have problem with suhana working... Even though Ishaan and Rano against it...BM knows Ishaan allways wants suhana happiness.. Ishaan surely understand and support his wife... BM later has clearly asked ishaan, IS he having a problem with suhana's job... Ishaan told he doesn't... I am sure, if ishaan told, he is unhappy to BM and suhana, surely suhana would have stopped working...Instead ishaan told he is happy, as suhana is enjoying her work and he want suhana to get fame and happy for her..

BM knows ishaan very well, she is the one who stopped RB and told ishaan will win suhana's heart.. Ishaan supported suhana and is happy with her even though, knowing suhana doesn't like him ..How can he stop supporting or can't see her happiness..

As far as Rano is concerned, rano has accepted her mistake with BM, when she was wrong objecting her decision for sending ishaan.. Rano said sorry to BM and told she was right... Rano again did said sorry to her daughter ishika...Rano will react in the spurt of moment without thinking and later appolising everyone... So BM thought this time also Rano will understand after some time and support suhana...

Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#20
I didn't want to quote because it might get confusing😆

Ekta- I don't know why but I do remember in one of the very first episodes of SGP they did show that BM was doing some expense report or what not and Rano playfully said that she can never handle situations like BM does. I do agree that BM is not perfect and yes she does need to give Rano the decision with her kids lives...but this situation is not entirely Rano's to have a say in. Ishan and Suhana are adults and they can take their own decisions which they did, but Rano has a problem with it and it is a legitimate problem, it's not a silly one that's why the family is on polarizing ends of it. I do think that everyone involved (Suhana,Rano,Ishan and BM mostly) are justified with what they are doing, it is just circumstances that are wrong. But SBS thing that will show Rano forgetting the whole things just because she got gifts is not sitting with me🤢


I do like that they are showing that BM's way of handling is not the perfect way and I like that they're showing two sides of the coin rather than justifying and glorifying one while demeaning the other. Yes Rano is right in saying that BM ins spoiling Suhana because she is and she always has.


Sachi di - Rano distanced herself from those type of decision making Everyone knows that Rano is sentimental and that is not a good trait to have while running a huge family like Kashyaps everyone including Rano understood that and hence she was not involved in the major decision making of the family
Edited by Tani91 - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".