Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

2.6k

Users

15

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

Luv4games thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21
i think what rano fails to understand is that suhana is close to Bm and listens to her not because of authority or because BM forces her or orders her but because bm guides her...she is more like a mentor to her...and seriously who would wanna be like rano...she should have voiced her opinion long ago not now...and not this way in a nice way so that everyone hears it...would she also get mad if suhana listens to her dad...rano didnt once hear what suhana wants or ask her...she just ordered her to leave...has bm ever done that...she never put her decision on suhana...she just guided her which is what she needed...and yah suhana would have said no if bm said so not because she is scared of bm but because she would know there is a logic behind it and bm would also explain it nicely...but rano has no logic...she is just creating problems...she cant claim her authority by sacrificing suhana's career...
Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Luv4games

i think what rano fails to understand is that suhana is close to Bm and listens to her not because of authority or because BM forces her or orders her but because bm guides her...she is more like a mentor to her...and seriously who would wanna be like rano...she should have voiced her opinion long ago not now...and not this way in a nice way so that everyone hears it...would she also get mad if suhana listens to her dad...rano didnt once hear what suhana wants or ask her...she just ordered her to leave...has bm ever done that...she never put her decision on suhana...she just guided her which is what she needed...and yah suhana would have said no if bm said so not because she is scared of bm but because she would know there is a logic behind it and bm would also explain it nicely...but rano has no logic...she is just creating problems...she cant claim her authority by sacrificing suhana's career...

exactly...Suhana listens to BM because BM understands her and is a mother figure. Rano is her MIL while there is nothing wrong with that but Suhana being the motherless girl she is sees her mother in BM not Rano again because BM took the initiative to understand Suhana, to love her as her daughter rather than her bahu

Totally agree if BM would have said no then there would be an explanation behind it and Suhana would have supported it full heatedly. Rano had said no BEFORE all of this media circus occurred, she always had a problem with Suhana working without having a justified cause of why. Rano's reaction now is her anger build up to this point.

Also I didn't like the way she was shunning Suhana when Suhana was calmly telling her that she would quit😡 and the things she said to Ishan too. I understand that was a spur of the moment of thing but still words hurt
Edited by Tani91 - 13 years ago
MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: abhi786



Sheema di, BM will tell to panna listen to your saas and husband... But here circumstances are different... All kashyaps know that how is Panna relationship with her saas... BM also know, only rounak is supporting her..., She taunts panna and kashyaps .. So BM want panna to listen to her husband and saas.. Going against their wishes may create rift between rounak and panna itself, where her saas taunts her and rounak simply can't support her wife allways.. Just like yesterday rano scholded ishaan for supoorting suhana, evn though that time all family members were present there...

There will be no other family members to supoort panna and rounak...BM from the beginning saying take care of your saas, as she wants panna to get the love and respect,from her saas, as panna can't share every problem with them... BM wants panna and her saas relationship becomes maa-beti and panna gets all motherly love from her saas..


But in suhana case it is different, none of the kashyaps have problem with suhana working... Even though Ishaan and Rano against it...BM knows Ishaan allways wants suhana happiness.. Ishaan surely understand and support his wife... BM later has clearly asked ishaan, IS he having a problem with suhana's job... Ishaan told he doesn't... I am sure, if ishaan told, he is unhappy to BM and suhana, surely suhana would have stopped working...Instead ishaan told he is happy, as suhana is enjoying her work and he want suhana to get fame and happy for her..

BM knows ishaan very well, she is the one who stopped RB and told ishaan will win suhana's heart.. Ishaan supported suhana and is happy with her even though, knowing suhana doesn't like him ..How can he stop supporting or can't see her happiness..

As far as Rano is concerned, rano has accepted her mistake with BM, when she was wrong objecting her decision for sending ishaan.. Rano said sorry to BM and told she was right... Rano again did said sorry to her daughter ishika...Rano will react in the spurt of moment without thinking and later appolising everyone... So BM thought this time also Rano will understand after some time and support suhana...



@ pink: Rano certainly does acts in the spur of the moment and usually those actions are the wrong ones to take because she is highly emotional, unstable, and having a full-on volcanic outburst. She doesn't think how to properly act. But by the time she reaches this bursting point, it's usually because when she was raising her objections everyone was sidelining her and acting as if her opinions were trivial. In a way, Kashyaps let her reach that point. I want to point out that everytime Rano is having her outbursts is usually when she feels caved in by everyone else. Everyone's sticking their fingers at her, chiding her, there is not a single voice supporting her (particularly the ones that matters, ie Alok's)...all this leaves her insecure and makes her lash out (her repeated cries of, "Kya main itni buri hoon?" "Haan, haan, main sab ki nazron main buri hoon." etc etc). She gets so insecure and keeps trying to fight for rights...in the end when she has calmed down greatly and realizes that despite her outbursts no one is still on her side, she ends up giving in and saying, "Yes, I was the one wrong and BM was right." For her, I think, continuing to argue against the majority would result in nothing for her so that's why I think she will calm down and support BM and Suhana again.

But this is just dumb since the issue never gets resolved. In future, Rano will again have another issue but the basic reason will be the same: Rano wants to make certain decisions herself.
MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Tani91

I didn't want to quote because it might get confusing😆


Ekta- I don't know why but I do remember in one of the very first episodes of SGP they did show that BM was doing some expense report or what not and Rano playfully said that she can never handle situations like BM does. I do agree that BM is not perfect and yes she does need to give Rano the decision with her kids lives...but this situation is not entirely Rano's to have a say in. Ishan and Suhana are adults and they can take their own decisions which they did, but Rano has a problem with it and it is a legitimate problem, it's not a silly one that's why the family is on polarizing ends of it. I do think that everyone involved (Suhana,Rano,Ishan and BM mostly) are justified with what they are doing, it is just circumstances that are wrong. But SBS thing that will show Rano forgetting the whole things just because she got gifts is not sitting with me🤢

With this post, I am now a little confused on what your stance exactly is cause it seemed like earlier you were supporting BM more, right? 😆


I do like that they are showing that BM's way of handling is not the perfect way and I like that they're showing two sides of the coin rather than justifying and glorifying one while demeaning the other. Yes Rano is right in saying that BM ins spoiling Suhana because she is and she always has.

Even I don't mind them showing that BM's way of handling things isn't perfect. But then they also have to show that even BM realizes that...otherwise it seems BM is thinking only along her own ways and bending truth to her will, thus maligning her character rather than showing her as a normal human being.


Sachi di - Rano distanced herself from those type of decision making Everyone knows that Rano is sentimental and that is not a good trait to have while running a huge family like Kashyaps everyone including Rano understood that and hence she was not involved in the major decision making of the family

I know this is directed at Sachi but I want to say that I don't think Rano had issue of BM handling household technicalities...but there are very specific things that Rano is asking to being involved in but isn't getting it.

MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Luv4games

i think what rano fails to understand is that suhana is close to Bm and listens to her not because of authority or because BM forces her or orders her but because bm guides her...she is more like a mentor to her...and seriously who would wanna be like rano...she should have voiced her opinion long ago not now...and not this way in a nice way so that everyone hears it...would she also get mad if suhana listens to her dad...rano didnt once hear what suhana wants or ask her...she just ordered her to leave...has bm ever done that...she never put her decision on suhana...she just guided her which is what she needed...and yah suhana would have said no if bm said so not because she is scared of bm but because she would know there is a logic behind it and bm would also explain it nicely...but rano has no logic...she is just creating problems...she cant claim her authority by sacrificing suhana's career...



Let's see if I have this correctly...Rano doesn't Suhana to work because of the nature of the job and the feeling that it might distance Suhana from Ishaan, right? Sorry, I didn't watch those episode so I'm not sure if that was what happened. So I'm basing things on this assumption. You're right, this isn't good justification. Suhana also does tend to see BM more as motherly figure than Rano and hence more liable to follow BM. But I still think Rano shouldn't be undermined as she is legally Suhana's MIL, a more direct relationship than BM's. So Rano should be taken into consideration by Suhana as well, whether right or wrong. Since Rano's reasoning was wrong, Suhana should be the one talking it out with Rano and telling her why she wants to work, etc, etc.
Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
Ekta I do support BM more mainly because Rano's way of handling the situation isnt right at all the way she lashed out at Suhana and Ishan thats my biggest problem with this whole ordeal. I know Rano is right but her way of showing it is wrong
MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Tani91

Ekta I do support BM more mainly because Rano's way of handling the situation isnt right at all the way she lashed out at Suhana and Ishan thats my biggest problem with this whole ordeal. I know Rano is right but her way of showing it is wrong


Then I agree with you. 😉 😆
Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#28
hahaha sorry I confused you before

I agree with both Suhana and Rano, I just dont agree with Rano's methods
Luv4games thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: MadameX



Let's see if I have this correctly...Rano doesn't Suhana to work because of the nature of the job and the feeling that it might distance Suhana from Ishaan, right? Sorry, I didn't watch those episode so I'm not sure if that was what happened. So I'm basing things on this assumption. You're right, this isn't good justification. Suhana also does tend to see BM more as motherly figure than Rano and hence more liable to follow BM. But I still think Rano shouldn't be undermined as she is legally Suhana's MIL, a more direct relationship than BM's. So Rano should be taken into consideration by Suhana as well, whether right or wrong. Since Rano's reasoning was wrong, Suhana should be the one talking it out with Rano and telling her why she wants to work, etc, etc.


just because rano is suhana's mother in law, it does not give her the right to want to dictate suhana's life...and suhana does not have to discuss anything with her because she is an adult...but still that kind of respect cannot be demanded but you have to gain it...instead of yelling and ordering suhana around maybe rano should try to have a motherly discussion with her like bm...rano and suhana will never have the relationship that rano and bm have...suhana didnt have a mother growing up but she found that mother in bm...no matter what rano does she will never get to that status and shouldnt even try...she will never be able to give suhana motherly love because she will be partial with her and ishaan while it is not the same with bm...and they did discuss the movie thing and the fact that rano didnt like it but at the end suhana is passionate about acting and wants to do it...so why should she stop because rano is not happy...rano's life has passed her but suhana is young and needs more in life...rano has no choice but to accept this truth...and maybe the reason nobody listens to her is because she always does stuff the wrong way...
shiuli84 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
hi guys!
its nice to see everyone debate about rano and BM...but no one has actually answered/discussed the actual post i had written...in relation to the exact episode of holi...not what happened afterwards...please discuss the points i mentioned too 😉

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".