mayank and gunjan how they are realated...??? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

120

Views

9k

Users

12

Likes

101

Frequent Posters

payalgarg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: sadesi

Ok this is nuts. The two kids are not related by blood. Whats the big deal? Its no different than two brothers marrying two sisters. My dad and his brother are married to mom and her sister. Gunjan and Myank r not cousins. Seema is not shyl sis. Gosh u guys need to put this topic to rest! As long as you are not related by blood its ok to get hitched by hindu rites!



were ur dad ur chacha and ur mom and ur maasi were all from same extended family?
looks like two brothers marrying two sisters and two people marrying within an extended family is just the same for you...this is actually what u call nuts...
Edited by payalgarg - 12 years ago
videosearcher thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: payalgarg



this is a hindu family story and not a muslim family story(with no offence to the religion) where u can marry with anybody within a family except ur own BLOOD ie...ur own brother...

ACTUALLY U ARE CONFUSING THE THREAD OWNER MIXING TRADITIONS OF TWO DIFFERENT RELIGIONS.

ITS VERY SIMPLE.GUNJAN IS A PART OF THE EXTENDED FAMILY ACCORDING TO HINDU CUSTOMS AND NOT FROM A DIFFERENT FAMILY

had it been real life Shail would have not allowed gunjan to do so but the grounds would have been completely different from the ones she gave in the show. It would have been on the grounds of gunjan being family and by way mayank's cousin and not because mayank is engaged or whatever...


PLEASE GET IT STARIGHT I am not Mixing any two religions. ITS Very Simple That all Hindu families allow Bua Bhitiji ( That is a girl & her bro's daughter(Niece) getting married into a same family. So I dont understand how Mayank & Gunjan became cousins.
Just Imagine
Had Shail been the younger sister of Sneha and Gunjan was born before Shail Got married and Had Dayal been the youngest Bro and Mayank been already born before Dayal's Marriege was even fixed with Shail, so you would have still called Mayank & Gunjan Cousins???? ] So just on the Day Dayal & Shail's marriage would have taken place , their Toddler neices & nephews would have become cousins ???????????

sadesi thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
In the Ramayan Ram's brother got married to Sita's sister...um is that also nuts? Or arent they hindu enough for you Payalgarg...i mean seriously, shyl niece is not from their extended family she was just staying there til her dad sort his work out. So how is that being unhindu like? Not like their extended family ever treated her like family anyways. This is the 21st century they been doing it since the days of the Ramayan, get over it already. Steups.
Edited by sadesi - 12 years ago
Peacefulmind thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
^^yeah

Ramayana is perfect... Two brothers can marry two sisters...


Lol

its according to culture...

So better don't bring Ramayana ...here as u don't know how the relations are related...
@karthika

its shyl and sneha are own sisters...

Shyl is married to dayal...
So she becomes mother to mayank...

And rachna and mayank will be brother and sister ...

Sneha being shyl sister she will become mother to mayank...

So gunjan and mayank will be cousins brother and sister...

So cousin brother and sister can't marry dear...

Only thing here is they are not blood related... But their relation is brother and sister...

Peacefulmind thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: sadesi

In the Ramayan Ram's brother got married to Sita's sister...um is that also nuts? Or arent they hindu enough for you Payalgarg...i mean seriously, shyl niece is not from their extended family she was just staying there til her dad sort his work out. So how is that being unhindu like? Not like their extended family ever treated her like family anyways. This is the 21st century they been doing it since the days of the Ramayan, get over it already. Steups.



in Hindu culture we can marry ...ram married sita...

And lakshman married urmila...
Its according to Hindu custom...
videosearcher thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: jeannierocks

^^yeah

Ramayana is perfect... Two brothers can marry two sisters...


Lol

its according to culture...

So better don't bring Ramayana ...here as u don't know how the relations are related...
@karthika

its shyl and sneha are own sisters...

Shyl is married to dayal...
So she becomes mother to mayank...

And rachna and mayank will be brother and sister ...

Sneha being shyl sister she will become mother to mayank...

So gunjan and mayank will be cousins brother and sister...

So cousin brother and sister can't marry dear...

Only thing here is they are not blood related... But their relation is brother and sister...

I didnt Understand how did Shail Become mother to Mayank??? How did Sneha Become Mother to Mayank???
payalgarg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: videosearcher


just for the sake of supporting something being shown in the show you can do so much imagination lekin agar reality mein loge karne lage to hindu dharm aur islam mein koi fark nahi rahega.SIRF SAGE BHAI KO BAKSHO BAAKI SABKE LIYE IMAGINE KARO.MAAF KARO,HINDU DHARM AAPKE IMAGINATION SE NAHI RISHTO SE CHALTA HAIN

Peacefulmind thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
Guys its better not to bring Muslim religion in this topic...

As its Hindu family drama...

So mayank and gunjan relation is questionable...

?


So better stick to topic... Not to compare two religions...

payalgarg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: sadesi

In the Ramayan Ram's brother got married to Sita's sister...um is that also nuts? Or arent they hindu enough for you Payalgarg...i mean seriously, shyl niece is not from their extended family she was just staying there til her dad sort his work out. So how is that being unhindu like? Not like their extended family ever treated her like family anyways. This is the 21st century they been doing it since the days of the Ramayan, get over it already. Steups.


SEEMS U ARE AN ILLETERATE PERSON AND DO NOT UNDERSTAND ENGLISH WELL SO EVEN AFTER GETTING A REPLY ON THE PREVIOUS POST U BROUGHT EXACTLY THE SAME QUESTION.

I HAVE NOT READ ANYWHERE THAT RAM,LAXMAN,SITA AND URMILA WERE ALL A BIG PART OFN EXTENDED FAMILY AND BY WAY COUSINS OR COUSIN'S COUSINS TO EACH OTHER.MAYBE SADESI WILL HAS WRITTEN A DIFFERENT RAMAYAN🤣


SEE SADESI AND OTHERS,I KNOW MOST OF U ARE RESIDING OUTSIDE INDIA AND HAVE BECOME HALF ANGREZ.THIS TOPIC WAS RAISED BEFORE ALSO AND I HAD MANY SUPPORTERS.MOST OF THEM LIVING WERE LIVING IN INDIA AND KNEW THERE CUSTOMS WELL.

SO THEY DECIDED TO OPT OUT OF THE SHOW.

BUT I AM STILL HERE AS I LOVE THE SHOW BECAUSE OF THE GIRLS IN THE SHOW.I LIKE THEIR TOGETHERNESS.BUT I AM NOT THE KIND TO JUST BLINDLY SUPPORT BECAUSE IT IS BEING SHOWN ON T.V. A LOT OF PEOPLE DO THAT

SO LET ME MAKE IT CLEAR-IF 10 PEOPLE HERE WILL TRY TO SUPPORT AN OUT OF INDIA IMAGINARY HINDU CUSTOM 100 TIMES JUST BECAUSE IT IS BEING SHOWN IN A SHOW,IT WILL NOT BECOME A NEW CUSTOM...

INDIA FORUM IS THE MOST IMPORTANT MEDIUM FOR CVS TO KNOW WHAT THE VIEWERS THINK.WE TALKED ABOUT AKASH AND HE WAS HERE,WE TALKED ABOUT BRANDON'S ABSENCE IN DIYA AUR BATI HUM AND WE SAW HIM IN FEW DAYS.BUT THIS IS THE THIRD TIME THIS TOPIC IS RAISED AND THEY NEVER EVEN COMMENT A BIT.THAT SHOWS THEY KNOW THEY HAVE MADE A BLUNDER WHICH CANT BE REPAIRED SO BETTER STAY MUM ON IT

ENJOY THE SHOW BUT ITNA NAHI KI SACH AUR KALPANA MEIN FARK BHOOL JAAO

Edited by payalgarg - 12 years ago
Peacefulmind thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: videosearcher


</div>
<div>
I didnt Understand how did Shail Become mother to Mayank??? How did Sneha Become Mother to Mayank???



yes in Hindusim...
My moms sister will be my mother... And i will be calling her as mausiji(its small mom)
so if shyl is thayiji (big mom)
than shyl sister is(small mom)
to mayank...


So gunjan mom is actually a mausiji aka mother to mayank...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".