Strange Episode to say the least:Mod's Note PG10

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

jini

@jini

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#101

Originally posted by: sonya85

A very nice analysis; detailed and observant. But in ranvirs defence he has always hidden his pain for the sake of his family, especially Ragini. This can even be seen in the jail track when Ragini came to see him. He never wants to see ragini in pain, and he understands that ragini's happiness depends on his. From what I observed, he was trying to hold back alot of tears and pain. As for the wink, I thought it was a nice touch. It showed characteristics of the ranvir we know, who is a little cheeky and quite playful... i guess ironically even at the brink of death. But as they say 'old habits die hard'...

The whole episode was kind of desperate, trying hard to establish Anmol in Ranvir's place. We have seen Ranvir in past, and he is a good actor. In this scene, he is not definitely not good, and I agree that he seemed as if he was trying to stop himself from laughing. It seems like Kinsuk was not convinced that Ranvir is actually dying !!

Quote

Veritas

@Veritas

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#102

If not for Ragini's performance..I would have been laughing too,the whole thing was unreal.
I am sure behind the scenes Kinshuk must be in splits..passing off his wife to a relative stranger..who comes up with this stuff *shaking head

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

smitha

@SPN_JD_Addicted

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#103

Ranvir was at his best on Nov 13th when he meets Ragini in their room before going to the prison.He was crying,smiling and all.I cried for him.But that was missing yesterday.He was,sorry to say,preening!Yes he didn't want Ragini to be hurt,but really what did he expect that she will be happy?

Quote

hereandhappy

@hereandhappy

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#104

i don't know why but i seriously feel like laughing whenever such type of scenes are shown in TV serials(trust me many times i did laugh when i saw some of the death sequences in a serial) ...Kinshuk was also trying hard not to laugh ,isn't it funny to act like you are dying 😆...i really wonder how Parul can act so aptly in all those emotional scenes ....Regarding Apurva ...he is a good actor and his reactions were very apt , he was very convincing as a stranger he was witnessing a private convo between a husband wife .

Parul's acting and background music are the ones which helped me to feel this scene rather than to laugh at it

Quote

479445

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#105

Originally posted by: --Anu--
IT, Its ok. There is nothing logical or realistic in Bidaai or any TV show. We watch these shows because we like the story, its presentation, characters, jodis, actors etc (at-least me). Cvs did a very poor job in ending SaAlekh and RagVir. Its just the actors and their performances that made it worth watching.
Looking forward to Anmol-Ragini story and see whats in store for Alekh.

Hopefully its cleared ... uff...

CTs did a poor job ending RagVir and ... they could still keep Saalekh alive. But Ranvir went so quickly and so silently. I mean, the hospital, the letter (when did he write it?), no parents, no sasural present ... just Ragini ... it didnt add up. Atleast in Sadhna's case people were there ... atleast there was something little more realistic (in whatever unrealistic manner). Atleast a stage was set. This one with Ranvir was just hurried ... and I'm really upset about it ... including the scene where Mamaji fails to remember a character named Ranvir (on the first episode post-leap). Didnt go well with me ...

Frankly I started taking Bidaai seriously due to Sadhna ... thats the character, presentation and actor which really got me into it ... and Saalekh being the jodi. Yeah, later on I started to appreciate Ranvir alot.

Couldnt believe what they did with Ragini (and I confess I was amused) ... but then, what they did to bring about a leap was even more disastrous. Was the leap so crucial?

I like Anmol, as he is the only actor I possibly know in TV. Angini seems to have a promising future in the most uncertain of ways ... lol ... !

Nowadays Bidaai is just for the sake of laughing and coming here and posting some stuff ... lol. Its not really an important thing or something I would really be curious about.

Its way easier now to just brush this serial off (for me). I was thinking how I will feel when leaving it on september ... but I guess CTs care alot for me 😆😳😆

Quote

hereandhappy

@hereandhappy

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#106

Reagrding this topic - i didn't find this episode to be so bad ,for me its acceptable . Even Ragvir convo on phone is not that bad . They lost someone who was very dear ,they still miss Sadhana but it doesn't mean they should mention it everytime in every scene . They are husband wife and their relationship should not be impacted by the grave situations around .

Best example is when they showed Tammy's b'day celebration and Sadi's Barsi at same day .

I might sound weird but they can be happy and sad at the same time😆😆...it reminds me of a very funny Harry Potter 5 scene where Hermione tells Ron and Harry about Cho's feeling

Quote

hereandhappy

@hereandhappy

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#107

Originally posted by: Ice-Thinker
Hopefully its cleared ... uff...

CTs did a poor job ending RagVir and ... they could still keep Saalekh alive. But Ranvir went so quickly and so silently. I mean, the hospital, the letter (when did he write it?), no parents, no sasural present ... just Ragini ... it didnt add up. Atleast in Sadhna's case people were there ... atleast there was something little more realistic (in whatever unrealistic manner). Atleast a stage was set. This one with Ranvir was just hurried ... and I'm really upset about it ... including the scene where Mamaji fails to remember a character named Ranvir (on the first episode post-leap). Didnt go well with me ...

Frankly I started taking Bidaai seriously due to Sadhna ... thats the character, presentation and actor which really got me into it ... and Saalekh being the jodi. Yeah, later on I started to appreciate Ranvir alot.

Couldnt believe what they did with Ragini (and I confess I was amused) ... but then, what they did to bring about a leap was even more disastrous. Was the leap so crucial?

I like Anmol, as he is the only actor I possibly know in TV. Angini seems to have a promising future in the most uncertain of ways ... lol ... !

Nowadays Bidaai is just for the sake of laughing and coming here and posting some stuff ... lol. Its not really an important thing or something I would really be curious about.

Its way easier now to just brush this serial off (for me). I was thinking how I will feel when leaving it on september ... but I guess CTs care alot for me 😆😳😆

@Blue : yes they do 😆😆...even i was thinking about spending less time on IF and they helped me in achieving this ....and i am over with my Ragvir obsession . ...but i have to admit i started liking Apurva ....and i have to try hard not to fall for Angini ,else i will blame the CT's again 😉

Quote

479445

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#108

I know they are husband and wife ... but its just months ... and their behaviour, personality (as shown), reaction and all ... it doesnt compute for me ... maybe for you!

And their language... they way they were having fun ... it doesnt look decent to me. Also, their personality and specially Ragini's way of looking and dealing with things doesnt suite that (maybe to you).

Tammy's birthday was nice. I liked it alot ... Anmol's entry was cool. Sadi's barsi is not exactly the reason to mourn. People commemorate the departure of someone own, and give gifts and make the day holy. Its for the peace of the loved ones soul. And that soul doesnt get peace by mourning.

Ragini also mentioned that she was celebrating Tammy's birthday as Sadhna would've wished the same.

See .. its been 7 years aswell.

But then its Bidaai ... tell me what else have been logical or computable? ... LOL!

Quote

hereandhappy

@hereandhappy

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#109

Originally posted by: Ice-Thinker
I know they are husband and wife ... but its just months ... and their behaviour, personality (as shown), reaction and all ... it doesnt compute for me ... maybe for you!

And their language... they way they were having fun ... it doesnt look decent to me. Also, their personality and specially Ragini's way of looking and dealing with things doesnt suite that (maybe to you).

Tammy's birthday was nice. I liked it alot ... Anmol's entry was cool. Sadi's barsi is not exactly the reason to mourn. People commemorate the departure of someone own, and give gifts and make the day holy. Its for the peace of the loved ones soul. And that soul doesnt get peace by mourning.

Ragini also mentioned that she was celebrating Tammy's birthday as Sadhna would've wished the same.

See .. its been 7 years aswell.

But then its Bidaai ... tell me what else have been logical or computable? ... LOL!

I know nothing is logical and computable ...that's why i just watch it for the sake of entertainment rather than trying to find out any logic ....

Seriously i watch TV or Movie just to have fun and i don't try to analyse anything logically(anways i am not good at analysis) and the thing is this is the only serial i watch(not by choice but by chance,as other serials won't fit around my job timing ) and so i have to steal the moments where i can enjoy ,it can be anything like just watching a particular expression/bodylanguage / clothes/Background music or simply Ragvir/Sadi/Aalekh or Apurva(now)...