Guni and Sara-Kinshuk (Note: Page 5) - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

6.1k

Users

21

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41
Parul is more suitable than Sara to play any age-type roles, at least whatever is shown till now. This is a great plus point for Parul, she can fit in any character, which not all actors are blessed with. She was good as a young college leaving girl who fell in love with Ranveer and now she is equally good as Guni's chachi. One's eyes do not get strained to see Ragini-Guni as aunt-niece.

Parul has a very bright future because of her versatile attributes.

Rahm thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#42
I think you guys are limiting Sara's capabilities. She may look young, but nowadays there are young mothers. I've seen plenty of women that look really young, but have kids that are 5,6, etc.

Also, I think that with a wardrobe change (just like Parul's) Sara would have fit the part.

As for Kinshuk, I also think he would have totally fit the part. He could have grown his hair a little longer (like he did in the Ragvir track) and gelled it back rather than up. Maybe a little bit of a stubble. He definitely would have looked the part.

They would be playing 30 year old (in Sadhana's case a little younger) and I think that would have been fine. It's not like they're playing Vasu or Indrajit's age. That wouldn't have been fine.

Besides, when Sadhana married into the Rajvanch, Gunni was already 8 which is why she's around 18 now so it fits the role.
Purehearts thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: Rahm

I think you guys are limiting Sara's capabilities. She may look young, but nowadays there are young mothers. I've seen plenty of women that look really young, but have kids that are 5,6, etc.

Also, I think that with a wardrobe change (just like Parul's) Sara would have fit the part.

As for Kinshuk, I also think he would have totally fit the part. He could have grown his hair a little longer (like he did in the Ragvir track) and gelled it back rather than up. Maybe a little bit of a stubble. He definitely would have looked the part.

They would be playing 30 year old (in Sadhana's case a little younger) and I think that would have been fine. It's not like they're playing Vasu or Indrajit's age. That wouldn't have been fine.

Besides, when Sadhana married into the Rajvanch, Gunni was already 8 which is why she's around 18 now so it fits the role.


Rahm.. you are talking about the physique here again.Believe me even Raagini looks/is young for the 30 yr old she is playing now, but she can carry on with her acting skills.
Ranveer could been dressed to look mature but it would have been hard for us to convince yourself of his age
.
Sara could have looked old with makeup but it would be hard for audiences to imagine her as a 30 yr old.

Anyways this is my POV.
Edited by Purehearts - 15 years ago
nazmobile thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: mona_28

saying dat parul has got matured looks ....... is like calling khushi n tamanna 18 year old gals ....... it actually seems to be the bggest joke of the day to me ....... 🤣🤣

</div>
as far as the comparison b/w sara n parul is concerned (since the topic starter herself started it )......................... honestly speaking wen both of them were launched in the show they were quite young ...... n they looked that way too ..... but parul looked somewhat matured at that time compared to sara BCOZ of the heavy dark make up she was bombarded with........!!!


with passage of time ..... there have been drastic changes in parul n sara in terms of looks ......... but the difference is dat parul has changed for the betterment ......... whereas sara has changed for the worse ......... she looked much more beautiful earlier but not anymore ....... atleast to me !!!


but today the case is completely opposite .........as far as parul is concerned she seems to be getting more beautiful day by day........ everytime i see her ...... she seems more beautiful , younger n cuter than the last time........ n i actually mean it guys !!!


for sara ......... those sunken cheeks ,coloured hair n too much skiny body ...... make her look highly matured n older........ everytime i see her she looks more matured than before especially in last few episodes that she shot during her pregnancy n after dat .............. even in the pic which is there in RH ......... she looks quite older !!!!


<div>ps ........ watever i've said is completely my opinion .... i do not mean to offend anyone ....... as far as comparison is concerned the topic starter erself started it !!!!



I don't agree with that, i think Sara has become beautiful as she's aged...yes she lost a lot of weight but i think that happens to everyone and they go through the motions before they find their ideal weight...i myself am of a slight body frame similar to Sara Khan and it's very easy for people to mistake me as someone younger than my age of 26 and to think that I am skinny but in actual fact maturity comes from a persons face and actions...and there were plenty of times that we saw that maturity in Sara/Sadhana....when she came home with Khushi and sang the lullaby i totally brought her as a mother and I think she would have been able to pull off the role equally as good as Parul.

Having said that yes because of Parul's look and physicality it is easier for her to mould into the older character but it's not fair to put Sara at a disadvantage and say she wouldn't have been able to do it...She hasn't been given the chance and we haven't seen her so we can't say for sure.

You have to remember that Sara was only 16 when she started on Bidaai at that age a girl is still a child to some extent with a little bit of baby fat...she's now 20 going onto 21 so she's turning into an adult and young lady so yes she's bound to change physically we shouldn't be negative about that.

Edited by nazmobile - 15 years ago
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45
@Rahm, Purehearts and nazmobile

good discussion and very valid points...thanks for the enlightenment ..

Rahm thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#46
Purehearts, I thought the discussion was about physique.

If it's about acting then I'm 100% sure that Kinshuk and Sara could have convinced us that they were parents and older. They are both great actors who have the versatility to play these roles. If they didn't then they wouldn't have done so well in this industry.

I think Kinshuk and Sara are just as good as Angad and Parul.
Rahm thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

@Rahm, Purehearts and nazmobile

good discussion and very valid points...thanks for the enlightenment ..



Thanks and anytime. 😊
Purehearts thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Rahm

Purehearts, I thought the discussion was about physique.

If it's about acting then I'm 100% sure that Kinshuk and Sara could have convinced us that they were parents and older. They are both great actors who have the versatility to play these roles. If they didn't then they wouldn't have done so well in this industry.

I think Kinshuk and Sara are just as good as Angad and Parul.



No doubt they both are good actors...but somehow I will have to see them in such a role to convince myself that they too can fit into mature roles naturally.
😃
Rahm thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Purehearts



No doubt they both are good actors...but somehow I will have to see them in such a role to convince myself that they too can fit into mature roles naturally.
😃



Did you see the episode where Sadhana sang a lullaby to Khushi? How natural did she look? She looked just like she was born to be a mother. It was such a beautiful scene. It really made me tear up.

As for Ranvir, when Ragini was in the hospital, the way he screamed at the doctor saying he wants BOTH-his wife and kid safe. He spoke like not only a protective husband but father too and the way he held Tamanna and kissed her. *sigh* He looked beautiful with the baby.

I feel Kinny and Sara would have been naturals at this.
.shona. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#50
i feel the number of years for the leap is wrong. I wish it was like 5 years leap...then i m sure everything wud've been perfect. Even though i still dnt get the reason behind leap.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".