Originally posted by: Nafisa_blossoms
I happen to agree Giaa is not the best dancer in JDJ 5 Isha and Shibani's performances have been better then Giaa's...leaving Gurmeet's popularity and Giaa's popularity with audiences, the final should be contested by Isha and Shibani from the performances so far they deserve that final. But the judges and the performances themselves don't count in who is put in the bottom 3 or who is going home after each weeks performance it's the viewers at home that have bothered to pick up the phone to call in for that performance that count.
This business of saying JDJ is scripted has been said to me several times, I suppose the question will be do we trust the integrity of JDJ and the votes they are publishing or not (it's scripted). Okay say its scripted and the winner is known and it's neither Isha, Shibani or even Gurmeet, say because Giaa suffered a loss of her job in Saathiya and Jhalak and Giaa made a deal for her to win JDJ 5, we all impartial observers that have neither voted for her and don't really watch JDJ in previous seasons, will be eager to see the final performances and who the winner is going to be.
But we will never know definitely that the votes from Giaa's following gave her the win or it's a manufactured win. I'm sure we will have a fun time talking about it though.
I want to ask you Pro Dev's one thing if Giaa looses JDJ 5 and you have it confirmed that no deal was made with Jhalak and Giaa how will you repair the damage made to Giaa now, as you say this now means people won't vote for Giaa Manek saying she has an assured win already, for gods sake they might even not vote for their other favourites in the show anyway because of all this talk of JDJ being scripted. Or you just don't care voting is a waste of money and time anyway as god's will whoever wins wins.