Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.4k

Users

6

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

-Nafisa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: bhavya

@Nafisa -Blossoms
i agree to your analysis but i have a point to say this...
but i feel anyways on the day of their Suhag raath, may be aham would have acepted her as his wife but when Anita called him and acused him for cheating her... his mind might have changed... and when Aham met Umang in jewellery shop first he asked him was how is anita and how she is... and on his birthday... he remembered anita how she wished him previous year... he had longing for anita as he kept looking at his mobile whether it rings.. so that he can hear anitas voice...
he has anita and his photograph in his diary till now... and he stopped gopi to see the photograph when it was fallen accidently...
he has killed his heart to marry gopi as his mother wished before marriage to gopi he has tried to convince kokila bout anita... but when he saw his mother broke down in tears... the idea stopped him from doing so...
so i think he was guilty when he married gopi for cheating Anita... he was in depression at that time for loosing anita... but he knew it that if he marries his mothers choice he can keep her happy... he initially was ready to accept gopi as his wife...but the fact that necklace incident, and when he came to know that gopi is illetrate he lost his mind and slapped her for lying to them that she is an illetrate... and he made her to sleep... he was behaving as a husband to her,,, just to keep his mother happy...
but inside he was not at all considered as his wife... from the begining...
he has told her once... she is in this house just because of his mother so it is her duty to keep his mother mother happy...
so i think deep down his heart he have kept love for Anita...
since gopi was illetrate made him angry thaats it...but he would have accepted gopi if she would have educated... may be but deep down he loves anita even today... may be gopi has become his aadath now... he brought gopi back since naani came to visit after her he was ready to send her back to mama mami... it was kokila who kept gopi in modi bhavan... he might have helped gopi in studies and would have got his attention on her beauty... but it may last for few days as he himself has not realized it is love or what... even we are in confusion... his behaviour has changed little bit... as he needs everyones attension... since anita has left him a year back and never came back,... so he would accept gopi with no other choice as she is good at heart and he may love her...
but his love to gopi will be justified once anita is back...
if anita would have been bad than she would have tried many tricks to revenge on GoHem from past year instead of that she left India and kept herself away...
so i dont think... Aham can hate anita... it may put him under dilemma for choosing between gopi aor anita...
so who will win anita or gopi...?
who does aham deserve...


Also a good explanation, that wedding day, the Suhaag Raath, when he was going to the bedroom Anita did call and put him in a bad temper, I think he even threw the phone away before entering the bedroom, also the day of his birthday he remembered Anita singing happy birthday sweetly, but that still goes back to comparison between the educated English speaking and confident Anita to his wife Gopi who had to look to Kokila for permission to wish him happy birthday and she made a right hash of wishing him too, as she couldn't pronounce the English words, so that birthday remembrance was a comparison between his ex-girlfriend and his wife, so perhaps he has thought about Anita after his marriage a few times, thinking it would have been so much easier if I was married to an educated girl like my ex-girlfriend, I wouldn't be embarrassed on my birthday in front my friends (remember also he had to cut minnie mouse cake), so he wouldn't be human if he didn't think how would be like if I had married Anita instead of the villager, who needs to be taught everything now after marriage. But that still brings me to my original point that the main problem with Gopi was that according to Aham she's a villager, Ghawar and not worthy to be a wife for him.

Consider if Gopi was educated like Anita was, she would sing happy birthday to him she would order the right cake, decorate the house correctly and not be fooled into decorating for kiddies birthday by Rashi, everything would have run smoothly for that party and why would Aham remember a phone call of Anita's the previous year on his birthday, they would be no need to. But he was miserable that day the party brought to his mind the long way Gopi has to go in order to be a good wife.

About meeting Umang in the jewellery shop anybody who meets your ex's brother somewhere after marriage you ask after you ex out of courtesy, you would be unfeeling if you don't enquire if that person is okay.
AamiraWilson thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12


Yes, i agree with Nafisa. If Ahem has cheated and dumped Anita because of his mother, Umang could have done the same to Kinjal for his sister. Natural. But he took it up a notch and ruined Kinjal, Publicly disgraced the Modis. He needn't have done that. Where was Anita when Umang was playing these dirty games? Did ALL this happened without her knowledge?

Anita even gave ultimatum to Ahem to choose between her and his mother. She could have herself coaxed Kokila into giving her a chance to prove herself. Its not Ahem's fault because as Anita was present on his engagement as a guest and Kinjal and Ahem's friend than surely she knows well enough about the Modi ladies's lifestyle. She should have known from the very beginning about this barrier. Even if they got married somehow, her unwillingness to compromise and adjust would have soon created trouble between her and Ahem.

Now, the biggest victim of being cheated is Gopi. Just imagine, she had been cheated into the marriage. Ahem didn't accept her as his wife. He shouted plainly on her face that he doesn't consider her as his wife, he loves another girl. the reason he married her is his mother's happiness. Even though Kinjal told Gopi on mehendi night that Ahem loves Anita, Rashi changed Gopi's decision not to marry Ahem by reading the letter from Kinjal as the opposite. Ahem should have told her that before marriage, He only thought about Koki. What he didn't think about was that by doing this he was hurting his mother even more. His mother would never want him to do that, hurt someone so badly. Ahem did that to Gopi knowing fully well that she was an orphan and helpless. Throughout the last one year, Gopi has tolerated physical and mental abuse from him. He treated her like dirt under his feet. Ahem had cheated her by marrying her without even caring about her. His abuse and torture can be labelled as illegal too.

So, in comparison, what happened to Anita? Her heart was broken and she was cruelly dumped. Gopi was the one cheated and abused not Anita. Anita has the luxury of choosing another path and starting life afresh. Can poor Gopi do that? Her life was completely destroyed, her hopes and dreams shattered. So, I think ,Ahem should apologize to Anita but it is Gopi's case that he should be repenting about. Give her the happiness that he has demolished himself. He didn't have any right to do that. As for Anita, she should try to forget the past and look forward. Ahem wasn't meant for her. If he was he would have somehow convinced his mother. He did go against his mother for Gopi's education. It clearly proves whom he truly loves. Anita can find a much better man who will truly love her. Her partner should be compatible with her. I personally think that if anything wrong happens to a girl just like it happened to Anita, the girl should not think its the end of her life. She is wasting her precious time and her life by crying over some stone-hearted jerk.
NazmaJ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
I have nothing to add Nafisa said it all in her first post! Lol
But those were the thoughts that came into my head also.
Ahem can't have loved Anita truly because as we've seen when Ahem believes something is right he will go against his mother as we saw when he continued Gopi's education. So although he may have thought he loved Anita he didn't have the stregth of conviction to go against what his mother had decided (I think because he truly knew that even if he did marry Anita she would never be able to fit in to his family or give his mther the love and respect that she deserves).
With Gopi we are seeing that he uses his own initiative a lot more these days.
OK so I have added a little bit more!
Peacefulmind thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Nafisa_blossoms

ya may be right ... he was comparing gopi with educated anita till now... but he never compared goodness gopi with anita yet...
you mean Aham did not accept gopi as his wife since she is not educated ???????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".