MARHABAA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Hi am fairly new to this forum membership even though have been following the forum for about a year..
Unfortunately have often noticed as soon as someone makes a comment with regards to an actors/actresses acting a very negative approach is taken by other users.

Its a forum ...surely people can express whether they like an actor or not ! Isnt that the whole point to give your own perspective on the drama and characters portrayed in it?
Agreed dont be overtly rude about a individual but this is a commentary on a TV drama serial therefore surely acting comes into the equation.

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.5k

Users

12

Likes

68

Frequent Posters

shobi12500 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
first of all @marhaba we welcome u to this forum.
member express thier view to just know each other point .
for critizing someone there is a permission but there is a limit and everyone have to follow the limit.
if the member r critisizing someone they r critizing in a limits they r not crossing the limits. i hope u will understand
Edited by shobi12500 - 14 years ago
MARHABAA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: shobi12500

first of wlcom @marhaba we welcome u to this forum.
member express thier view to just know each other point .
for critizing someone there is a permission but there is a limit and everyone have to follow the limit.
if the member r critisizing someone they r critizing in a limits they r not crossing the limits. i hope u will understand


Thanks ..I do agree not to completely ram raid against the actor..however on this forum if someone even mentions that an actor/actresses acting has been bad or not up to the mark they are slammed for it ..thats not really the realistic approach of a forum based around characters , story lines and acting.
I personally comment of the role and story line with regards to the shows however if others want to make a comment of the way in which a role is being portrayed then a little tolerance should be shown,which if you look across the forums is not the case at present.
simran15 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Since I have been on the forum....I have always noticed ...the SNS forum welcomes everyone n their comments whole heartedly.......but there are ethics ,code of conduct etc.. that everyone individual has to follow.........Like u mentioned if someone is rude about the cast or not ready for an open debate....there is a stage were members like to withdraw n look for another interesting topics.......n if ur approach is rude from the start irrespective of the topic....isn't it the general human nature not to confront the individual...not a single thread started goes unanswered at the forum....but sometime we run out of materials to discuss too.Everyone has positive n negative comments for a particular thread...😊
Edited by simran15 - 14 years ago
upasana.diya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Before i touch upon the issue, let me welcome you to the forum again, as i believe you used to post here once in a while sometime back... and your name is Natashaa... right😉

I am not sure how you got this idea hun😲, but believe me we have not shunned anyone for saying that an actor's acting is bad😊… if anyone is talking about acting fine, but if someone starts personal attacks on actors for their physical appearance or their personal life or using bad, provocative and rude language… then it's not acceptable😊… like if someone says "hey Giaa is so short, she doesn't look good with Ahem"… then this becomes a personal opinion about physical attributes of height not their skills as actor... even in those scenarios we politely inform the person about the rules and proceed forward…

also, like if you put an opinion and I try to argue with you and shout at you just to show that my argument is powerful… then what I am doing is a big no-no😊… everyone is entitled to their opinion, but being civil in speech is what is anticipated anywhere…

there is discussion and then there is argument, separated by a thin line... discussion we are open to but argument, I don't think many of us would like to enter... everyone has their own set of problems and we see this as a serial, which is not a big media of social awareness😊… if we are talking about social awareness and are arguing here, its meaningless as no one is benefiting, we are only rising our BPs… but if someone can be civil and atleast acknowledge (if not accept) a different opinion then too any kind of discussion is enjoyable…😃

me and sADhli(-tellyaddict-) go after Ahem and Nazim all the time... sADhli is gaga over Ahem and Nazim and I literally blast him at every turn... and no one slammed me… ask sADhli if you don't believe me... that was because, I never touched the topic of his physical appearance in a demeaning way… I have argued on Nazim's lack of acting skills many times...

Tell me how you would feel if one day you come across some post or message somewhere, where people are calling you ugly or something... I would go ballistic and I won't like it😃... so basically the only ground rule here is "Don't do something to others, which you won't appreciate when done to you" 😊we need to appreciate that actors are also humans and we need to respect them as human being if not anything else


sorry for the long post guys... just wanted to put things in a clearer perspective so Natashaa doesn't feel her concerns are not being addressed...

Edited by upasana.diya - 14 years ago
MARHABAA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
yep I been here for a bit then I sit back and absorb the forum n then respond when I get time 😉


Never said the forum was unwelcoming,infact they are a very incorporating place 😛 However only this morning some newbie wrote I think Ahems acting isnt great.....to which some senior shot her down by saying u cant say tht here as he has lots of fans ..Its not something I imagined folks .

Am not condemning the restrictions on a open healthy discussion but for that to take place then all should adhere to the rules .Noone is stating tht no matter what is said its acceptable ..from the outset my view point has been views expressed within realms of decorum shouldn't be blown out of the water.

If your a fan of someone and another person doesn't feel that person is upto merit then that leaves the case up to discussion.
Its NOT discussion when u state to someone you cant state ur view as its different from the majority.

I hope the issue is now grasped because it seems to have gone off to a tangent with regards to people being rude ..forums being unfriendly etc etc when thats actually not at all what am stating .

Anyhows no worries enjoy..

upasana.diya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
if that was so, i apologize on behalf of whoever said it... i for myself might have missed the thread, since i never saw such posts floating around😔
NotYourType thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
@MARHABAA - Just adding my two cents...I completely agree to what you said. But I would like to say something about the post by the Newbie about Ahem's acting not being so great...Many of us here think that Nazim needs to improve his acting skills, we have also discussed a lot about this in the past. The member who replied to this post might be stating his own POV and what he THINKS is the other ppl's POV. I think it's unfair to judge the entire forum based on one member's comments.
MARHABAA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: upasana.diya

if that was so, i apologize on behalf of whoever said it... i for myself might have missed the thread, since i never saw such posts floating around😔



no need for apology hun its not an issue no worries ,i choose not to leave comments on that other topic as then it would just give rise to conflict which is not my scene
stay happy 😉
loveanime thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: upasana.diya

if that was so, i apologize on behalf of whoever said it... i for myself might have missed the thread, since i never saw such posts floating around😔


diya i saw what this person wrote. it wasn't on a thread on its own, it was on another topic so it is not obvious for people to find. i personally felt they stated their point in decent manner. not sure why this is an issue as it was just some back and forth and everyone politely agreed to disagree that is all.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".