Zidane-nedved thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
It is not up to the judges to eliminate when ever they want!
Vasundra and Rohanpreet and tanmay are the weakest links of those five and i saw in the last two episodes that sonu Vasundra "guardian" and Suresh" Rohan and Tanmay "Guardian" tries to put down Aamir and Anamika!Thats it now,they eliminated better singers(Rohit,Sahil,vibhore and smita)By their negative comments against those they dont favorer!Vasundra should get eliminated cause i dont want to see Another Diwakar Story!Sonu is so childish.He likes aamir,when he sings Sonu or kailesh kher songs and hates him when he sings other!I swear if Anamika or Aamir gets eliminated next week,

Moderator's Note:


The last line of the Post edited.. Do not bring any indirect comparison between the two shows...


Edited by Anu.Rad - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

3.4k

Users

17

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

mango-frost thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
ahh...u seem to be a voi supporter....so i wont bother to waste my energy on replying to this topic as i was about to...😊 good day 😊
jazjassu thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
May be I have been watching a different show because both judges praise Anamika for her daring song selection and wonderful performances.. So what if they like to give advice on what do to refine the singing.. I have seen Vasu, Rohan being criticized for their weak performances..
As for no elimination this week, it was not sole judges' decision, paretns gave their consent as well. That said I would have liked to see an elimination this week, if not on Friday than may be Sat.
I think no elimination this week will have more effect on who will stay in top 4 or 3, not on top two.
As of now, to me Anamika seems most deserving for position #1. Then, that is just me.. some people might find Vasu most desrving.
Judges' comments have influence, but majority of people will vote depending on their own eyes and ears.. Judges criticized Rohan for yara mera dil karta performance, but I found it to be the best. Voting will be done subjectively not objectively... It is what appeals to the audience not to critics- commercial movies make bigger bucks than art films...
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

I think Aamir is the best among all of them talent wise.😊But the other kids too should be able to improve.

pervezaziz thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
I also seriously think that Sonu is very biased. Even though Amir and Anamika sang best in last episode but they gave them only A. Even on Amir performance both guests were so excited and praised a lot . Similarly Vishal also praised Amir very much but ur judges just know how to criticise both Amir and Anamika. Let us be clear that this is a musical show and not a charity show where we should praise Vasundhra for what ever she sang and it seems they get scare with her crying. How come she gets A+ while both Amir and Anamika didnt get double A+. SaReGaMaPa is fast loosing credibility. Please note that i am ardent fan of SRGMP and i watch since it first started as SRGM with Sonu as anchor. But for first time i am thinking of moving to VOI as atleast it has better judges.
chatbuster thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: pervezaziz

I also seriously think that Sonu is very biased. Even though Amir and Anamika sang best in last episode but they gave them only A. Even on Amir performance both guests were so excited and praised a lot . Similarly Vishal also praised Amir very much but ur judges just know how to criticise both Amir and Anamika. Let us be clear that this is a musical show and not a charity show where we should praise Vasundhra for what ever she sang and it seems they get scare with her crying. How come she gets A+ while both Amir and Anamika didnt get double A+. SaReGaMaPa is fast loosing credibility. Please note that i am ardent fan of SRGMP and i watch since it first started as SRGM with Sonu as anchor. But for first time i am thinking of moving to VOI as atleast it has better judges.

haan yaar, this is not a charity show. they should stop with all those garibi-hatao AVs, no?😉

as for aamir, i think he gets higher grades than he deserves. much higher.😉

chatbuster thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Summer3

I think Aamir is the best among all of them talent wise.😊But the other kids too should be able to improve.

do u mean in the 5% of songs that are sufi kinds? not that aamir's particularly good even there, as was demonstrated in the sufi rounds. now, dont we get singers like that every minute? do we really need a hundred singers in that genre itself?😆

problem with sonu is he's too biased towards aamir. emotional ho gaya na after all that unemployment business, aur kya?😉😆

Chits1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
Aamir's voice is unique.I personally do not like anamika's singing.Her accent puts me off.
iiHEARTyu-x0 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
i also thynk dat vasundhara shud be out, but she sings realliii gud, but shes da weakest out of all of them😊

anddd stopp blamiin sonu for everything! 😡
itz not his fault dat they sang good dat day
chatbuster thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Zidane-nedved

It is not up to the judges to eliminate when ever they want!
Vasundra and Rohanpreet and tanmay are the weakest links of those five and i saw in the last two episodes that sonu Vasundra "guardian" and Suresh" Rohan and Tanmay "Guardian" tries to put down Aamir and Anamika!Thats it now,they eliminated better singers(Rohit,Sahil,vibhore and smita)By their negative comments against those they dont favorer!Vasundra should get eliminated cause i dont want to see Another Diwakar Story!Sonu is so childish.He likes aamir,when he sings Sonu or kailesh kher songs and hates him when he sings other!I swear if Anamika or Aamir gets eliminated next week,This show will not win the talent hunt show award again cause Voice of india is waiting around the corner!

dont agree with you one bit.😛

sure, not having any elimination this week matters. but only to get some folks all het up, bursting their vessels.😉 not otherwise, if we're looking at the longer-run.😉 if not this week, then by the next, the guy who polls the least in the 2 weeks combined would have been eliminated anyway. in other words, doesnt matter if someone like aamir came in 2nd this time around. kaheen na kaheen fail toh ho jayega, kyoon?

oh, as for being biased, sonu and the entire team seems to be heavily biased towards aamir. starting with that AV😉😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".