vaishali got A from judges-not justified

Page

Hibernated

Posted: 17 years ago

Vaishali sang the whole song besura and just because ayesha takia danced with her...the judges gave her A.is it really justified????I mean i really thought she deserved C+ for her singing and A for her nautanki.i guess saregampa is a platform mainly for singers😕....if she got A all others deserved nothing less than A+😊.your views please

Quote

Frequent Posters

77199

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

She did not deserve an A. Saans ki bhi problem thi. 😕

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Ron

@AznDesi

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Sonu openly said for her "SINGING" only she deserves C+ but because she was sick , cute , ayesha danced with her etc.. he gave A. Same with Suresh Ji he said the same thing. Muscially she didnt more than a C+ , B but it was nice of the judges to clarify why they are doing what they are doing. 😆 😆

Quote

gopalbhai

@gopalbhai

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

I can not say what she deserved. In the condition that she is in right now, coughing heavily and voice not in good condidition, she sung the song with correct taal-maan and that too with an unplanned stage performance, at her age, she is an exceptional talent.

I would say Vaishali is an exceptional Little Champ.

Quote

Manik_mia

@Manik_mia

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: gopalbhai
I can not say what she deserved. In the condition that she is in right now, coughing heavily and voice not in good condidition, she sung the song with correct taal-maan and that too with an unplanned stage performance, at her age, she is an exceptional talent.

I would say Vaishali is an exceptional Little Champ.

Does not matter what ever was the condition, grades should be only for the song not for all the natangki.

Quote

smiley23

@smiley23

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I agree. Vashali should not have gotton an A from both of the judges today. Her constant talking is really starting to get annoying. I don't think it's cute anymore. I mean it seems like she comes on the show to talk more than sing. Her song today was just horrible, yet she got the same grade as everyone else.
I do realize that she is sick but we have seen other shows where contestants who were sick got bad marks due to sickness. So it is not fair to the other participants, that Vishali receives good marks even if she does not sing well.

Quote

Manik_mia

@Manik_mia

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Sonuji gave Anamika A and Vaishali also A. If I compare with Anamika's A grade, Vaishali should be B at max.

Quote

Ajnabee

@*Woh Ajnabee*

Stunner

Posted: 17 years ago

I agree with you, her performance was no where near an A. But I did like the fact that Sonu Nigam clearly said that she deserved a C+ for her singing. I think they gave her the A because they didn't want to judge her while she was sick, as she clearly was. On the other hand, if the A was given when she was feeling well, well then we might have trouble there. Lets hope that the public makes the right decision! Pssh, who am I kidding?!?

Quote

Aseel

@Asseel

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

i was about to post the same topic
vaishaly killed the song actually
there is many faults in her song
and thats because she was dancing with ayesha !!
she should get C+ and she should eliminate next week
i know she is ill and she danced with ayesha
but thats not excuse to be in the final 6
her last performances all were not so good
saahil , vibhor , rohit , smita & even loria are much better than her !!
the ppl loves her only because she is a too young & talk machine !!!
if we were talking about singing than she should be in top 15 only !!

Quote

Manik_mia

@Manik_mia

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: zaara&amanat
she shouldnt get a A

I agree

Quote

1 2 3

vaishali got A from judges-not justified

Related Topics

Explore Topics