fair or not?

I don't think it's fair to take Vaishali and Sagar out, when Anamika and Loria were on the verge of it last week😡😡😡

it waznt faiir,
becuzz loria shud hav been out instead.......

It is not fair to base judgement on one performance but the judges should look at a few performances to be fair. Anameeka is good, and cute too. Loria has not been singing so good although she has improved. Sagar's performance is enjoyable.

Loria and Sagar would have been fair!

I felt Vaishali should have been retained and Loria should have been eliminated as she was not good last week. Vasundhara too was not good last week but her excellent performance of "Nanna re..." brought her back to race again. Sagar's elimination was expected .

I feel that last week(Nov 30th and dec 1st episodes)Loria was better than Vaishali.Of course,the week prior to that Vaishali was way beter than Loria.
Last week,Vaishali's Poocho zara poocho was pretty ordinary.Loria was slightly better with 'Main albeli'..Loria's 'chadthi jawani' was def better than vaishali's 'Jai jai shiv Shankar'...Loria cld have brought the masti of the song better and she also made a a mistake in the tune.. Vaishali kept the mood intact,par uske Sur kahin nahi lag rahe the...She was totally off key(in at least 4-5 places)....And in Carnatic music we say,Sur-maata,taal-pita...Without the maata, there is no song 😊

Originally posted by: SAnode

You are forgetting their age differences. Loria is 12yrs old but comparing to the other kids of her age her singing is quite ordinary. In that aspect Vaishali is way better than her. Loria's voice trembles too much. It became very evident when she sang 'katra katra' and Sonu pointed out it. She has proved that at 12, she's as bright as a 17yr old(she's passed 12th). But i should say that she doesnt have that much talent in singing.

I agree that their age differences are huge and during this period a difference of 2-3 yrs is a lot..Vaishali is 10 and Loria is maybe,13.Keeping the age factor in mind,Vaishali is way better and when Vaishali is 13,she cld beat Loria hollow....

But unfortunately,currently,the competition format doesn't differentiate between age groups...All kids,aged 7-14 come under this category..When they have been put under one category,they will have to be judged equally...We shld presume,that we dn't know the age/face of these kids and only listen to their songs...On that basis,Loria was better.For eg)when Loria passed her 12th coz she was good,not becoz she was a 12 yr old competing with 17 yr olds....Hence age,unfortunately,is not a criteria here as per the rules of the competition. 😊

There is no way Anamika should have been eliminated before Vaishali. She is the most melodious singer in this group. It was surprising that she was in bottom 3 last week. Maybe the judges did that to give her a warning. They did this to Aamir few weeks back and now see the results! Since last 2 weeks, Loria's performances have been weak because of her throat infection, but before that her performances have been superior to Vaishali's. That's why Sonu keeps saying that he is waiting for the real Loria to come back. Sagar's elimination was very much expected. So I think yes, these eliminations were fair.