Originally posted by: anarvekar
Only one other thing to add about the show. I have the utmost respect for Sonu Nigam and Suresh Wadkar as judges. In fact, I think they are best in the last few years. However, I don't understand why Suresh Wadkar gave Anamika B+ after saying all good things about her (except for the 'ra' pronunciation). The same thing happened two weeks ago. He said everything positive about her and ended up giving her a B+. Why is that happening? And he gave Sayon also a B+ after saying many negative things about the performance. I don't quite understand that. Is Anamika getting penalized because she is slightly older and he is judging older contestants by a higher standard?
Exactly..It was a difficult song and Anamika did quite a good job. On Friday Aamir getting an A just because of the 'Gadi' part even though the song was an easy one whereas Anamika's song on Saturday, was the most difficult one and she was mostly good, I really didn't understand her getting B+.
Now coming to the show,
On Friday, Vasundhara shd have got the 1st place, I felt. Rohit 2nd and Vibhore 3rd..
Nagin was irritating, otherwise it was good.
On Saturday, Rohanpreet sang the song 'kansura' , still he was not in bottom 3(just because of his voice) whereas Tanmay was in bottom 2 though he sang the song fairly well(only the 'chahne' part was a bit lower than the actual sur, may be bcuz of his range limitation)..😕
Edited by lifeztuf - 17 years ago