What Amanat Lacks Raja and Aneek have - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

125

Views

9k

Users

66

Frequent Posters

77124 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: lovlymahima

😆 oh amanat lacks stupids fans who dont know about music.

Nope after your comment I dont think he lacks stupid fans at all :D

There all good singers. But I agree with the majority that Amanat has no soul in his songs. I dont know why his fans cant accept that, instead they shoot down Raja and Aneek Fans. WOW. Real mature.

sumitkapoor21 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: lovlymahima

😆 oh amanat lacks stupids fans who dont know about music.

He did not lack stupid fans because it seems he has one....😆 😆 😆 😆

Edited by sumitkapoor21 - 17 years ago
jncblr thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
Amanat lacks the throw in his voice also offlate he seems a bit breathless while singing. But he has more melody than the other two. All 3 have different strengths and weaknesses and would be interesting to see who wins it in the end.
ellen4eva thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: Shawn89

Nope after your comment I dont think he lacks stupid fans at all :D

There all good singers. But I agree with the majority that Amanat has no soul in his songs. I dont know why his fans cant accept that, instead they shoot down Raja and Aneek Fans. WOW. Real mature.

We're not acceptin that amanat does not have soulful singin becoz he DOES have it. y can't U accept it that he does have soulful singin becoz of all the people defendin him?!!!

ur the one bein immature by pointin out mistakes rather than supportin all those in the finals.

he's the onli guy who has made everyone cry with his SOULFUL singin, includin all the audience WHO HAVE FEELINGS!!! i wasnt even gonna bother defendin amanat againt all those who have taken an oath to critisize amanats singin. but wat to do, aadat se majbur i can't see sum1 who is the most talented to be bashed with a bunch to 'i have nothin better to do other than critisize amanat'.

btw this post is not to be taken in an offensive way to anyone. thankyou😆

rohita_dhe thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
Amanat lacks

1. Soulful singing as he does not feel the song (please now don't give me 'Tujhse Naraz nahin Zindagi' example. A contestant can not win a contest on one single hit)

2. Amanat lacks the throw. He can not sing powerful songs, even though he is technically best amongst all other contestants.
Saif-Preity-Fan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
Oh come on guyz,what has Shekhar and the others said: Amanat is the only one,who can sing all kind of songs,Raja and Aneeq can't do it.Aneeq sings only songs of Mr.Sonu Nigam and Raja sings song of an other singer,don't remember his name.

And what did you all say,the lyric is the reason,why guests and peoples cry.Raja and Aneeq are able to make the other dance and cry by there singing,oh come on,than I can also say the reason is LYRICS.

Amanat is the only one,who can sing fast and slow songs,happy and emotional songs,disco and party songs.And he sings with feel,he feel the song and the lyrics,this hasn't Raja and Aneeq.

And just listen what the guests and the mentors said about Amanats last peformance,he can even sing in the next movie "Ali Bagh".I mean Bappis son,a music director,chosed him.

Amanat has a really clear and good character.Raja credit the song to his favourit actor and Aneeq to Dia,coz he "loves" her.Amanat isn't so selfish,he sang it fpr Meghna and her parents,not because she is don't know what ever.

So plz,stop this nonsene,Amanat is for us a real winner.

nidapida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: mat1

Amanat ia a good singer with original voice. But he does lack in giving a feel to the songs, And Raja and Aneek both are great at this. Raja may make mistakes but the expression and feel he brings to the songs transforms one to a different world. Same with Aneek. Once Raja and Aneek start singing , one wants them to go on and not stop. But Amanat despite the flawless singing, makes me get bored after a while and makes me wonder how long his song will go on.

I guess a great singer does need the above mentioned qualities too

did u not see the last performance? i no that was ur opinion and i respect that but still i don't agree with u

pooja4ulove thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
No need to argue Amanat's biggest lacks is regional votes this program looks like now Indian ideal votes will makes stars but not singers.
canadianbeauty thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: mat1

Amanat ia a good singer with original voice. But he does lack in giving a feel to the songs, And Raja and Aneek both are great at this.



Did you not see Amanat cry during his last performance?

I don't know about you, but I think that when some one becomes emotional while singing a song....then they must be singing it with FEELING.

that is only one example.

I have seen Amanat bring emotion, and feeling on stage countless times.

I hope Amanat wins...the guy has charisma, versatility, and PERSONALITY.
lÁmhÁ thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
Amanat lacks?...'lack'and 'amanat' don't go together.Anik can only mimic Sonu and Nigam and Mohammad Rafi's musical genre,while Raja only adheres to Sukhwinder-Kailash kher types of songs. So who are we left with? That's right.Amanat is the man.He is the only versatile singer to have performed on the face of saregamapa stage.I'd rather puke than not to vote for Amanat but someone like anik!!

I was somehwat disgusted to see Anik win..hello?May i please be excused?Anik?Typical voice.CUTE?Yeah right *HAHAHAHA* Cute...hahaha...

In the end,I don't blame you lot.Anik is like a burger that you get to eat by throwing a penny..People just want to munch on the day-to-day diet but not eat something new,healthy and fresh.They're just restless to go for something new.
As for the ''breathes-too-much-during-performances'' and ''lacks this-lacks that'' sutff.I could very well potray a plethora of proofs and examples regarding his 'amazing singing skills',but as I now think you've all had enough of it already,i'll just let it go ;)


Moderator's Note:

Do not make such posts attacking the contestants.

Edited by Anu.Rad - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".