Your opinion on this weeks show - Page 5

Here I go

1st round

Anek - must you go for Rafi numbers? The low notes were clearly shaking. Rafi is a v v difficult singer to emulate, so stay away as far as possible.

Amanat - technically v v good. I don't think it is possible to do more justice to a Rafi classic than this.

Raja - unimpresive. OK.

2cd round
Raja - was pretty good. I thought the censure was too harsh.

Aneek - the songs does not suit you at all. Stick to softer lyrical numbers like Main agar kahoon.

Amanat - actually I liked this one.

Overall v bad song selection.

3rd rojnd - Raja u rocked. And you have added Daler Mehndi to your list of attempted singers. What a relief at least one singer understands his strengths and sticks to them.

Amanat - v good, but this song is not your style.

Aneek - v v good. But song selection for both A and A could be better, at this stage u need sure fire superhits, not just hit songs.

Not a very memorable episode.

Friday's Show:
I was totally disappointed today..felt that all the three were not at their best..may be lot of stress or less time to practice, whatever be the reason, it was not upto the mark..

Ist round:
Aneek - 9.5
Amanat - 9.5
Raja - 7. I felt his voice lacked the softness that was essential for the song. Wrong choice

2nd round:
Raja - 9. Though he didn't hit the notes properly at many places, overall he was good.
Aneek - 7.5 Completely bad choice..
Amanat - 7 Again I felt this song didn't suit him.
Aneek and Amanat could hv chosen better songs.

3rd round:
Raja - 9. He was out of breath in this song.
Amanat - 9. Good but could hv been better.
Aneek - 9.5 He was the best in this round.

Overall the episode failed to meet my expectations.
😡

Lots of show, perfoemance.
singing quality was less than expected, in second and third round choice of song could be better by respective contestant. last week I thought better is yet to come of their singing but look like this is it.

Originally posted by: lifeztuf

I was totally disappointed today..felt that all the three were not at their best..may be lot of stress or less time to practice, whatever be the reason, it was not upto the mark..

Ist round:
Aneek - 9.5
Amanat - 9.5
Raja - 7. I felt his voice lacked the softness that was essential for the song. Wrong choice

2nd round:
Raja - 9. Though he didn't hit the notes properly at many places, overall he was good.
Aneek - 7.5 Completely bad choice..
Amanat - 7 Again I felt this song didn't suit him.
Aneek and Amanat could hv chosen better songs.

3rd round:
Raja - 9. He was out of breath in this song.
Amanat - 9. Good but could hv been better.
Aneek - 9.5 He was the best in this round.

Overall the episode failed to meet my expectations.
😡

biswita & lifeztuf -Thank you for such an unbiased rating 😊
I wasn't too happy with the show today either. And I so hate it when everyone has to come on stage and dance.

The show stealer this week was the live orchestra back in action !!!!!

On Friday the violin round was excellent. The performances were top class. Amanat was the best followed by Aneek and Raja was third. Raja was good but I prefer the original version.

Did not like the guitar round one bit. There are far better songs for the guitar round. Of the lot Raja was the best in this round, followed by Aneek and then Amanat. Ismailji was right when he scolded Raja and Amanat. They both could have done much better.

The third Round , all threew were brilliant.

On saturday felt the scene was too perfromance oriented and there were way too many celebrity guests. I am really mad with Asian television Network(ATN ), our Zee channel provider for editing the "once more's of Amanats !😡

Saturday they all performed very well, but the best was undoubtedly Amanat and his last song Tujhse Naraaz Nahi Zindagi"..In a flash he changed the mood from masti to emotional.

Sekhar is indeed right when he says Amanat is the most versatile singer of the show. I simply wish there was a way he could become #1...

Lets see what the final results tell next week.

Saturday was a pretty much forgettable episode, except for Amanat''s last song

Originally posted by: biswita

Saturday was a pretty much forgettable episode, except for Amanat''s last song

Singing wise actually all three were top class on the songs they sang. Did not much like all the songs but that is another story, but these 3 did full justice to the songs allotted to them but yes, Amanats last song was great.

Good show good comments... some time felt too much talks...phir bhi acha tha...

BUT
i felt the comments were readymade.. 😃

Originally posted by: advil

Singing wise actually all three were top class on the songs they sang. Did not much like all the songs but that is another story, but these 3 did full justice to the songs allotted to them but yes, Amanats last song was great.

Saturday's show was a circus with over 30 clowns including the mentors ... the gimmicks, the star cast and all the commotion was an irritant ... and the music was somewhere lost ...

All of the three, Amanat, Aneek and Raja performed admirably though ... as regards to the 'Tujhsey Naaraj Nahin' song, whenever I have heard this song whether it be the Anup Ghoshal version (male) or the Lata version (female), I have been moved beyond words .... I don't think the lyrics of any other song impinge on reality so closely (I had even mentioned this in one thread on the best lyrics way way back) .... and anybody who has an attachment with the real world is bound to be affected ....

Whenver RDB and Gulzar has come together, magic has been created .. whether it be Aandhi, Izaajat or Masoom or any other ...

😊

aaj agar bhar aayee hai.. boonde baras jaaengee
kal kya pataa in ke liye.. aankhein taras jaaengee
jjane kab gum hua, kahaan khoyaa
ek aasoo chhupaa ke rakhaa thaa..

tuzse naaraaj nahee srgmp, hairaan hoon main
HR ke bekaar drame se pareshaan hoo mai 😳 ...

well, LOVED ALL 3 contestants on SAT. 👏

Bringing 22 judges on stage was "pushing it", but none the less, the promotion made me wanna watch the movie.
Dino din't look hot enough.. 😕
I loved ARA's comments and language 👏 👏 👏 .. what a treat!

ALL 3 Contestants ROCKED today!! I'll miss them 😭 .. and wish them tons of success..
VS were rocking, ID was emotional, HR a wee bit more tamed than usual after finishing his aneek-publicity-via-every-skirt-on-stage 🤢 drama.

I was very touched by Amanat's perfromance. I wish him a very sweet happy reunion with his family soon. May God bless!