Your opinion on this weeks show - Page 4

Originally posted by: rrr111rrr

RAJA IS BEST.............PLEASE VOTE FOR HIM...DO NOT TAKE HIMESH SERIOUSLY...NOW HE HAS STARTED ANOTHER DRAMA OF "Auraton ka votes" I am just bored of him....so PLEASE VOTE FOR A GREAT SINGLER LIKE RAJA

This thread is meant for opinion on the show and is NOT the canvassing ground. Please stop writing in all caps.Its taken as shouting .

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar

Okay Adi..you asked for it...

Here is my extremely UNbiased opinion...

1st set of songs...

Aneek: WOWZER...10/10

Raja: 2/10

Amanat: 1.5/10

2nd set of songs...

Aneek: Outstanding...10/10

Raja: 1.5/10

Amanat: 1.0/10

3rd set of songs...

Aneek: Mindblowing...10/10

Raja: 1.0/10

Amanat: 0.5/10

Total: Aneek: 30/30. Raja: 4.5/30 (not bad) and Amaanat 3/30 (not too bad)

😆

btw: i have yet to watch the show..😆

Manish yeh kya tha main agar raja aur aneek ka ratings ulta pulta kar doon toh I mean Raja 30/30 and Aneek 4.5/30

it was another disappointing episode for me.

Over all for today-
Raja > Amanat > Aneek

none to remember.
Adnan Sami was very cewl and very tiny compared to when I last saw him. VS - great energy.. ID- he bashed amanat way more than he deserved..
everybody could have / should have done much better i thought :)

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

it was another disappointing episode for me.

Over all for today-
Raja > Amanat > Aneek

none to remember.
Adnan Sami was very cewl and very tiny compared to when I last saw him. VS - great energy.. ID- he bashed amanat way more than he deserved..
everybody could have / should have done much better i thought :)

😆

i was eagerly waiting for your sweet comments and in last as expected😉...

if they read you comments they will shout only one thing..

arrey, bache ki jaan loge kya....

Originally posted by: guess_gallery

😆

i was eagerly waiting for your sweet comments and in last as expected😉...

if they read you comments they will shout only one thing..

arrey, bache ki jaan loge kya....

ahmed, can't help i have high standards and expectations!

bacche made me very happy last friday.. they raised their own bar. how can they drop it now 😳😳..
i wish all well and acknowledge their talent. but they gotta remember people like poonam, sumedha and musarrat have left the stage and these 3 have huge responsibility in every performance to justify the previous eliminations.. that's my opinion..

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

ahmed, can't help i have high standards and expectations!

bacche made me very happy last friday.. they raised their own bar. how can they drop it now 😳😳..

arrey subhagya ji...

i know we all expect rocking performance..

i hope some times your expectation bar drops😆😆😆..

programe very dull like adnan no charm i am waiting for today and than tell you by that time i am voting to Amanat coz he is still upper than others as singer.

Adnan was rocking! 👏

I enjoyed Raja's performance the most in Rounds 1 and 2 and Aneek's the most in Round 3.

Aneek's 2nd song selection was almost as bad as Mauli's Taal se Taal Mila. Why on earth is he picking such songs? 😕 Contrary to popular belief, he cannot rap well and this song completely exposed him.

Amanat disappointed me a great deal. His song selections were good, but his perfomance wasn't impressive.

Overall Raja > Aneek > Amanat

First of all great live orchestra 👏, i think they were the clear winners in todays episode & Adnan was as usual sweet & short in his comments, but somehow i feel he enjoyed his presence on II more than here. He showed more involvement there compared to SRGMP. Probably Adnan bore in his mind that ID had made fun of Adnan's singing in an earlier episode asking Joy to sing in a lemon-stuffed-mouth style to sound like Adnan's deep voice.


Now coming to performances;

1st round: Great song selection, fabulous & soulful performances from all three

Aneek: Good expression of pain, right feel and perfect singing

Amanat:Great song selection, perfect for Amanat & he did fair justice to the song.

Raja: Again one of my favourite songs and he brought out the romance in this song very effectively.

My ranking for the first round 1.Amanat, 2. Aneek, 3. Raja

2nd round:This was a real test since all the three were attempting new songs and some how reflects their futures if they decide to pursue playback singing.

Raja:Perfect song for him and he gave a mellifluous performance quite different from his mostly usual high energy ventures, he indeed has improved a lot with soft songs & low notes. HR even though gave a long boring lecture on Raja's singing, was right on target when he said that Raja's unique voice with perfect singing could do wonders for his career, which should be taken by Raja in the true spirit, and contrary to popular belief this was not Raja bashing by HR but a sincere advice from a marketing genius to a budding bundle of talent that Raja is.

Aneek: I would not call it a rank bad performance, but clearly not an enjoyable performance. I hate rap(wonder why they call it music) and Aneek should try & avoid such songs in the future which are not his strengtht. He was good in the Hare ram parts but the transition from English to Hindi was not upto the mark.

Amanat:I would appreciate him for his brave attempt in going for an untested song, but some thing was clearly missing in his rendition, it was a very strained performance rightly pointed out by his guru, but Amanat will have a lot of time to practice for such songs in the future & with proper guidance from a good MD he will certainly be a singer to look out for in the future.(He had mentioned in a chat with his fans that he recently has recovered from a bout of tonsilitis, which affected his throat & breathing, hope he gets back into form at the earliest)

Ranking for the second round: 1. Raja, 2. Aneek, 3.Amanat

Third round was the usual popular songs routine which we have been witnessing all these days, those songs which many of us might have heard a million times.

Raja: Tailor made song for him(recommended to him by joie-de-vivre through this forum). He started well, boosted by the presence of his gurus VS on the stage, but lost steam midway through the song and finally losing it. One thing i feel Raja should improve is his landing notes which are not rounded enough robbing the sheen of his performances. He is the king of high energy songs, but he clearly faltered with Rang-de-Basanti especially towards the end when his initial energy started petering out, showing evident loss of breathlessness and abrupt ending of lines.(Even last weeks Chaiyya Chaiyya had the same faults). So please buck up Raja, you are certainly the find of SRGMP.

Amanat:Back to his usual perfection self, he lifted himself with this rocking performance & showed his versatility & class. Hope he continues in the same stead.

Aneek: What a splendid comeback, he set the stage on fire with the performance of the evening. High energetic singing which made everybody to dance to his tunes, that is what we are looking in a high class singer, the ability to capture the mood of the audience and make them sway in admiration. But one thing which annoyed me was he again choose a song with a mix of hindi & english lines, fortunately he carried them well this time.

Third round:1.Aneek, 2. Amanat, 3. Raja

Overall a fairly entertaining episode, but feeling a bit let down comparing it to last week's heavenly experiences.

Originally posted by: dhruvie05

First round-I think all three performed well. Amanat's song did'nt suit him that well I felt..If I have to rate, I wud say Aneek was the best, followed closely by Raja and then Amanat.. Second round-pathetic song selection 🤢 ..did'nt enjoy it at all! First Raja sang, and I thought Oh God! did'nt they find any better song for the guitar round?! Then Aneek rapped, and I thought Raja's song was better than this..then Amanat, and I thought..never mind! Singing-wise too, I thought I felt Raja, Aneek then Amanat.. Third round-it was a relief to see VS back on the sets..loaded with enthusiasm and energy! They lended full support to Raja and stressed on the fact that he sang the Saiyyaan song very well (ofcourse it was not that great as they made it sound, but still I appreciate the mentor-support)..

Performance-wise, I felt Raja was getting breathless in this round, even though he was standing still and singing, and not dancing and jumping like last week 😕But he sangthe song really well with a lot of energy andlike Adnan pointed outrightly, his voice has that throw whichis impressive!Amanat technically sang the song very well, just that I wish he wud pronounce the words more clearly as he tends to say them loosely..Aneek's performance was the best in this round.. So overall I think Aneek did better than the other two, followed by Raja and then Amanat today..

Btw I really enjoyed the live orchestra..boy! what a difference it makes compared to the tracks!I don't even want to get into the whole voting scenario, bcos I honestly don't understand how it works..somewhere I read that there are free sms voting booths in Raja and Aneek's towns..well that puts Amanat in a slight disadvantage, does'nt it? (if that info is to be believed) 😕 According to me all three are already winners, with soooo much of exposure and recognition 👏 👏 👏

Ditto.....Totally. My feelings exactly!! 😃