Amanat vs raja - Page 3

raja beats every1 hands down-no contest

@Hirni.. Sorry I beg to differ, taking nothing away from Raja, Amanat is a better singer, has a much better voice than Raja, suitable for Ghazal, Classical & play back singing alike, has consistency as his middle name...as for the looks, Amanat wins hands down in my eyes, but then who cares abt it in a singing contest? if they did Juni & Sumi would have never left!

Personally,I feel Amanat's voice per se is run of the mill...Sure he had tremendous control over sur,taal yada yada...But there are LOADS AND LOADS of singers like Amanat why are struggling to get a break!!.Personally,I can ramble off names like Amey Date, Karunya, Arijit Singh, Hemachandra who are as good as Amanat, if not better....

In today's day and age,only a singer who can create his own niche is being recognised.....Rahet Fateh Ali Khan,Himesh Reshammiya,Sunidhi Chauhan,Caralisa to cite a few..There are a barrage of singers who can sing better than HR,Rahet etc,but what makes them click is their idiosyncratic voice quality,the freshness the lend to the song, their own stamp......Raja in that mould,in their league...I'm looking at their commercial viability...I see Raja as a more successful singer in future than Amanat,only due to his unique voice which cannot be replicated!!Finally it boils down to getting offers and being successfully established playback singer,isnt it?? 🤔 Just my views,personal thoughts and opinions...

Originally posted by: swifthorse

@Hirni.. Sorry I beg to differ, taking nothing away from Raja, Amanat is a better singer, has a much better voice than Raja, suitable for Ghazal, Classical & play back singing alike, has consistency as his middle name...as for the looks, Amanat wins hands down in my eyes, but then who cares abt it in a singing contest? if they did Juni & Sumi would have never left!

You kidding me mate??...Junaid voice was laced with hoarseness towards the end...He sounded gruffy !!!

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

You kidding me mate??...Junaid voice was laced with hoarseness towards the end...He sounded gruffy !!!

Hey my point being.. looks dont matter and looks do not a winner make! I was saying if people votes for looks then Junaid & Sumedha who not have left?

Originally posted by: swifthorse

Hey my point being.. looks dont matter and looks do not a winner make! I was saying if people votes for looks then Junaid & Sumedha who not have left?

Foot in the mouth moment😳...Forgive me,I misconstrued what you said!!

I disagree

Amanat is goodlooking (more then raja)
Amanat is versatile Raja isn't
Amanat has an fresh new voice Raja voice looks like Sukwinder/Kailesh and we already have those 2.

Raja is far better than amanat in many points.
As this is a singing competition, first lets take up that.

- Amanat is a good singer and perfect in his Surs. But that charm which is there in Raja's voice is missing in amanat's singing. Raja takes u completely to a different world by his sweet voice.

And now if we have to talk about looks,
- Raja has got innocence kie a child. Just look at his smile, you can make out how good he is by heart. So I don't think amanat will score more in this point as well.

So overall, Raja is the BEST.

Originally posted by: ummmmm

i disagree.

amanat is better looking. amanat is a better dancer. amanat has better stage presence. amanat has better expressions.amanat has lovely hair. amanat is a better performer.

VOTE FOR AMANAT!

And above all Amanat is a great singer. And not to forget his versatality in singing songs from different genres.
Raja can sing well, same type of songs.

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

Personally,I feel Amanat's voice per se is run of the mill...Sure he had tremendous control over sur,taal yada yada...But there are LOADS AND LOADS of singers like Amanat why are struggling to get a break!!.Personally,I can ramble off names like Amey Date, Karunya, Arijit Singh, Hemachandra who are as good as Amanat, if not better....

In today's day and age,only a singer who can create his own niche is being recognised.....Rahet Fateh Ali Khan,Himesh Reshammiya,Sunidhi Chauhan,Caralisa to cite a few..There are a barrage of singers who can sing better than HR,Rahet etc,but what makes them click is their idiosyncratic voice quality,the freshness the lend to the song, their own stamp......Raja in that mould,in their league...I'm looking at their commercial viability...I see Raja as a more successful singer in future than Amanat,only due to his unique voice which cannot be replicated!!Finally it boils down to getting offers and being successfully established playback singer,isnt it?? 🤔 Just my views,personal thoughts and opinions...

You kidding me mate??...Junaid voice was laced with hoarseness towards the end...He sounded gruffy !!!

ur rite how can sum1 replicate a replicate singer!!!

first i wanna make this clear that i realllliii like raja but when u sed the works unique...i dont think so, he sounds like a lot of singers e.g kailash kher or sukwinder singh!

where as amanat he's got a different vioce from all the other singer.

but i'm also not sayin that raja cud have a successful singin career cuz he does have a powerful voice, but i dont think that his voice is very unique as when u listen to the song he sang of sukwinder, he sounds very much like him (chaiya chaiya)

if i misunderstood ur comment plz notify me😃

wow...the debate still goes on...... 😊

Beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder...
but listening too lies in the taste of the listener......