History repeats again***Spoiler*** - Page 5

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Why are you all comparing between Nihira and Sumedha. I never said that Sumedha was better or Nihira was better. I feel that they were the best female contestants of each season. You all are more than welcome to disagree. During C2005 lot of our members thought that Himani was better than Nihira. And that's fine. Its their personal opinion.

Coming to Raja's consistancy. He is highly inconsistant. Initially he was in Eklavya gharana. Came to the contest and gave some brilliant performances and then got eliminated for some bad performances. Again came back with a bang and gave outstanding performances for few weeks, but for the last three weeks he is quite bad. This week either Raja or Poonam should have been eliminated in an ideal world.

People of Rajasthan is equally crazy as the people of W.B. and entire northeast when it comes to crazy voting. Didn't Rajasthan make Sandeep Acharya the winner of II2, although Karunya was the favorite.

I totally agree with you.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Harpreet and Mussarat were better singers than Sumedha in my opinion....Also, in the episode Akhsay came she got very poor marks so she should have been out(according to ur logic) but Harpreet was out 😉 ..in her last performance she was told by two judges to take care of her sur ..infact has been repeatedly told by judges to take care of her notes although she has a very beautiful voice.....
Now, coming to Raja his 'Pardesi' performance was not his best but still better than Mudssarat's signal so why should he be eliminated...

btw how do u know rest of India was on Karunya's side 😕 rest of India was divided ....but he had very low support from his home state...also there were reasons which are beyond the scope of discussion in this forum...

Originally posted by: jugalbaj

If somebody says Raja is inconsistent thats not right.

I think except for one or two performances he was always up to the mark.

Last three weeks;

1)Ankhiyan no chain naa aawe( better than NFAK)
2)Kesariya Balam (Excellent only singer to sing real folk song in that episode)
3)Aaake sidhi lagi ( was very good)
4)Pardesi Pardesi ( Bad)
5)Hum thi woh thi (Excellent)
6)Tenu leke (Start bad but end very excellent)

So his only one performance was bad.But if anybody has preference for any other contestent and is not neutral then the opinion will never change'

good effort 👏....there is only one bad performance ..even Pardesi was not as bad as it was made out to be by HR....

Originally posted by: tindrum

Harpreet and Mussarat were better singers than Sumedha in my opinion....

Sure dear, you are entitled to your opinion. Everyone has got one.......

Also, in the episode Akhsay came she got very poor marks so she should have been out(according to ur logic) but Harpreet was out 😉 ..

in her last performance she was told by two judges to take care of her sur ..infact has been repeatedly told by judges to take care of her notes although she has a very beautiful voice.....

Take care of her sur does not mean besura. As ID said "sometimes you hit the high notes very easily, and sometimes it seems strained, does not mean besura. There is always scope of improvement for every singer.

Now, coming to Raja his 'Pardesi' performance was not his best but still better than Mudssarat's signal so why should he be eliminated...

Well, then why did you forget Mussarat's performace on Saturday. It was way better than Raja's.

btw how do u know rest of India was on Karunya's side 😕 rest of India was divided ....but he had very low support from his home state...also there were reasons which are beyond the scope of discussion in this forum...

If India was divided, say 50, 50. (Which it was not. It was more like 65, 35 in favor of Karunya) Then some state must have voted like crazy to get Sandeep the lead.

Originally posted by: jugalbaj

apparaohoare,

I wont argue becoz I dont want to.

I am not a pandit in music.

Calling me immature is I feel a personal attack.

Dont reply please its ok.No problems.

I apologise. But comparing a legendary singer with a singer of two days is just wrong.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Mods: Its not actually a spoiler, but the result of this week is here, so I put spoiler.

Lets compare C2007 with C2005.

1. The best female singer gets eliminated on the 5th spot - Nihira and now Sumedha. (Both with very sweet voice and personality)

2. One judge starts acting like a monkey on steroids when it comes to final 5 - However, thats a constant.

3. One gharana is left with two contestant - 1 boy and 1 girl. Both very good. Specially the boy (Hema and Amanat). Both the girls have a husky robust voice (Himani and Poonam)

4. There is always a male contestant who is a victim of other mentors - Debu and Raja.

5. One mentor always acts like a lap dog of Himesh, and that mentor has the maximum contestants left - Its was Adesh in C 2005, and Ismail in C 2007.

6. ID always has one contestant with "Ma" issues - Debu and Poonam.

7. Himmy always have only one contestant left, and he has to be a shorty and has to fall in love - Vinit and Aneek.

8. There is always one mentor who is very fair and wants to stay out of all dramas as they feel suffocated - Ismail in 2005 VS in 2007.

9. The same fair mentor's contestant has a huge regional support and has a very likeable personality, and also very inconsistant when it comes to performances - Debu and Raja

10. One mentor always stages a walkout and comes back - ID and BL

So now can we expect a walkout by the contestants next week (Aneek, Amanat, and Poonam) because Raja is on the top on the voting chart - Last time too it was HR and his lap dog's contestants who staged the walk out.

So, does that mean, that RAJA will be the winner of C 2007??????????????????

Your views please. Please forgive my term like "lap dogs". I could not think of a better term. Also please forgive me for the spelling errors, my keyboard is acting up.

Simply brilliant great comparison between C 2005 with C 2007.!!

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

I apologise. But comparing a legendary singer with a singer of two days is just wrong.

True he is legendary singer....but then it's not impossible to sing better than him.....

Sometimes shagirdh beats the guru too....

Such is the truth of life...that in time someone better will come....intially we all dislike the comparison but eventually become more accepting...

Maybe with time......

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

"sur par dhyan dijiye" is a polite way of saying u r straying from it 😊 and not just once many times(esp by VS and I think their opinion carries weight)...I am not saying that she is a bad singer or anything ...

If Mussarat's perf was good on Sat( He didn't get perfect 10 infact Vishal told him sur ajeeb se lag rahe the ) so was Raja's performance on Friday and voting is based on both performances ...

Well, I 'll leave the Karunya topic coz as I hv already said there were strong reasons which cannot be discussed here...