Why Amanat.......? - Page 3

Originally posted by: *xsaher jaanx*

i love love love love love amanatttttttttt

haila! me too!lolz!😆

temi:

i don't know whether i should answer your question because you seem to be taking things to emotionally and suggest that just because someone may disagree with amanat as the top singer in saregamapa....that it's due to only personal factors.

I think he is technically sound when it comes to songs that are ghazals/semi-classical.

i don't think he is a versatile singer.He often lacks the feel or energy required for songs that are extremely high-pitched.

i think if you give him a year to improve....i have no doubt he'll attain some versatality.

as of now, i don't feel he is a complete, all-round singer.

my opinion, i like semi-classical songs.....so i might pick him as the winner based on that criteria...but that wouldn't be a fair assessment.

Originally posted by: tripler

temi:

i don't know whether i should answer your question because you seem to be taking things to emotionally and suggest that just because someone may disagree with amanat as the top singer in saregamapa....that it's due to only personal factors.

I think he is technically sound when it comes to songs that are ghazals/semi-classical.

i don't think he is a versatile singer.He often lacks the feel or energy required for songs that are extremely high-pitched.

i think if you give him a year to improve....i have no doubt he'll attain some versatality.

as of now, i don't feel he is a complete, all-round singer.

my opinion, i like semi-classical songs.....so i might pick him as the winner based on that criteria...but that wouldn't be a fair assessment.

I see what you're saying. But do we actually have a singer who's completely versatile and an all-rounder on the show presently?

Originally posted by: Temi

haila! me too!lolz!😆

i'm in the club too!😆

for others, i respect ur opinion when u say that amanat is not versatile, but i'll have to completely disagree...he's proves various times he can sing any song he wants and i have no doubt on his talent....he always has energy in his songs like when he sang koi mil gaya...there's always room of improvement of course but i dont think he has a very long way to go as a singer😊👏

I dont hate Amanat. I dont think he is a versatile singer.

I would like to see Poonam and Aneek in final

Amanat is a good singer. 😊

I would like to know what made you think that people hate Amanat ? I have seen even people who are fans of other contestants never deny that Amanat is a good singer.

idk why anyone wouldnt like Amanat as a singer b/c he IS versatile...
and what's to hate about him? he's such a sweet laid-back kinda nice guy 😛
but i'd never bash Amanat 😳 im def. his fan... 😃
Amanat should win this competition!

Amanat is a great guy, a good singer, and shud definitely reach the finals. People are just looking for an opportunity to put him down and they get personal becos they can find nothing else to say. His performances have been quite consistent. He has a great voice and is in every way fit to be in the final. Amanat rocks 👏

Originally posted by: bittersweet93

i'm in the club too!😆

for others, i respect ur opinion when u say that amanat is not versatile, but i'll have to completely disagree...he's proves various times he can sing any song he wants and i have no doubt on his talent....he always has energy in his songs like when he sang koi mil gaya...there's always room of improvement of course but i dont think he has a very long way to go as a singer😊👏

omg i am soooo in the club too

those people who dont like amanat and think he is versetile seriously need a reality check cuz either they are jealous or have nothin better to do than critiseze sum1 elses talent. a guy who can sing yeh honsla as good as he can sing koi mil gaya - i think he is versetile enough!!!