poonam should be out now

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

126529

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

#41

everyone give me an answer for my post. but i have qouestion to all of them if poonam is good singer why she didn't get any break in any movie for singing. even ismile darbar doesn't giver her any break in movie. (ismile darbar bhi vishal shekhar se poonam ko gavane ke liye kaha.) almost everyone get chance to sing in movie except poonam. so i think u all says that all music director are dumb and they don't know singing. even himesh didn't even give her chance.

Quote

Mistyy

@Mistyy

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: priya1978
everyone give me an answer for my post. but i have qouestion to all of them if poonam is good singer why she didn't get any break in any movie for singing. even ismile darbar doesn't giver her any break in movie. (ismile darbar bhi vishal shekhar se poonam ko gavane ke liye kaha.) almost everyone get chance to sing in movie except poonam. so i think u all says that all music director are dumb and they don't know singing. even himesh didn't even give her chance.

ok so when Vishal - shekhar told her that her last performance of movie Taal was ONE OF THE BEST PERFORMACE OF SAREGAMA, they were lying to her😕..when Vishal almost had tears after listening her "Vande Matram" song..he was faking it.!! All these standing ovations she got from judges..was it a joke???

When many guest judges including Lara Dutta, Salman told her that this was the most powerful voice they heard in long time...WERE THEY ALSO FAKING???

Plz STOP being so unreasonable..even u know in ur heart that she is not barely there caz of sympathy but caz of her talent..!!

And about the breaks from judges, i think Bappida and Vishal-Shekhar has already signed her. HR doesn't sign anone so easily..and ID is not doing any work..so STOP BASHING HER😡😡

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

gopalbhai

@gopalbhai

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: priya1978
everyone give me an answer for my post. but i have qouestion to all of them if poonam is good singer why she didn't get any break in any movie for singing. even ismile darbar doesn't giver her any break in movie. (ismile darbar bhi vishal shekhar se poonam ko gavane ke liye kaha.) almost everyone get chance to sing in movie except poonam. so i think u all says that all music director are dumb and they don't know singing. even himesh didn't even give her chance.

If you use this logic of if she is a good singer then why she did not get any offer for singing ? Then there is a scope for rigging by giving offers for singing to participants to show that they are good in singing. Exactly this is being used to hype up the contestants by announcing singing offers right there in the show.

They are good music directors they cannot be dumb, they know more music then all of us ?

They can be sometimes dumb though not all the time. Once during Asha Ji's stint as Mahaguru , all of them were going ga ga over the performance of one of the participants(thought i forgot who it was) and gave all the great comments but Asha Ji caught them and gave them all dressing down by saying "Bolo ye sur se hili thi ya nehi? ", then all of them were dumb and they had now anser.

Any of these mentors of these mentors had the capability to make someone a singer ?

Actually ID once carelessly and emotionally said to a participant " Tumko main singer banaungga!". Asha Ji shot back by saying " Koi kisiko banata nehi , wo(pointing at sky) banake bhejta hain".

Can she become a playback singer ?

Well there be thousands who might think so. But Asha ji has complemented Poonam by saying "Aap playback singer ban sakta hain". So at least Asha Ji thinks that Poonam has the potential to become a playback singer

Quote

shineyyy

@shineyyy

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#44

plllllllllllzzzzzzzzz dont compare poonam ad mauli.poonam is da best female cotestan of saregamapa

Quote

Barnali

@Barnali

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Do you really think, these offer decides a good or bad singer? If this is the criteria then Aneek should be out before Poonam... He is winner of SRGMP Bengali, he is singing in this show but still did not get a single offer from these mentors or in Bengali movie/serial... So he should be out according to your criteria...

No Jaadoo Bhaiya aneek has three movies already in his biodata where he has already sung. Shantanu Moitra's "Little Krishna", Shamir Tandon's "Bal ganesha" and Bappida's Love.com.

But i agree completely with u that these are not the points thats decide who is a better singer.....and how can ID giv her a chance when he himself is looking for one! 😛 I hv a feeling poonam may not be the winner....but she would be the winner among girls this time.She is the most consistant performaer of the show. maybe in few songs she was bit jarring at high notes but her one song.... Vende Mataram says all about the calibre of singer that she is.

Edited by Barnali - 18 years ago

Quote

Zaara saberi

@Bananamilkshake

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: Chief Saab

agree

agar versatility ki baat aati he to there are only 3 singers who u can say that they r versatile singers .. Poonam , Aneek , Amanat .. you are absolutly right!!!!!!!😃

Quote

Govind Deshmukh

@corvallisi

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#47

What I would like to know is "is Bappi giving music to any movies currently or is it a showmanship to hide his unemployment? I have not heard of any movie named "Balle Balle" or something like that. You remember, Himesh opened his big mouth when Nihira sang Chalka and asked her to come to some sound studio follwing Monday? Has it ever happened? I think these MDs make such statements just to throw dust in public eyes to make themselves look good. There are some MDs who do not talk but just act, such as Aadesh Srivastav who gave opportunities to Hemachandra, Nihira and Himani. He never publicly promised any one of giving chance. So, Bappi Lahiri might be a big baloon of hot air.

So, do not judge a contestant on how many fake promises that contestants has gotten. None of those promises may materialize.

Edited by corvallisi - 18 years ago

Quote

Martand

@Martand

Dazzler

Posted: 18 years ago

#48

Poonam ka matla bhi jante ho tum ...Poonam ka matlab hai ek pyari beti..Aur beti ko ghar se jaana hi hota hai...Wo jayegi jaroor par khoob mota dahej leke (I mean lots of work)...

Quote

atria

@atria

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: priya1978
everyone give me an answer for my post. but i have qouestion to all of them if poonam is good singer why she didn't get any break in any movie for singing. even ismile darbar doesn't giver her any break in movie. (ismile darbar bhi vishal shekhar se poonam ko gavane ke liye kaha.) almost everyone get chance to sing in movie except poonam. so i think u all says that all music director are dumb and they don't know singing. even himesh didn't even give her chance.

Himesh hasn't given anyone a chance to sing in his movies. Even Vineet from last time who was his absolute favourite was given chances to sing in concerts, but not in movies. ID doesn't have any movies in hand. And VS have already signed a contract with her. So its not true that Poonam isn't getting chances, she's getting as much chance as the rest of them. All of them recognize her talent.👏

Quote

BibiS

@BibiS

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#50

Huhhhhh? You HATE Poonam? What did she do to upset you? 😕

I think Poonam is a very talented singer, with confidence and a very powerful voice, anyone with ears would surely even half agree with that!

Even if people don't like the fact that judges keep on bringing her personal life into this, it doesn't change the fact that she's a good singer 😡

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

poonam should be out now - Page 5

Related Topics

Explore Topics