Relate C'07 contestants to C'05 - Page 2

Originally posted by: SGMPfan2

I think Vinit has a more powerful voice than Aneek. Aneek's voice still needs to mature a bit more. But yeah the similarity because they have the same guru is the idiotic love shyte and singing Sonu type songs (that's what his mentor wants him to do poor fella)

true...Vinit never gave a single dissapointing performance and never got below 8 on the Mento Meter..

Aneek is definately like Vinit! When I saw his performance for the first time, he soo sounded like Vinit, and plus, they have another thing in common, HIMESH AS A GURU WHO LOVES THEM!!!!

I still think that Vinit had more confidence and more of a WOW factor than Aneek, but they're both good singers.

The rest of them have unique voices.

Originally posted by: sp_2012

nahh i dont think so

Twinkle's sur was horrible

Mauli I think was far better than Twinkle

When Twinkle started Challenge 2005, she had some terrific performances like Daiya yeh main kahan aa phasi and tumhe yaad karte karte. She had a great voice. But then later in the show, it was clear she wasn't practicing because her voice became hoarse and horrible and her tuning went way off. By the time she got to EMET, she was terrible. I felt bad because she started so good.

My favorites from C05 were Himani and Nihira. Both of them rarely ever slipped . I don't think they had even one performance u can call "bad"

Originally posted by: sp_2012

Relate the contestants of Challenge 2007 to the ones on Challenge 2005

I'll start...I think that

Aneek remindes me of Vinit...because of all the love stuff created by HR and in my opinion, Aneek's voice sumwhat resembles Vinit's voice

Sumedha reminds me of Nihira because they both have a high-pitched voice.

Poonam reminds me of Himani because...well i dont know she just does 😆😕

Who else in your opinion relates to the contestants of Challenge 05?

I don't think you can compare Sumedha with Nihira, Nihira has avery sweet voice as well as her sur is perfect and that is not the case with Sumedha.

^^^Sumi in no way can b compared to Nihira!She's average...Poonam is way better but even she cannot b compared to Nihira!
No1 in C07 reminds me of C05...

Originally posted by: ms_naughty_devi

Yeah she was alot better but they're both into dancing/performing and acting as well so they seem very similiar to me at times!😛

Yh I agree out of all the contestants from Challenge 2007 Mauli can be compared with Twinkle because of performance... but I think Twinkle is better... she has had some great performanes in Challenge 2005 such as: Daiya Yeh Main, Hungama Ho Gaya, Chot Dil Pe Lagi and she was brilliant in EMAET along with Vishwas

Aneek definitely reminds me of Vinit but nobody reminds me of Nihira or Hema....No comparison at all.

aneek reminds me of vineet because their voices are very similar and also himesh's attitude towards them.

mauli can be compared to twinkle because they both had horrible singing near the end and focused a lot more on performance.

no one reminds me of my favourites hemachandra and nihira, not because they are not as good, but because they are all good but different from each other.

Nihira = Nihira period.

Sumedha = Ujjaini

Poonam = Poonam, may be = Himani

Anik = 3/4 Vinit

Debojeet = 0

Amanat = 1/2 Hemachandra

Musarrat = less than 0

Raja = Rajiv

Mauli = 1/10 Twinkle

^Agree w all of d above cept Hemu...he was much much much better than Amanat... 👏