HR's confrontation of Raja ;good or bad. - Page 2

When did we last see someone being humiliated for an average performance.On the same day Aneek was not at his best and VS politely conveyed it to him. HR continued to praise Aneek.When Raja was singing HR looked almost irritated right from the beginning and before anyone could say anything he jumped on him.And not just his singing , he pointed fingers at his honesty too.This is an issue with HR's ego and love for his fav contestant.

This is all too controversial and Himesh should not have been so hard on Raja in Public, for a little lapse in his singing. Perhaps it was not his intention and as the conversation dragged it became worse. Well being adults they should be able to clear the air and work together. No one has any complaint or dissatisfaction if Raja is declared the overall winner because he truly deserves so.

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

No, it was not about making Raja accept that Raja is a great singer. The conversation prolonged because Raja said he did not know where he had gone wrong. HR's point was , being a great singer that Raja is, how can it be that Raja does not know where he had gone wrong? In fact HR went went to the dias with Raja and demonstrated how the lines should have been sung!

ohhhhhhhhh ok...darn it...I shud stop blocking HR when gives his opinions😳😆...per kya karein... even in those couple minutes he starts singing😭😡 ...😆

I have no doubt on Himesh as music director. Raja made him stupid by saying "agar mujhe pata hota toh competition me kyun ataa" .. this is the first time I heard from a contestent something like that .. definitely Raja was off track quite a few times .. Himesh's point was he is a great singer so he should identify his faults too .. Raja is much much hyped .. now he thinks he is always correct ...

Aneek was also commented on saturday .. but he humbly accepted it .. so was Mussarat few days back ..

I feel HR was just stating the fact

Originally posted by: kuchikoo

I have no doubt on Himesh as music director. Raja made him stupid by saying "agar mujhe pata hota toh competition me kyun ataa" .. this is the first time I heard from a contestent something like that .. definitely Raja was off track quite a few times .. Himesh's point was he is a great singer so he should identify his faults too .. Raja is much much hyped .. now he thinks he is always correct ...

thats what i thought. himesh didn't start a random fight with raja, HR told Raja that he must of knew he was off sur but Raja completely denied that he knew he was off sur. Thus, himesh got mad about how could a contestant like Raja who sings at such a high level not know when he is making mistakes and afterall Raja is classically trained (i think by his father as they showed in one of his video packages) so how does he not know where he is making a mistake in sur?

HR was using a tactful two edged sword in this matter and the ultimate objective is to help Aneek and write off Raja from the show.

HR needs to consult a good manners consultant. 😡

Originally posted by: Anhsirk

This is all too controversial and Himesh should not have been so hard on Raja in Public, for a little lapse in his singing. Perhaps it was not his intention and as the conversation dragged it became worse. Well being adults they should be able to clear the air and work together. No one has any complaint or dissatisfaction if Raja is declared the overall winner because he truly deserves so.

I agree..Why did Zee not edit these portions?

Originally posted by: sibal52

HR was using a tactful two edged sword in this matter and the ultimate objective is to help Aneek and write off Raja from the show.

I agree, he sees Raja as the greatest threat to Aneek and as the competition is getting tighter, he will use every tactic to get anyone out, so that Aneek can go on to win. I hope the public is smart enough to see through this drama of HR's. I felt that VS should have defended Raja a bit. Why were they quiet?

I thought that Raja took it well, but he spoke up for himself. Raja will be in the top 3 this week, my gut feeling.