Mussarat scores 29 Mouli 30 - Page 4

Originally posted by: dhruvie05

Not only Mussarat, but Poonam also didnt get full 30, whereas Mauli did! I am not saying that Mauli sang bad..infact yday was one of the few times she actually did well..but a perfect 30 score for her and not for these two?

If I remember right, when ID requested for 10 points from VS for Poonam saying sabka aaj 19-20 ho raha hai, Shekhar said that we want 20 and not 19..so does he think Mauli is always 20 and never 19?? 😕 Ouch for their music knowledge, in that case.. Bcos acc. to me as a singer Mauli is not close to 19-20, she is somewhere around 12 🤢

I was thinking the same..Yesterday, excluding Amanat, all others hv been 19-20 in surs..Did VS not notice Mauli was also 19-20??? Even Raja was off-key at some points yesterday..Then why this discrimination for Sumedha, Poonam, Mussarat??(although for Sumedha they gave 10 later after ID requested, but for Mauli it was a straightaway 10)..I agree Poonam had done a few mistakes here and there, but it was a difficult song, she deserved 9..but same way Mauli didn't deserve 10 either..She also deserved 8 not more than that..

Originally posted by: US_Zee_viewer

are you kidding me? you've got to be a relative of hers to say that because it doesn't take a genius to know mussarat owned everyone with his afarren performance.

i agree with you hun ^^, i didnt think mauli sang better then mussarat, but she did sing good😳

Originally posted by: US_Zee_viewer

you obviously don't know qawwali so don't make such statements! Just play the original singer's version of the song and you will see its the absolute same! Sur is not the problem! If your saving sur is the problem then you might as well be saying NFAK's sur is the problem!

Its quite evident that your making this statement on the basis that the majority are criticizing mauli (who deserves it)!

i gues u didnt get my point .. my main point is dat 29 is great... i havent heard da orignal.. i said maybe i dunno y dey gae it but dey prolly must have fel tosmehitng... ididnt say he did isaid maybe he didnt lose one point for nothin but its being mad a big deall 29us a eally gooodreusltt...

she doesnt desrve it dis time ok? she sang really well im not makin dis statemanty on dabasis of anyhitng i just said its a good score n its not dat big of a dela is someone got 1 point higher dne himm.. 29 was is good n he is also good mauli got 30 but she also sang really good...

Originally posted by: pyaari_puja

29 isnt soo bad ya noee... dey both fot good grades.. maybe he messed upa bit on his sur wich mite have cos thima point.. somethign.. but 29 is great

29 is good. And he was happy with it.

But on the sur part....

If you're saying he messed up on sur...

Then Mauli sang in complete sur?

Now I'm not a musician but am pretty sure he sang in sur. And Mauli shrieked so if shrieks and screams is sur then she should have gotten 20 😃

No one sings peerfectly but he did sooo much better than Mauli. And Mauli was decent today so he deserved it more. 😃

ur bein sarcastic right u betta b😆
cuz mussarat is wayyyyy betta den mauli.. n he so deserved 30!!

Originally posted by: pyaari_puja

i gues u didnt get my point .. my main point is dat 29 is great... i havent heard da orignal.. i said maybe i dunno y dey gae it but dey prolly must have fel tosmehitng... ididnt say he did isaid maybe he didnt lose one point for nothin but its being mad a big deall 29us a eally gooodreusltt...

she doesnt desrve it dis time ok? she sang really well im not makin dis statemanty on dabasis of anyhitng i just said its a good score n its not dat big of a dela is someone got 1 point higher dne himm.. 29 was is good n he is also good mauli got 30 but she also sang really good...

Here's original (he sang remix but this version isn't remix)

Closest I could find.

But I think he sang it better. (Mussarat!)

His voice is more polished and it was so smooth.

Wah Hmmm it was dreamy 😳

http://smashits.com/music/artists/songs/5055/roop-ki-dhoop.h tml

Originally posted by: Shukhsmiles:

]

29 is good. And he was happy with it.

But on the sur part....

If you're saying he messed up on sur...

Then Mauli sang in complete sur?

Now I'm not a musician but am pretty sure he sang in sur. And Mauli shrieked so if shrieks and screams is sur then she should have gotten 20 😃

No one sings peerfectly but he did sooo much better than Mauli. And Mauli was decent today so he deserved it more. 😃

no i didnt sya he did.. i said he mite have or somethign wich ids y da judge didnt give him a 10.. i didnt say he did.. hemust have lacked a lil in csmehtign if one of em didnt give him a 10.. sur was just an exampole.. i didnt say he did tho

I think i knoww why she received a 30 and mussii didnt

well she has given some horrible performances in the past
so according to her own standards, her performance last night was good
and this is the bestt she can do, nothing more
so they decided to give her a 30

where as mussii gave a marvelous performance and he has the capability to do ALOTTTTTTTTT better
and they know it too so that's why he got a 29

Originally posted by: pyaari_puja

no i didnt sya he did.. i said he mite have or somethign wich ids y da judge didnt give him a 10.. i didnt say he did.. hemust have lacked a lil in csmehtign if one of em didnt give him a 10.. sur was just an exampole.. i didnt say he did tho

NO I don't think its that.

Everyone gave him 10s and Haathi Da gave him a 9.

He probably gives lower scores because the other singers are wayy better and he has t keep comptetition behind (Raja exception)

Haathi Da is the most biased judge ever.

So it wasn't Mussarat it was haathi ji.