One Hit Wonder - Mauli Dave- well said HR - Page 4

Originally posted by: tapish

Wow so much of duscussion about Mauli..That means she is very famous then other singers

i have just deleted a repeated post here, so just excuse me guys!

Originally posted by: April2007

Many voter like her voice. Why do you have problem with this..ask yourself this question.

lol😆 😆 😆 You have moved away from the real issue I emphasised in my last post and that waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaas, of course her inability to sing in sur/laya/tal and I guess I have also explained well why I hold such view. The show is named on saptak 'Sa Re Ga Ma Pa' and that suggests participants will only be judge for singing in sur/tal/laya and as a viewer I would be looking for the same thing, I believe.

If you have read my post we will know that I have not said anything about her voice, it was her poor 'pakad' that bothered me so much and since you know that if you do not understand a great deal about pakad you can do anything but sing in tune. Since Ms. Mauli is incapable of singing (in sur/tal/laya), do you think she should be participating in a singing contest my dear? No is my answer! Why? Like people say 'dancers with two left feet shouldn't be taking part in a dance competition' similarly 'singers with no sense of pakad shouldn't be participating in a signing competition'😉.

I do not have any problem with mauli's voice but I will only vote for her when she sings (in sur). And if people fails to identify it's a singing contests and votes for contestant for their personality, beauty and etc, etc, than it's their choice. I am just putting forward my views as an admirer of Indian music😊.

Oh one more thing, when you reply try to stick to the real issue, and if you fail to recognise the issue that is being discussed then please do not reply, as you know it may show your ignorance😳.

**Viewbie note - You are not supposed to call members ignorant and ask them to stay away from discussion.. Respect others views also.. It has been seen that many times you have broken the rules.. next time if you break any rule, strict action will be taken**

Originally posted by: ramas

you are comparing the seasoned singers with mauli here. Mauli is starting out in music world. I was trying to say that singers who are singing differently too have place in music industry. Let me give you one example when I heard shreya ghosal's song from devdas first few times I did not liked them at all and now she is my fav. singer.

As for the knowledge no one knows better than me how much music mauli knows. I have heard her at least few 100 times and listening to her since she is very young. her entire family is dedicated to music including her paretts grand parents. her aunts uncles and even cousins. It is like family tradtion they are either singing or playing music. her dad and her aunt was even akashvani radio artists in India. Mauli too sang in children's program in akasvani several times. I don't think they will allow to sing any one has no knowledge of sur taal.

Also she was selected from entire US contestants and trust me we have good talented singer in houston alone and I am not talking about entire US.

I don't think Bhappida would have selected if he even for a second thought she has no knowledge of sur taal. So let us just wait and see what happens next.

very well said ramas!👏

Originally posted by: tangina r

very well said ramas!👏

Originally posted by: ~Nehpu~

Well i think that since mayya mayya, everyone has had lots and lots of expectations from her...in other words, they are hoping that every song she sings will be better than the original. After mayya mayya, her songs were good but not as great as people had expected.

I agree..

Personally i am not a Mauli fan.. But this girl has a large fan following ad apprantely YOU & I cant do anything to change that so have to just live with it.

Honestly, tell me how is her fault at all though..? I mean is she voting for herself..? I dont think soo.. If people are appealed by body, her voice or her modelish looks, how is it her fault at all..? If judges are all gooo gaa over her then how is it her fault..? I am sorry its just simple logic, thats all..!

Not all people are born talented, you have to work at your talent to finess it, some people are fast at doing that while it may take time for others and I think Mauli is one of those people.. 😃

I am really curious, if all the non-Mauli fans will be happy if she came in a Burkha.. covered from head to toe..??😆

I am Raja fan.. and have been since the begginning..! The guy is great..😳