Whats your opinion for this weeks show - Page 2

Sarika: 7/10 I thought her voice was shrill at places. Asha ji's comments that day would have suited her this time.

Sunil: 6/10 Wrong choice of song and then he had no life. Worst performance of his on srgmp stage. I have always liked his renditions before.

Raja: 10/10 Fabulous. He should be back.

Saberi: 5/10 It was one of the most horrible beedi number on TV. Some contestants on other talent shows sang it much better than her. I don't know why at such a crucial stage they choose such songs just because it is a hit. Highly overrated comments tonight.

Harpreet: 9/10 I didn't like his song selection but Harpreet did full justice to the song. He always has. With Junaid it was a close competition. I hope he comes back for sure.

Desh Gaurav: 6/10 I have never liked his renditions and felt he doesn't deserve the srgmp stage at all so calling him back is not something I would ever support. He was made to mimic different voices😕. I don't know what HR was trying to prove.

Overall tonight's show was just average. At times it looked like Aditya's tribute episode😃 with 'chota bachcha' playing more than once. The disagreement of Zee Bangla and Maharashtra winners by ID looked staged and HR seemed to follow the suit. Obviously they were going to sing the next day because the time was over not because ID needed time to decide. 😆

Originally posted by: yer.a.fob

Why would anyone wanna sing Beedi? That song has to be the most overplayed and overrated song of the year. That has to be the worst song selection anyone could possibly make.

and the performance was terrible too!

the whole forum seems to agree on harpreet and raja today. it is one of those rare days :)

Originally posted by: yer.a.fob

So whats gonna happen in this round? Will they choose one boy and one girl as they have done in the past or it doesn't matter what sex they are?

I hope the sex doesn't matter after this! I would drop a bunch of girls to retain mostly all guys. My top 5 or even 6 don't fit a single gal that's left. They have 2 men added from regional zones ( maharashtra and W. Bengal), so the balance may be off? I also don't think equal guys and gals were picked with Brahmastra- I may be wrong.

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

I hope the sex doesn't matter after this! I would drop a bunch of girls to retain mostly all guys. My top 5 or even 6 don't fit a single gal that's left. They have 2 men added from regional zones ( maharashtra and W. Bengal), so the balance may be off? I also don't think equal guys and gals were picked with Brahmastra- I may be wrong.

this is exactly why i think shaberi and raja get thru..because they want to put a girl through...and i dont think they'll let sarika get through...though i can be thoroughly wrong😕...i dunno why i think they'll try n get one boy n one gurl through...but i guess since till now they've always tried 2 balance the no. of gurls n boys,they'd do the the same now...but since its publis voting..i really don't no..😕

Originally posted by: sareg

Sarika - bad, I was thinking people were thinking she got eliminated for one bad day, oh no, she just had another of those bad days, wondering if there will be another fainting😉 now who will they blame, Ashaji to nahi hai🤔

ya..i wonder wat'll happen now if sarika gets eliminated again😕...n i personally didn't like her performance yesterday...

Raja was fabulous! Harpreet was also good. Sunil wasn't into it. Desh Gaurav was okay. Sarika was lacking something. Saberi was completely off in parts.

Raja and Harpreet would be my choices based on today's performances. But it seems like Raja and Saberi would make it. At least that's what VS seemed to want.

Adi's kiss scene was hilarious. He seemed to be lost for words, and didn't know how to react. It was like he was excited and embarassed at the same time. 😆

Raja's sob story was very touching. 😭 It was almost too sad to believe - 3 deaths in 4 days! And he was smiling and laughing all through it - smiling tooo much, in fact. Now I realize why...

Tum itna jo muskura rahe ho
Kya gham hai jisko chhupa rahe ho...

Raja was the star of the show today... what a power packed performance.... mindblowing !

Liked Harpreet's performance too. Don't know why,....but I just love this song....especially the part "mujhe kuch kehna hain"☺️

Sunil messed up the song today, Saberi seemed too hyper , Desh gaurav a poor copier and Sarika...well could have been better. Why bring back Sunil ,Desh Gaurav Sarika? There were far better guys to bring back .Shrestha and Sikander should have been recalled.

I somehow dont like Sarika's voice, it has a very distinct nasal touch.I just wish Ashaji had given her reasons for not choosing her, then we could have escaped hearing her again..

The drama at the end by ID was uncalled for...why complain now or raise the issue now when this format was already known in advance? Just a few days back read that ID sleeps like kumbhkarna ,seems this late reacction also is a Kumbhkarna reaction😆.ID/ HR's point is valid, but it should have been raised at the beginning of the show.What those two guys - Aneek and Abhi must be feeling... this show can carry without this kind of drama..

The kiss thing looks scripted but dont think Aadi was aware of it.. I am stunned Zee pulled such a thing,especially since a few days back another peck by Richard Gere had raised such a furore in India !

Apart from good singing another factor is playing a role in favor of the show here- its the friendly environment, and the easy camaraderie between the judges. I feel the mentors should go maintaing the decorum that they have maintained.ID/HR should sort it out behind the camera these iisues with the production team.

Raja's reason for forgetting lyrics was too sad. Hats off to him for even being able to perform after all that. Why do good guys have to suffer the most.....life is indeed cruel...

One thing is sure... in C2007 the quality of male singers is just fabulous...!!👏

overall a thoroughly enjoyable show....!👏THUMBS UP !!👍🏼

I've not watched the show so cannot comment.

However, I've always wanted Raja & Harpreet to come back, I'm glad they gave good performances. These two deserved to be in Agniparissha directly.

We do have terrific male singers in the contest this time. Sadly no good female singers, except for Poonam. I miss Nihra & Himani terribly.

Originally posted by: sareg

Sarika - bad, I was thinking people were thinking she got eliminated for one bad day, oh no, she just had another of those bad days, wondering if there will be another fainting😉 now who will they blame, Ashaji to nahi hai🤔

there was a reason why these folks were eliminated and they are showing why😉

IMHO Harpreet and Raja are only two worth coming back on their singing abilities, if anyone comes back it will be for non-singing reasons

Well said, its very easy to point a fingure towards some one.. Mahagurus were unnecessarily abused around by all...

I think Raja will be top three in the show sure..

rest all they desereved to go back home...

Originally posted by: yer.a.fob

Why would anyone wanna sing Beedi? That song has to be the most overplayed and overrated song of the year. That has to be the worst song selection anyone could possibly make.

Completely agree

i hope it's not a male/female split...that would be unfair

still haven't heard sunil's and raja's performances, but of the rest:

sarika ~ i don't like her voice 😕 it has a strange twang to it..makes her sound like an old lady, singing...albeit in tune.. 6.5/10

saberi ~ why, why, why?! she didn't do herself justice with the song choice or her performance 5/10

desh gaurav ~ 'kay..if they really wanted to give someone a second chance, why didn't they just bring back imran? 😛 4/10

harpreet ~ if he's not one of the two chosen to return then i'll be very disappointed... 8.5/10 😊