What is Your Opinion For This Week's Show - Page 2

Junaid being chosen was a good decision. He performed wll on both songs.

I think I'm the only one who cannot stand Mauli's voice. Her voice just irritates my ears to no end. I hope when public voting starts, she gets eliminated very very soon. As someone said she's the Sanjaya of SGMP - annoying and horrible and just there for looks.

Mauli Mauli Mauli...why dus she ALWAYS get thru despite better singers being around ..i really felt Shrestha shuld've gotten thru....not dat Mauli was bad, she was way way better den last time, but i still feel shes not gr8 (n m saying dis after at first finding her my fave contestant )

Junaid was amazing 👏 👏 ..he deserved 2 get in...hes a gr88 gr88 singer.. 😃 👏

The boys decision was good 👏 ..but from the girls, Shrestha shuld've been in...

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Today's episode may easily be termed as day of blunders. This first blunder was that some very good singers had to compete against each other. Harpreet, Wasi, Junaid all shouldn't have competed against each other.

Agree, that maybe these 3 good singers should not have been pitted against each other, but I'm glad that Junaid & Amanat were not put against each other. Imagine one of them losing! Both of them are the very best in this competition.

I wish SRGMP would do away with this gender separation, then we would have kamaal ke final 12 agnipariksha contestants, about 8-9 boys and 2-3 girls (unfortunatley we do not have many good girls this time round and its' disheartening to seel derving boys go.

The show today was really great performance wise....there were some great performances. learnt some gujarati words too.😃

The star of the episode according to me was Junaid. He was just outstanding !!

Frankly speaking in front of Junaid's performance, Harpreet's kind of paled out. He sang well, but there was no impact.

Wasi sang the song well, but today his illness was visible especially at the lower notes. He sang well, but his song did not have the punch or the tempo that goes with the song. Junaid clearly stood out as the champion. A very good decision by the judge....👏

Amonst the girls, the contest was between the two girls- Mauli and Shreshtha.

Mauli messed up some notes and sur in the K-sera sera song, but sounded much better in that Subha Mudgal Song.

Shreshtha shook a bit in the first song lambi judai...and despite that her rendition was good.Mast Kalandar rocked. If today's performance was the criteria for selection, then in my opinion Shrestha is the winner. She was as confident as Mauli and that reason as the cause as cited by Anandji Bhai did not cut any edge.

Hats off to Mauli to stand up and acknowledge that her performance today was inferior to Shreshtha's . Its takes a lot of honesty and uprightness to do that.👏

Why is Mauli being kept in the competition time after time even after not good performances? I feel this is to get the public into action and vote more to rectify the injustice and bring back Shreshtha's & Jyothi's and in turn Mauli's devoted fans would also go crazy voting for her to mnake her win. So the only one who stands to gain is Zee TV.... with high moolah and TRP's.

Overall , a fabulous episode today. Disheartening to see so many talented ones leave today, but in a contest this has to happen someday.

To quote Aamir Khan from the movie Rangeela - 'I shocked!!'

How can any judge of music pick Mauli over Shrestha? Every single person in the studio - Anandji included - claimed that Shrestha had sung better than Mauli. Then what was the reason for selecting Mauli? Her fan following? Her one past (almost 2 month old) performance?

I can't even begin to think what Shrestha must be going through. The girl must have literally slogged over the two extremely difficult songs she selected! She must have had a hope that if she sings well, she will be selected. What goes through a person's mind when you know that whatever you do, you will not go through because someone has already been preselected. All your motivation for performing falls through. You feel lost, defeated, and don't care about how you perform. Would Shrestha have gone through the preparation of the songs so enthusiastically if she had known that Mauli was going to go through regardless? I don't blame her one bit for questioning Anandji. I might even have permitted her one slap to Anandji. Now that would be welcome drama.

Also felt sad for Harpreet. It's not that he sang badly, but that Junaid sang well. The competition among the men is extremely tight, and we're going to have to say bye to a few good performers. Wasi is a very good singer (the #1 Pakistani pick, if you remember), but he was dogged by a bad throat all through the competition. I hope the vada pav didn't have anything to do with that. Would be cruel.

Good news is that some singers can be brought back in Bramhastra. But that is another headache. Sikander, Wasi, Harpreet - who to call back? Among the girls, I was supporting Sarika to be brought back, but now I'm strongly behind Shrestha. So all's not lost.

This was one of the best shows till date. But I really feel we left out gr8 talent today, the exit of Harpreet was just sad. He did sing he was among the top contenders should have made it to the finals. In comparison to all the singers who got a direct entry, Joy from Rock didnt perform exceptionally well that he got a direct entry, That spot should have been there for Harpreet.

Junaid was exceptional though to be honest he didnt get marks on his singing he took it because of the way he was dressed up. I really like Junaid but when i was listening to the comments passed by legend Anand ji for the first performance really made me lose interest. I mean what is going on. Are u marking how they look dance, or are u there to listen. When you buy track records nowadays its of the bollywoodactors some of them dont even have the singers pic up. so at the end of the day how are u going to make business. by selling a track that is popular with others.

Wasi was not up to the mark but hats off to him to pull of after the condition.

Now to the girls

Sumana alrite performance, not too good but not to bad.

Shrestha now she was the suprise package, she pulled off lambi judaii, and dum mast kalandar superb. really upset she got out after the performance that she gave. What were they marking on. Sa re ga ma pa is not Indian idol, she was very good.

Mauli:after Maaya Maaya her songs werent exceptional to be really honest Do respect her for voicing and taking a stand in what she believed, it takes alot to admit that you werent the best and u gave thumbs up to another participant . Hats off👏👏👏 but she lost at both the performance. It wasnt up to the mark she did lose it at place where it could clearly be pointed out. But she made it and hope works on her weakness she could do better

Judges:

The most discouraging people: Himesh, Bappi Lahri, Ismail darbar, they were highly unprofessional with their comments.

Bappi Lahri saying that Mast kalandar so many time its was ok. I mean hello arent u suppose to judge the person and not compare them. if he didnt want to appreciate then dont discourage.

Himesh: what is wrong with him, i am not discouraging anyone excuse me, u are Shrestha sang well and u are saying that oh i dont mean in it that way.. ulta chor kothal ko kate. If contestants are given the same hype appreciation you will have fan following. u could just stop the show and declare the winner if its on fan following.

Ismail Darbar: are u voting people out because they didnt perform well in previous one. Because legends like kayaam sahb/asha bholse selected people on the basis of performance thats why they made it that far. it wont be fair

VS: You guys rock, not because of who the supported they were honest. They didnt give any discouraging remarks. they were honest about the contestant even from their own gharana.

Sorry guys i didnt want to make a post so long. just wanted to vent it out here. 😆

My heart went out for harpreet.. the way he cried and shrestha asking where did i go wrong.. the answer confidence.. I mean it takes alot to be up there...and u r saying confidences and the judges couldnt even buck up the contestants.. Yet again tomorrow more disappointment's

Btw just point I noticed. Shekar when did u starting visiting I.E .. that u have info on how many fan clubs are there 😳😆

Originally posted by: LonelyHeart

Btw just point I noticed. Shekar when did u starting visiting I.E .. that u have info on how many fan clubs are there 😳😆

When did he say that?

Originally posted by: advil

When did he say that?

lol when Mr himesh said that Mauli is much more superior singer..Something along those lines.. and Shekar is like" App internet per jaiye, Mauli ka bahut fan clubs hain, she is already a star,"