Ismail Durbar's compositions - Page 4

oh and since this is becoming debatable, should we be requesting that this topic gets moved elsewhere? last time around when we were having a debate, we did, no? 😉 😆

isse pahle topic close ho jaye mai chalta hu.... 😆

Originally posted by: N Sinha

he he eh

very interesting discussion between chastbuster Vs Jadoogar, ID saab is an ace musician with deep understanding of Indian Classical, now even Pt Ravi Shankar's sitarvadan or Ustaad Zakir Hussain's work may fail to impress a person who prefers Preetam or HR over them, this doesn't mean former's work is not great.

with all due respect, but ID aint no Pt Ravi Shankar or Ustaad Zakir Hussain. 😉they've got quantity and quality both going together for them. ID has very little quantity-wise. and we are debating quality right this very minute😆

and yes, i do prefer preetam and HR over ID. that's not such a biggie😆

Originally posted by: N Sinha

isse pahle topic close ho jaye mai chalta hu.... 😆

arre naheen sir. we are just having hopefully an honest give-and-take. mein bhee kuch seekhoon "genuine music believers" kya sochte hain😆

IMO appeal of music is something difficult to explain, why X gets appealed by HR and Y by ID is something we would never know. Isiliye cheers to all tastes of music.

Amritvarshini seems to be truly interested in a discssion about ID's songs so let's post some positive thoughts, we can always avoid posting in topics which we are not of our taste.

Originally posted by: advil

I Love Ismail Darbar ji's compositions and I can go on listening to them again and again without getting bored. My fav is. Albela sajan aayo re.. I can go on forever listening to it.

Then Jhoka hawa ka aaj bhi...is another great one.

All songs of HDDCS, are good. Even the devdas songs. Tera jadoo chal gaya is also great. What he has in his songs is substance.

awwwwwww I totally forgot Albela sajan ayo re....I love this song!😳😳😳Shankar, Kavita and Sultan jee perfomed this song so well!👏👏👏

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Nahin Sinha ji, I am not debating with ChatBuster, It is difficult to debate with him.. For him every topic is debatable, and all topic should move to Debate Mansion because as he posts something that topic becomes debate topic.....

would appreciate if we can keep the personal analysis of my posts out Mr. Jadoogar. rest assured, will be sure to ask for it when i need it.😛

I gave my opinion and nothing more...😉

so did i😛 Incidentally when someone posts something on the forum, that's supposed to be open for discussion unless qualified. lemme know if somehow that understanding has also changed 😉

please dont take this wrong, but if one must deviate so strongly from topic, then it would be better imo not to comment on what other members are about or their posting style. u wouldnt for example want me to tell you what i think of you, your posts or posting style, would u?😉😊

Originally posted by: .:Aphrodite:.

i agree with chatbuster. ID's music is very nice under the context of the movies he composes for. But on its own i feel like something's missing.

I can only enjoy his songs when I watch the videos. 😊

Shekhar said he loves ID's composition....😛

I think that ID probably poured his heart out into HDDCS, but didn't put that kind of effort later on.
If he goes around mentoring and trying to make every
gharane ka bachcha a star, his music is going to go down to the lows of Bollywood in the 80s.

I think ID's music is very similar to ARR's. Which is also why in some of the movies he's done (Devdas, Kisna), he's had to share the music with ARR - and not many people even realized the difference.

The flip side of this is that ek jungle mein do sher nahi reh sakte, so ID is finding it hard to bag the few movies that involve his style of music - those are already taken by ARR.