Written & Video Update - 12th May 2007 - Page 2

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

I did not watch yet, but judgement should be on singing if that is the criteria... If it is done on dresses and composition/wordings then it is unfair...

Nahin bhaiyah, judgement was fair and was not based on composition/wordings.. There have been so many times when contestants have sung this song and there was no objection to it, then why today they have objection to it

Thankoo for the lovely update Anu!! 🤗

I am quite satisfied with the eliminations, although Shreshta really needs to work on the throw in her voice she has a better hold over sur than Koyal does..

Liked Yogendra a bit, feeling bad for him, it was emotional but out of Apurva and Sunil, it was a correct and proper decision..

Nice performances, Apurva and Sunil really improved quite a bit 👏

all the best to Yogendra and Koyal!

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

They might be just looking for drama and want to divert the attention from rather boring episodes... This year MDs comments look more fabricated than C2005. Panel of MDs is not good, 2 are from C2005(their acting is repititive), Bappi Da has no opinion of his own(He is the nicest MD, but worst actor), VS are just boring and do not know any acting. Abhijeet should have been one of the MD... Last time MDs carried the show and this year singers need to carry the show but I doubt it....

Agree and one more important issue to raise the TRP will be cold war between Ashaji and Himesh 😉 If Abhijeet and Alka were here, it would hv been fun to watch the drama 😆

Thanks Anu!!!

one thing I dun like + like

Don't like: they start the show with a difficult theme... if they had few simpler themes, the contestant's would adapt to the stage, and be more skilled, and have a higher chance of doing better
Like: Those who advance through this, have a greater chance of being called, if they win, a deserved winner...

Thanks to Anu and Noni for posting the video link.

IMHO
Group Performance:

Aditya Narayan, Rimi and Amanat sing tauba tauba ishq main kariyaan
from the movie Kaal.. Agree, not a good performance, Rimi was
particularly awful.


Meghna sings zindagi mein koi kabhi aaye na Rabba.
I thought she was besura in more than a few places. Is that due to her
throat infection? Also her voice does shake and it is annoying.

Apurva sings Tu hi meri shab hain from Gangster..
The first note was off but no doubt he has a nice voice. I just wish he
would concentrate on pitching rather than dancing because I think that
Ashaji is correct that he actually has the kind of voice that would make
him a good playback singer. Also a good song choice for him.

Yogendra from London sings Phirta rahu darbhadar
Why didn't Himesh find someone who was really from London? That
really bugs me. I think that girl with the odd red hair would have been a
more interesting choice. Great song but but he was really besura, I could
barely stand to listen! He got a little better towards the end. I felt sorry
for the judges. But he does seem like a nice person. Totally would have
him to dinner but would avoid having him doing the after singing
entertainment

Shreshta sings Tere liye hum hain jiye
Some besura notes but a nice voice. The antara was better. I thought she
put some nice touches in and put feeling into it. Also a nice song choice
for her voice. Needed more throw. But much better than yesterday.


Sunil Kumar sings dil de diya hain jaan tumhe denge..
Nice song but he missed many of the kaj and was a little flat on some
notes though I hate to disagree with Ashaji. But still sang it well.

Koyal sings - Rock me baby from Aitraaz..
Why was she screaming at the beginning? NOT a good song choice in
front of these judges. Antara was besura. Both Ujjaini and Himani did a
better job with this song. She could have made it softer. I could have also
done without ID's comments on the clothes. I do agree with Asha on the
comments on the song and I wish SRGM would retire the song from this
show. It's a beautiful song but every time it is sung, ID has this creepy
smile and half the audience is embarrassed. If Asha queen of the cabaret
songs is embarrassed, I think that says it all. But regardless, she did not
do the antara well so her marks were low. As for the song choice, I wish
someone would clarify who chooses the songs. In fact, the more I think
about it, they probably made her sing this song to annoy the judges and
cause controversy! Really yesterday they started with a rag mala and then
talk of Pa is for parampara and then they go to "Rock me baby, push me"
baby which is inappropriate for a family show.

Right choices to leave.

This overemotional sequences are a little corny. Someone please get
Himesh a mood stabilizer. Poor Ashaji! She probably feels compelled to
forgie him because he clearly some issues when on the SRGM stage.

Why was no one crying for Koyal, not that I was either. Every elimination,
one person is apotlighted and the other person is pushed to the side.

Anu...thanks dear! I'll wait till later this evening to watch the show. Dekhne ke baad zaroor aaongi comments maarne ke liye 😉

thnxx a lot for da update😛

Thanks Anu.

Todays show also was nothing to rave about. Liked Yogi's innocence that all.

There was no dum in the performances.. it was.just OK.

Thanks for the update Anu...I missed it so will have to watch the video. 😛

Jab mdroyji ne hi sab keh diya hai to main kya kahun?😳 Well analyzed! 😊

Though, incidentally, I did find Sunil to be the best of the 3 today. Somehow Apurva just felt flat today..rather monotonous. Sunil managed to infuse a little life into the song, though even he has a long way to go.