Sa re ga ma challenge/ Updates/ Comments - Page 35

I am really aghast to read that Irfan was chosen over Viswas... Really of all the people Daler Mandhi as a judge...What's wrong with Sa Re Ga Ma Pa organizer

Originally posted by: arien79

Laagi tumse mann ki lagan ...which sharib sang in 2nd charan is
from which movie?

Paap - I think

Ujaini & Viswas are really very good, do not get it
If the judgment are going to be like this. of a great show like this, they
need to work how and who has to do this job.
There were on my final 8 list.

Viswas is out 😕 . Whats wrong with these judges. Counting how many times they went besur 😕 .
Viswas has been good and Ujjaini's black movie song was so good in fact better than the original singer.

I agree with all of you- ujjaini and vishwas were much better than keka and irfan..but i must say that isamail is a good mentor and a smart one- he had irfan trained by lalit who is the orginal singer and composer of the song.

i am also surprised to hear that ujjaini & vishwaas got eliminated. based on previous episodes i was sure that they would get blue cards.
waiting for priti's detailed update to get more info on how they sang. i will be able to watch this shocking episode only on oct 9

The 2nd day of the performances-------

Recap- Yesterday Nihira and Vineet got green cards.

Judges for the day- Pandit Jasraj and Daler Mehndi

Theme for the songs- Songs composed by Jatin- Lalit

The contestants for the day- Vishwas and Keka from Jaiho gharana, Irfan from Yalgaar and Ujjaini from Dum.

Nihira and vineet joined shaan in singing the first song of the day- salaam namaste

The first contestant for the day

Vishwas- Vishwas was a standby participant and was chosen and subsequently got two green card in his first appearances. Got a good voice and personality, has got a lovely 'khanak" in his voice which is nice to hear…something which udit narayan has. Aadesh told him that he must get green card, as he is worthy of one. The jatin lalit song chosen by him was jab kisi ki taraf from pyar to hona hi tha. Good selection, it suited his voice quality. Good singing with feeling- got a little husky touch…was a little off in the lower notes. But overall good performance, his voice is very pleasant to the ears.

Mentors- Ismail said that vishwaas did not pick up the song properly but got hold of it later and then sang it well. Jatin-lalit refused to comment saying that it is their song and that is why they can see many faults but overall he sang well. Himesh refused to comment saying if JL don't want to comment, he should also not say anything. (he did that religiously in the full episode- seems like someone has told him to shut up as whenever he opens his mouth, it is to complain about….sweet-2 nanu, pyare…….and so on.

Keka- Aadesh told both of his students that he wants them to win only if they deserve and if at any point they think that they have picked up the song from "khali" and are given green cards, they should not take it and on the other hand if they think that they have sung better than the others- don't say that the other deserved it. ( I am impressed by aadesh- he seems genuine). Keka said that this is the reason why she, when asked yesterday, had said that she deserved yellow. She chose a beautiful song (one of my favs)- Baahon ke darmiyan from khamoshi. Aadesh did point out that her voice is not ok and baitha hua but he is not saying this as excuse. It was evident in the song that her voice was not at her best. But she sang it melodiously…. problems in sur..she did falter few times. I was not much impressed by her singing today (the other day- she was very good). I think this was not her kind of song and the sweet romance of the song was also missing.

Mentors- Ismail said that we should acknowledge JL for giving us this wonderful song and incidentally he had played violin in this particular composition. He said that considering Keka's limitation with her voice (baitha hua), she tried well. (seems like ID is in a trip of reform- he was all nice and good, praising everyone- probably realizes the bad image he is getting in public eye). Jatin lalit also felt that the effort was good.

Irfan- Irfan is a singer whom I find very one dimensional- hardly any feeling in the song- sur and voice good but nothing to rave about- very mediocre. Here ID got shyana- he chose a song Rooth ke humse from Jo jeeta wohi sikandar, which has been sung by Lalit and sent irfan to learn from Lalit. Good move, good song selection. Irfan was shown as being trained by lalit. This song suited his voice perfectly- a sad song but not too much emotions- no need of any energy. But to his credit, he sang it wonderfully- copied the original song nicely and some bit of his own harkat as well.

Mentors- Jatin-lalit said that in only two stanzas, irfan had created an atmosphere which is not easy. Aadesh said that irfan has sung wonderful and was the best (I think he meant today). Lalit said that irfan was very hardworking and told ID that soon we will sending our singer to you to get trained.

Ujjaini-I know I am repeating myself, but her Black performance has made her one of the favs. Even yesterday, her singing was good but it is difficult to beat nihira. Jatin lalit were shown telling her that she must win today specially because it is their songs round. Ye dil sun raha from Khamoshi sung by kavita krishnamurthy was the song chosen. It is very difficult to sing a song of KK- but ujjaini tried well………good control over sur but her voice through did not too good…it was better the other day. She did falter on sur also in couple of places but handled the western bit very well. Good singing overall.

Mentors- Frankly, I don't remember the comments…but I think they all said that it was good effort.

The second round-

Boys- Banke tera jogi from Phir bhi dil hai Hindustani.

Vishwaas started it and sang it well….his khanak in the voice helped him in this song….irfan lacked the energy needed for this song…seemed very flat.

Mentors- Ismail said that when will I make songs like this! (reform mood). He said that I hope jatin lalit keep on creating such wonderful music all their life. Most of the mentors were refusing to comment saying when they have such guni judges, they should leave it for them.

Girls- Aaj mei upar from Khamoshi sung by Kavita. Ujjani started the song and sang it well…specially the ta..ra…rarariri….. ok. But keka was very good in this, her powerful voice was certainly more suited and she sang it well.

Irfan was shown the blue card, vishwaas had already requested his teammates not to cry if he lost. He said that his gharana was still there and hema and Rajeev will take it to the final and may win it. He said that if god is willing he would come back.

Keka and ujjaini- there was a tie- They were asked to sing their own song- antara again. Daler said that keka slipped on sur 5 times and ujjaini 8 times. Keka can do very well on stage and Ujjaini will be very good in recording. But the blue card goes to keka. Aadesh pointed out that ujjaini has already sung for him and it is 99% final and if mata rani is willing even that 1 %will be final. Ujjaini was crying because she had dropped a year in studies to come here and not chosen science stream even though she had good marks because she wanted to be a singer. Daler said that music is the right choice and she will certainly got far. Keka (who was in lucky colour of his gharana-red) said that she did not know what to say as she was close to ujjaini, they stay quite nearby in Calcutta and shared a room here too.

Shaan said that the brahmaashtra may not be from the top gharanas as will be chosen by the mentors together.

Originally posted by: pingme

[Paap - I think

thanks so much ....i think Sharib sang much better than original.

In my opinion for a mega musical competition like this especially when it is close to its final rounds, the organizers have to be very careful while choosing judges. Shivji – Hariji was a perfect combination. Jagjit Singh – Alka was a DISASTER 😡 . They could not even make a decision in one of the rounds and have to leave the decision to the mentors and musicians. J. Singh commented "Aishwarya ko tho mike pakad na bhi nahin atha hai". Kavita Subramaniam is a perfect choice. I am sure you all would have noticed her concentration while the participants singing. Before showing the results, she always gives a pleasant comment on each participant to make them feel good. If they pick judges like Daler and Sameer you better prepare for more shocks!! 😆 If they continue to have judges like them, I won't be surprised to see even Nihira or Hemachandra get eliminated!!! 😆

I just switched on the TV and Sa re ga ma pa uncensored just ended 😭 I really wanted to see that. Can anybody please tell me if they are going to telecast it again here in US or if I can download this from somewhere.....I can't believe I missed that 😭 😭 😭