Judges - Page 2

Originally posted by: rajk001

The songs were lypsynched? How do u know that?

Watch the video closely.You can make out.😛

Originally posted by: rajk001

The songs were lypsynched? How do u know that?

yes, it was all lipsync

Originally posted by: rajk001

REALLY? That is awful! It is called deceit. Period.

Its not really a deceit. Thats I think looking at it too harshly. When you need to perform and sing at the same time , it is a chosen option to keep sur taal rhythm steps all in sync.

Originally posted by: B & B

BL is the worst judge I ever saw. Never gave his critcal appraisal. ALka & AB were good judges. They scolded when some one was not good and applauded when they were good.

actually i kinda liked BL.... cuz u can give w/e marks u want, sure. but when u r passing comments u shld remember, that they r children... the fact that their voices migh be becoming mature, doesn't mean their mind is... to be sooo critical of kids under 15 is something am not comfortable with.... sure he was easy going but thats part of the parcel when u r dealing wit kids, he understood that. i agree i did not like alka ji's complete behaviour after the results... she liekd sanchita, am sure many ppl do, n its fine if she showed joy on her face when she heard the results, but i think she went overboard with it, cuz even tho it is true that it is a time of happiness for sanchita, it is also true that it was a sad time for diwakar n sameer, so it was a mixed feeling occassion, shez an adult she shld kno not to behave like that..... i mean wat would diwakar's n sameer's faily see it as? would they not think that alka since she showed her bias after results, she migh have used that bias while judging their children during the show. I agree she might not even have done partiality, bt her actions sent a wrong message that day.

Originally posted by: ani11

It says that Bappida is a good mentor .Mentoring and Judging are entirely different.Bappida failed as a judge.

Agree with u B&B.

Agree with Ani! Pls. come back😭

Originally posted by: seema_17

actually i kinda liked BL.... cuz u can give w/e marks u want, sure. but when u r passing comments u shld remember, that they r children... the fact that their voices migh be becoming mature, doesn't mean their mind is... to be sooo critical of kids under 15 is something am not comfortable with.... sure he was easy going but thats part of the parcel when u r dealing wit kids, he understood that. i agree i did not like alka ji's complete behaviour after the results... she liekd sanchita, am sure many ppl do, n its fine if she showed joy on her face when she heard the results, but i think she went overboard with it, cuz even tho it is true that it is a time of happiness for sanchita, it is also true that it was a sad time for diwakar n sameer, so it was a mixed feeling occassion, shez an adult she shld kno not to behave like that..... i mean wat would diwakar's n sameer's faily see it as? would they not think that alka since she showed her bias after results, she migh have used that bias while judging their children during the show. I agree she might not even have done partiality, bt her actions sent a wrong message that day.

Okay. But Alka usually didnt use show that bias while judging. There were times when people in the forum felt 'Alka was jealous of Sanchita' 😆 Check the older posts. Usually, it was Bappi and Abhijeet who would give Sanchita an A+. Alka would end up giving her an A. The Jagjit Singh episode is one example. Jagjit Singh's comment on Sanchita's Dard se mera daman was: 'at some places, you sang better than the original'. But Alka wasn't that happy. She felt Sanchita could do better and gave her an A.

I agree Alka was overjoyed at Sanchita's victory and perhaps, showed some bias. Actually, she did, maybe cos she was Sanchita's 'mentor'. Would she have reacted the same had Diwakar or Sameer won? Maybe. I don't remember the other two judges' reactions but according to some articles, their favorite to win was Sanchita as well.

Side note: In JDJ, the judges didnt show much enthusiasm after Mona Singh won. Shilpa Shetty congratulated Mona and gave a standing ovation to Shveta Salve. Farah and SLB said nothing (possible their comments were edited out) No doubt Shveta was the better dancer and deserved to win. But it wasnt right on the judges' part to act like that. If someone wins, you have to acknowledge it, whether or not its to your liking.

Originally posted by: adi_0112

The same logic should should ythen apply for all, not nay individual then.

As judge most of them failed, some were too harsh,some too soft ,some too critical .But of the three Alka ji was better.Abhijitda totally pathetic -too harsh and way too biased. Bappida too soft and too generous.Both of them were not suitable.

But Bappida was biased towards Divakar

Originally posted by: bangboy

But Bappida was biased towards Divakar

and alka towards Sameer