Is Himesh losing his Midas touch? - Page 4

Originally posted by: s.priya

It always takes one to recognise another.

jaao jaake usko poocho jisne HR ke sar pe yeh tag likh diya thaa, phir humse poocho 😆 (AB comes in handy with all the good dialougues)

Or😉😉 was it S.K. Jha Saab who gave him the title 😆

😆

Originally posted by: mohinih

Moastly the music composed by HR is melodious like "Tere naam" "kyon ki" and many others, only when he sing , is bit nasal, otherwise his compositions are always very good.... other music directors who can;t be so successful in so many years , HR has shown his talent in few years and thats why all producers are signing him, otherwise producers are not dumb taht they want to waste money by signing HImesh Reshammiya....

MOHINI!!!!! U said it. Maybe a couple of movies he did sound melodious to a few ears, but what about the rest of the movies and what about the rest of the listeners.

And U urself missed out ONE good composition which possibly represented the HR the original MD who was pretty good when he started his career - Banares. Possibly because it is not his typical OOOOOOOOOOOOO variety.

What about those movies where he kept making noises, in the name of songs 🤢

What compositions now.😕 The songs of his latest ones are rehashes of his old movies.

Originally posted by: Bhaskar.T

👏

Too true...... The list is too long. And frankly speaking a list can be made of concerts which have been always much more better than the ones you are talking about. And I am sure the list will be quite long.....

But where's Appa. I want to see his expert comments here 😃

Exactly my thoughts... Thanks Priya for putting it so well 😃

Originally posted by: jayc1234

Exactly my thoughts... Thanks Priya for putting it so well 😃

Thanks, Jaya and Bhaskar.

But looks like Appa is not around or answering Bhaskar's call for comments on this thread 😃

Originally posted by: mohinih

Bhaskar, Who told u that hR was looser in srgmp2005, his student Vinit was in finals, even Jatin lalit and Adesh jIs gharana's students were out before Himesh Gharana.... And Himesh student was much more talented than , others who only win because of voting system.... So though Vinit was second out of lot of contestants, still he is the winner in majority of people hearts in world, so need not to say that Hr was looser in Srgmp 2005....

Mohini for me it's always.....

Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikander 😃 And HR lost there. Ismail Darbar won......

Originally posted by: s.priya

Ranig,

No offence, but I think you have drawn unfair comparisons.

Maybe HR is good, to you, but please do not compare him with the likes of Ghulam Ali, Jagjit Singh, who are in a leaugue and genre of their own.

You could say he has drawn incorrect comparisons, but I don't see anything unfair about someone comparing their favorite performer with your favorite performer.

And I think ranig has every right, if he wishes, to compare Himesh to any singer. Please don't suppress his voice and freedom of speech and thought.

Talking of Midas touch... is that a reason why bappida has so much of gold on him to boast his golden collection???Some of his songs are priceless gems...

*******************

***Please no personal attack***

Originally posted by: mohinih

Moastly the music composed by HR is melodious like "Tere naam" "kyon ki" and many others, only when he sing , is bit nasal, otherwise his compositions are always very good.... other music directors who can;t be so successful in so many years , HR has shown his talent in few years and thats why all producers are signing him, otherwise producers are not dumb taht they want to waste money by signing HImesh Reshammiya....

Not always good Mohini. Yes some are definitely. I agree to that.

Producers are signing him as he is at the top. They also mean business and earn money. But as the article tells his time is going bad now. So what happens after say 6 months time or maybe one year..... Remember when any MD starts going down he will be just discarded by the producers.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

You could say he has drawn incorrect comparisons, but I don't see anything unfair about someone comparing their favorite performer with your favorite performer.

And I think ranig has every right, if he wishes, to compare Himesh to any singer. Please don't suppress his voice and freedom of speech and thought.

Shady, No one is suppressing ranig's voice and freedom of speech.

It would be UNFAIR to compare a ghazal singer with a self proclaimed rock star 😃 I maintain my word.

Originally posted by: mohinih

Yes, Shady , u are 100 percent correct, if somebody feels that Vinit's voice is like Sonu Nigam, why are u suppressing, his fans feels .... So if somebody says Himani voice is like Sunidhi chauhan, so why supress it, its every body point of view...

No everybody's, just yours. You can't really pin your opinion on someone else....