Is it not too much criticism from ID? - Page 2

Originally posted by: bittu777

ID had pointed out that instead of "ankhoon ki"
sharib was singing "ankhoooooon ki " everytime.
Even I had noticed it.May be ID thought that even after listening to the song(during practice and rehearsal) how can one make such blunders that too when MD of the song himself is sitting right in front(who knows every sur and taal of song)

I agree during rehearsal why MD did not point out and correct him 😡

It is MD'd fault not sharib😡😡

And worst part is that MR. Hari's star influence by ID'd comment.

why would ID criticize??? becuz he wants to make them better. why did ID criticize Debojit??? becuz he wants to make him better...the best they can be....though i personally feel sharib was very good in aankhon ki gustakhiyan and even banjo wasnt that bad... 😕

I completely aggree with u BS ARE NOT TRBS IS THE BEST
I just watched the episode where UA sings the silsila song, and they didnt even know the WORDS!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yet they still got 5 and 5 stars!!!!!!!! ANd when poor BS make even a slight mistake they are first INSULTED and HUMILATED and then given like a point. I swear this show is just full of crap! EATED FAIRLY!!

At first I would agree that Ismil was way to harsh... however after thinking it over I felt that he has no reason to lie? It was his song, and maybe that's why he was a little harsher ((everyone likes thurr own song to be NO.1)). Im sure if UA had sung an ID song the way they sang Suraj Hua Maddam he would've gotten on their case too. I think overall Ismil was fair, he culd've just been a little softer. As for during C2005, I think that at first he was a good judge and not biased against anyone. However, when Nihra went out, he became very competative and unfair. When Hemu would make one tiny mistake, he would take off two points on the mentor meeter. Even with Vinit I always felt at the end Ismil hated the poor guy ((expec with those killer looks he gave him)). I hated him b/c of that!! But after Debu has one, I think he has returned to his old normal self. Sure he's tough!! But look after that how much better BS did the day after. Think about it!

Ya I agree Initially the most best judge was ID.
But later on in final stages when HR was publicizing vinit tooo much and calling debo "underdog" in front of sunidhi ,kunal,shreya,he obviously had to boost up his contestant's confidence.After that I agree that the battle wasn't between D and V.

it was HR + V and ID + D

I am a BS fan also, and I totally agree!!!!!!!! The judges and ID are not being fair to BS!!! What Sharad Kelkar(nahar) said in today's USA episode was sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooo true!! The judges are not supporting BS and they want UA to win!!!!


BUT PEOPLE DON'T SUPPORT THE JUDGES!!!!!!!!!!! SUPPORT SHARAD KELKAR AND ONLY VOTE FOR SHARIB AND BANJOTSNA!!!!!!!!!!!

GG, Guest Judges, GS, EMET Production Team, EMET Musicians and also TO WHOMSOEVER IT MAY CONCERN

*********************