c2005 if eminent music ppl had judged - Page 2

1. Nihira
2. Vinit ( Bcos Hema had a bad performance in earlier rounds and he would have been out then)
3. Himani
4. Sharib
5. Ujjaini/Hema
6. Debojit/Raktima
(this is the ranking as per paneled judges as per me)

Bangboy and all others please join the Anti Quota Stir on the link given in my signature

Nihira for sure among girls, boys Hemu/Debu

IN GIRLS:
nihira/himani[though nihira was better overall,himani completely stole the limelight from her in the final rounds]

IN BOYS:
definitely VINIT[the most consistent in all the agnipariksha rounds]

in the girls Nihira and himani
😛 and in the boys one and only vinit 😊

Nihira would have won by landslide. Any judge with musical ears and senses would have selected Nihira, amongst girls, as a winner even blindfolded.

most probably nihira or himani.hemu would have been out coz he had performed badly in a few earlier rounds

nihira/himani/vinit were most consistent but anyone would have realized vinit copies sonu

None could have come even close to Hemu in the male category. Hemu would have been a sensation by now.
In female category it is definetly Nihira.

The third category, 'haunted voices' awrad would def go to Himesh and his chela Vineet jointly, as they are quite inseperable.

nihira without a doubt!... it doesn't matter that she didn't win as i think she has a great future ahead of her anyway 😊 ... she sang brilliantly in alag (i probably shouldn't say this but i even feel that she put gayatri ganjawala to shame 😳 )

2 other people that i think deserve a mention are sharib and hemachandra... sharib was my personal favourite- i just love his voice... but for some reason i don't think he would have got far with judges... if it was down to judges, the male that would have won would have been hemachandra... he's a great singer and once again this showed in his song for alag (just wish it wasn't picturised on karan johar 😆 )