Rank and Rate 18th May Performances! - Page 2

Just finished seeing the video by Suruchi...

Debojit was just toooooo good! Absolutely Brilliant 👏

Coming over to the jodis, here are the rankings

1. Ujjaini & Aishwarya - Superb, even after Ujjaini having so much pain in the leg - she was so good and Aishwarya supported very well 👍🏼

2. Banjyotsna & Sharib - Really did not understand why there was so much controversy created unnecessarily.. I thought they were OK though there was a scale issue... 😕

3. Sanchali and Rajeev - They did not do justice to the song, its such a beautiful number by Kishore'da.. I guess Rajeev had to sing on a lower scale to match up Sanchali.. Overall mediocre

4. Twinkle and Vishwas - I think they were really bad today.. Vishwas just murdered the song! Dont want to say anything more 🤢

This is too much...The people who have respectable knowledge in music say they were worst and you are saying they are the best...This shows how arrogance has more appeal than singing..I hate that Sharib.. 😡

Originally posted by: affluent

This is too much...The people who have respectable knowledge in music say they were worst and you are saying they are the best...This shows how arrogance has more appeal than singing..I hate that Sharib.. 😡

Now - isn't that tooo strong a word to use against Sharib, or for that matter anyone? You may have your likes and dislikes, but lets show restraint from making such personal remarks!

Debojit was very good. WAs it live or recorded not sure. That was so touching that he talked about his mother. very humble and down to earth guy.

WALK OUT IS THE NEW THEME IN INDIAN MUSIC REALITY SHOWS

SR sounded arrogant with their answer about public voting. They are just plain lucky. They should know that
I think it is inappropriate to ask who will be voted out. I think Sharib gave a verydiplomatic answer
I think it is very annoying that they keep asking judges and contestants about who is going to voted out. I think it is inappropriate

UA; awesome. They both sang very well. Ujjaini was awesome even with her tornligament. Aishwarya has improved sooomuch. very good. I loved Ujjaini's answer about how she would spend the money if she wins. She was genuine

TV: Vishwas was ok, oversang the song a bit. I think Twinkle sings every song with the same sensual feeling, that it sounds like a item number. Twinkle was really mediocre. Overall fine. I dont think it was that great for Hariharan to praise that much.

SR: The song did not have the romantic feel of the original song. Again Rajeev had his low pitch issue. Sanchali was good, but was sharp in places. I think RAjeev was very inappropriate about pointing fingers on Vishwas. VEry silly.

SB: Sharib sang in a lower pitcha and sounded gruff. I think he did not sing well today. I think he was trying to compensate for Banjyotsna's voice. THey sang in completely different scales. It was very bad. Hariharan was completely right. They should have picked another song, I think this excuse was ridiculous. I think Sharib should have just accepted and moved on. He sounded like a complainer and he always does that. That is not nice to whine after singing. I feel that they did not rehearse enough and if they did they would have known the problem, This attitude is going to get them voted out. vEry sad. The first and foremost thing to learn is to accept mistakes and stop whining and learn from mistakes to be a good singer. I cannot believe that these upcoming singers show this much attitude.
Hariharan should say about the sur by hitting a nail on Leslie;s head since he harps so much about prancing on stage. It does affect singing.

I think they should not have DEbojit singing before the results. It was kind of inappropriate that he was singng and others were talking among themselves. Anyway my opinion

i think UA were the only good ones. rEst all were mediocre.
I did feel bad for Twinkle(not that she sings well) but and agree that she should not have come to this contest and made her career with her fame from sRGMP2005

Originally posted by: sweetmusic

Debojit was very good. WAs it live or recorded not sure. That was so touching that he talked about his mother. very humble and down to earth guy.

WALK OUT IS THE NEW THEME IN INDIAN MUSIC REALITY SHOWS

SR sounded arrogant with their answer about public voting. They are just plain lucky. They should know that
I think it is inappropriate to ask who will be voted out. I think Sharib gave a verydiplomatic answer
I think it is very annoying that they keep asking judges and contestants about who is going to voted out. I think it is inappropriate

UA; awesome. They both sang very well. Ujjaini was awesome even with her tornligament. Aishwarya has improved sooomuch. very good. I loved Ujjaini's answer about how she would spend the money if she wins. She was genuine

TV: Vishwas was ok, oversang the song a bit. I think Twinkle sings every song with the same sensual feeling, that it sounds like a item number. Twinkle was really mediocre. Overall fine. I dont think it was that great for Hariharan to praise that much.

SR: The song did not have the romantic feel of the original song. Again Rajeev had his low pitch issue. Sanchali was good, but was sharp in places. I think RAjeev was very inappropriate about pointing fingers on Vishwas. VEry silly.

SB: Sharib sang in a lower pitcha and sounded gruff. I think he did not sing well today. I think he was trying to compensate for Banjyotsna's voice. THey sang in completely different scales. It was very bad. Hariharan was completely right. They should have picked another song, I think this excuse was ridiculous. I think Sharib should have just accepted and moved on. He sounded like a complainer and he always does that. That is not nice to whine after singing. I feel that they did not rehearse enough and if they did they would have known the problem, This attitude is going to get them voted out. vEry sad. The first and foremost thing to learn is to accept mistakes and stop whining and learn from mistakes to be a good singer. I cannot believe that these upcoming singers show this much attitude.
Hariharan should say about the sur by hitting a nail on Leslie;s head since he harps so much about prancing on stage. It does affect singing.

I think they should not have DEbojit singing before the results. It was kind of inappropriate that he was singng and others were talking among themselves. Anyway my opinion

i think UA were the only good ones. rEst all were mediocre.
I did feel bad for Twinkle(not that she sings well) but and agree that she should not have come to this contest and made her career with her fame from sRGMP2005

sr sounded arrogant?😕 did u hear twinkle and what she said that in reality shows always injustice is done😡debu's win over vinit was fully justified.what was debu doing keeping mum.if i would have been their i would have told her to shut up.nautanki kahinki😡

Sadaf I always found ur biased opinion abt BS jodi...

I haventw atched yesterday performance ; still I read update from thsi section ..

Jodi number 2: according to the judges: Sharib and Banjotsna
They sing Bin tere sanam mar mitenge hum.. They sing well.. But the scale of both Sharib and Banjo are not matching.. Sharib takes a high scale and banjo takes a low scale.. This creates a problem and the GG's scold them for not singing well.. now they are not singing well because of the reason that banjo had a sore throat and sharib has some cracks in his lips.. Hariji also agrees to it but then says, wen u sing concentrate on sing rather than the performance..

According to judges TV performed well too...

So r u giving points by taking Sharib in high scale & Banjo in low scale separately ? 😕
I dont understand the separation of marks...When they sung togetehr u shoudl mark them together their support to each other & whetehr they r loosing control of anything...

Rather than keep giving separately & giving more marks for sharib always to compensate the marks u agve to banjo....

I agree its ur opinion; but i prefer u rank them as a jodi not separately...as this is not a solo singer competetion & judges giving them for overall performance of both...As a jodi both have to sing well too & support each other...

Anyways this is just my opinion but am compelled to say thsi time as I always finding ur opinion biased on shaarib;

1. UA (GOOD)
2. SR (BAD)
3. BS/TV (CRAP)

i liked da way sharib banjo sang i dunno wat they were talkin abt

Originally posted by: meera_005

i liked da way sharib banjo sang i dunno wat they were talkin abt

agree with u 😊

Originally posted by: sumesh

Sadaf I always found ur biased opinion abt BS jodi...

I haventw atched yesterday performance ; still I read update from thsi section ..

Jodi number 2: according to the judges: Sharib and Banjotsna
They sing Bin tere sanam mar mitenge hum.. They sing well.. But the scale of both Sharib and Banjo are not matching.. Sharib takes a high scale and banjo takes a low scale.. This creates a problem and the GG's scold them for not singing well.. now they are not singing well because of the reason that banjo had a sore throat and sharib has some cracks in his lips.. Hariji also agrees to it but then says, wen u sing concentrate on sing rather than the performance..

According to judges TV performed well too...

So r u giving points by taking Sharib in high scale & Banjo in low scale separately ? 😕
I dont understand the separation of marks...When they sung togetehr u shoudl mark them together their support to each other & whetehr they r loosing control of anything...

Rather than keep giving separately & giving more marks for sharib always to compensate the marks u agve to banjo....

I agree its ur opinion; but i prefer u rank them as a jodi not separately...as this is not a solo singer competetion & judges giving them for overall performance of both...As a jodi both have to sing well too & support each other...

Anyways this is just my opinion but am compelled to say thsi time as I always finding ur opinion biased on shaarib;

sumesh i think u missed that part of my post where i rate the jodies in a combined manner. its not that i give marks seperately only, after that i always rate the jodies altogether.

and yes seriously there wasnt any big issue related to BS as the judges created. both of them sang pretty well. and so i give them marks as to how i felt they sang and i dont give marks on the basis of judges comments, as they are biased towards some!

sharib usually gets more marks from me as he sings brilliantly most of the times, thats it! like u can read some previous topics of mine too, last week on thursday and friday sharib was superb and yes he managed to get all 10 marks from me. when he doesnt sing well, he cant get the same! yes i do like sharib a lot but in this topic i try to be as unbiased as i can.

and by the way sumesh first kindly watch the episode and then point out towards others ratings and analysis! 😊