karunya from II is singing - Page 8

Originally posted by: madhavir108

aneesha, I would like to just stress one thing over and over again, that Amey is an amazing singer and that is my personal opinion. After hearing his Laga Chunari Pe Daag, my expectations from Amey is a LOT more!! His Juda Hoke Bhi was good.. and so was his Mahi Ve. Heck, I liked his RDB too.. if it was any other singer I would be shocked at the simple fact that he attempted such a hard song. I dont like his newer songs because his older songs are according to me MUCH MUCH MUCH better. I loved his Tu Mile that he sang during the Piano Round.. I loved his Tanhayee he sang during auditions..but they come no where close to his Lagaa Chunari pe daag. If he can pull off such an amazing old son which is very hard, it really shouldnt be that hard for him to pull of a Suno Na... I wish he would sing more classica songs though..I cant wait to listen to his Satrangi re..

Karu..well Kava Kava and Lagan Lagi are relatively new, so I wouldn't say he sings only old songs. Whatever happens, Amey and Karu deserve to be top 2..after tat who ever performs better on that day wins.. but these 2 really really deserve to be there in the finals..


I dont think u r attacking me at any cost!! you are just voicing your opinion and so am i..

I agree. Out of the 4, Karunya and Amey certainly deserve the crown and I would not mind if it goes to either of them - though in my heart after watching the previous gala, I feel more inclined towards Karunya. May the best of these two win!

Well okay u win i lose....now is dat fine????.......i hope u r happy now 😊 ........i also want both of them to b in top 2 but dis is also fact that karu only sings sukwinder's song n do justice 2 them bcoz his voice suits on thses types of songs unless 2 sum others. When he sang sonu's song, chakde chakde, it wasn't gud n he recieved bad comments on dat song...........anyway i also wish da best of them wins bcoz both r equaly gud.

hehe its not about who wins and who loses.. enough fights happening already !!!!

sigh..its been almost 3 weeks since SRGMP C05 drew a final curtain..but voices still echoin.....

Originally posted by: madhavir108

hehe its not about who wins and who loses.. enough fights happening already !!!!

sigh..its been almost 3 weeks since SRGMP C05 drew a final curtain..but voices still echoin.....

yep and still arguements and wonders even after it is over...

I saw the II2 episode just today in which Karunya sang Ramta Jogi... I think he was stupendous!! Sur was right, he sounded good, the diction was cool. I enjoyed his performance immensely! 👏 👏

u know i thought that karunya sang it a little better than hema because of his diction and his voice suited the song perfectly when hema sang it he didn't have too much diction and his voice was low but they are both good singers and i wish them great luck...

Hmm Sweety i beg to disagree..

Karunya didnt sing it to his true potential..the singing was technically perfect..but there was something missing..

Listen in the beginning itself to get an idea.. 'Naa Jaane Dil Vich Ki Aaya... Main Prem payala pee aaya'..just tat bit.. n u can make out hte difference.. Hemu sang like he was in love.. he sang like a Ramta Jogi!!And the imprefections he had made that song sound like his own...

Karu also messed up on the Jogi part in the end.. and somehow the performance was a let down..

I guess I am having too much of expectations from Karu after hearing his Shiva Sankari (Classical performancE).. and I couldnt watch his Ramta Jogi without keeping Hemu's in my head !

And I thought Hemu took it a bit higher than karu...

Originally posted by: madhavir108

Hmm Sweety i beg to disagree..

Karunya didnt sing it to his true potential..the singing was technically perfect..but there was something missing..

Listen in the beginning itself to get an idea.. 'Naa Jaane Dil Vich Ki Aaya... Main Prem payala pee aaya'..just tat bit.. n u can make out hte difference.. Hemu sang like he was in love.. he sang like a Ramta Jogi!!And the imprefections he had made that song sound like his own...

Karu also messed up on the Jogi part in the end.. and somehow the performance was a let down..

I guess I am having too much of expectations from Karu after hearing his Shiva Sankari (Classical performancE).. and I couldnt watch his Ramta Jogi without keeping Hemu's in my head !

And I thought Hemu took it a bit higher than karu...

I completely agree wid ya👏. Obvioulsy hemu sang beta than karu bcoz hemu got da song right dat moment n derefore he also didn't practice n karu practiced dis song 4 a week n i also think hemu had dat pain in his voice n a lot of mitthas. Am not saying karu didn't sing gud............he was also gud but i would give him 9 n i would rate hemu 9.9 out of 10.

Keerin_Jay ji, it does sound the same 'technically'..but hear it carefully...when he says Main Pee Aaya Main Pee Aaya, Hema modulates hsi voice very well.. especially at the Pee.. Karu didn't do it too well...

But nonetheless, Karu was fantastic.. after Laaga Chunari PE Daag of Amey, this was the best performance of the galas...