CLONES - A DATABASE - Page 15

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

Absolutely they are just wonderful....which is this last one...

then there is Kaun hai ju sapne main aaya.. I somehow like his songs which arent that popular... like Mehfil se uth jaane walon.. or Tu kaha.. from TGKS

Dil ka bhawar fro TGKS again...Key Jaan chali jaaye from anjaana... so on...

First, TGKS songs are very popular. And I know all the songs that you have mentioned. You seem to like songs that are subdued. These are the songs in which Rafi Sahab has absolutely no scope to reach 3.5, trust me.not that he could not have done it, but the respective mds would not have allowed it. It would have ruined the songs. Plzz listen to the songs that i have listed.👍🏼 And I accept all thanks in advance for letting you in on all these gems.😊

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

Its like saying I cant back into a stroller.. u see its a kind of calculated statement which will have me waiting for a while to ensure there arent adult strollers (and i was misinformed..) but know for sure that i cant fit into baby one right now - and that doesnt require me to realy go ahead and try that out....do I ????? 😆 😆

Also I agree with you that there might be more beautiful songs of Rafi.. i agree but I kinda like his haunting echoing melodies and rare gems over his top twenty.. or top forty.....

There you go again. I have not mentioned any song that is in his commercial top 20 or 40. PLzz go over that list once.😊 and my reply to your earlier post.

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

thats gross misinterpretation all i was asnwering is your statement that its not impossible to span a 3 octave range.. true.. but singing in that range is quite a differnt thing.. try even talking in that range it can be exhausting.. so if I have implied that Rafi was screaming over his 2.5 pr 2.75 range then I apologize though it was totally misinterpreted.. I cant think of saying such a thing for the sheer legay he has left behind and which makes my day many a times... 😊

there you go again......try shouting../ means what...we are to attempt what Rafi Sahab did(not shouting, but singing) and then fail completely? Does that not imply that WE WILL FAIL IF WE ATTEMPT TO SING, SHOUT, SCREAM, ETCin that range. If we cannot do it, so even Rafi Sahab could not have done it.😆😆😆

Rafi Sahab is born once in a lifetime. We should not decide his abilities based upon what we can do.He was unique,,,,NOT LIKE US. Is that simple. Hence what you find impossible to do, does not mean he found it impossble to do. He was different. And yes, he never went to that place you had mentioned, to try and scream to find out if he could reach 3.5...with or without first aid.😉

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Iggjhactly. Reason why Rafi Sahab passed away at the age of 58. High pitched singing strains your heart. And to maintain that silken stretchable voice, he used to keep sipping Malai Chai. That's very bad for the heart. Thanks to Geetadi (musicpulseji) for the info 👍🏼.

Rafi's range, as by that article I posted, is over 3 octaves. That's from a credible source.

Abhi, he was 56 when he passed away.

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

👍🏼 👍🏼 Great songs no doubt 😊

ofcourse they are. And again your "great songs" comment implies you have heard them. And after hearing them, you are arguing like this...I mean...common.....accept his range. He could have reached 3.5 or admit you have not heard these songs, hence are not well-informed about Rafi Sahab, hence not fit to argue. Case rests.😉

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

Sat vachan.....hum already 24 uthak batak kar liya hoon na...... 😆 that place is close to abhi i dont know much about that.... 👏 👏 👏

😆

Originally posted by: musicpulse

ofcourse they are. And again your "great songs" comment implies you have heard them. And after hearing them, you are arguing like this...I mean...common.....accept his range. He could have reached 3.5 or admit you have not heard these songs, hence are not well-informed about Rafi Sahab, hence not fit to argue. Case rests.😉

so qwerty ji, i assume you have read this also.😆

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Geetadi takes the day👏 . First round to Geetadi. Qwerty saab, are you up to continue or...? 😉

abhi, this is not the first round, it is the end of the case.

Rafi Sahab was, is and will remain the best and no doubt he could have reaches 3.5😉

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

Ab toh hum yeh bhi bhul gaye hai ki baat kis octave may ki jaati hai...whereas geetaji started on the lower octave and reached the 5th one in the end..... 😆

Well i am total Rafi Bhakta...had to follow him there.😉

Peace brother?😊