Saregamapa Injustice

Page

Next Last

Poll

Which contestants exit in the Agnipariksha Round was the most unjust?

-shehzaadi-

@-shehzaadi-

Rocker

Posted: 19 years ago

PLZ PARTICIPATE IN THIS POLL AND FEEL FREE 2 GIVE COMMENTS

Quote

Frequent Posters

sameer seth

@sameerseth

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

there are 3 votes given to the top 3 contestants on this list ,no need for me to further elobrate.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Aruna

@ab_srgmp

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

Although Hema was my favorite, I would say Nihira. After Nihira, I knew Hema's turn was coming soon.

Quote

Shreyafan

@Shreyafan

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: ab_srgmp
Although Hema was my favorite, I would say Nihira. After Nihira, I knew Hema's turn was coming soon.

Yes, You have a point but still I would say that this was a game show and the public system was introduced, so as per the rule, regardless of the fact you sing well or not, it was obvious that somebody had to go out each week so Nihira's Himani's and Hema's turn for the elimination came out soon. It looked as if it was not a singing competition but it looked as if it was the competition that who has catched up lots of votes and who has got least thats it...................

Quote

Shivani Shah

@shivvy16

Navigator

Posted: 19 years ago

i think tht the last 3 outsed challenger's elimination was the most injustice! i think tht from thm 3 1 of thm should have won or should have been in the final 2 with vinit;)

Quote

Shreyafan

@Shreyafan

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

Dear Petlover,

I completely agree with you that injustice was done to sharib nihira and Hema but I think you mistook me my friend. 😊 I didnot mean to remind anybody or something like that but I meant to say that more then a singing competition it looked as if it was a voting competition as to who received lots of votes and who has received less votes regardless of the fact whether you sing well or not. 😆. This was my intention my friend and not to remind anybody yaar. 😊

Quote

madhavi_r108

@madhavi_r108

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I haven't heard much of Sharib but I heard he was really good. So its sad he got voted out.

Well, see my view personally is tht its fine to get voted out if you performed bad that time or something like that, or you were weaker than the rest but when there are people around you, who were much much worse and you get voted out, its unfair, its VERY unfair.

That way, i felt bad for Swananda mainly. Because she wasn't that bad to have gotten voted out.

Other than that, Hema, Nihira and Himani got the success they needed. So if the got ousted, well they had too! We can't have everything in life.

A Hema vs Nihira final would have been a cracker, can you imagine how hard it would be to accept who ever gets voed out then ?!?!?!

Quote

NMK

@NipunKhatri

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I guess it was Nihira... 😃

Quote

Not Given

@Chippeshwini

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 19 years ago

nihira.
even though i absolutely love hemachandra, i realllly liked nihira. she was the best
her departure was probably the saddest, and it was also the most stupid one
the week before she had given 2 AMAZING (as all of her performances) performances, and so HOW can she get he least amount of votes becuase of that?
audience voting is just not the right choice

Edited by rach_nir - 19 years ago