Vinit - Talent 6 out of 10 only - Page 2

Originally posted by: chatbuster

arre yaar, phir woh mentors ke marks kee baat? kabhie chor bank manager ko achey marks dega? naheen na? wahee toh!😉

Nahin yaar, leave the mentors, even other musicians gave Vinit quite good points, but that is besides the point but ur analogy was quite intelligent, it will take people atleast 5 minutes to figure out😉

Originally posted by: divine303

how dare u say vinit knows nothing about music!?! he knows very well how to copy sonu and rafi....if he wins he will learn to copy shaan, kunal, udit and so forth....this is how in this music industry not only we will have copycat music directors but also copycat singer.just think about it. inspiration will overflow

😆 copy song copy song..... most new songs are copy songs

Originally posted by: chatbuster

arre yaar, phir woh mentors ke marks kee baat? kabhie chor bank manager ko achey marks dega? naheen na? wahee toh!😉

👏

Originally posted by: letsrock123

Nahin yaar, leave the mentors, even other musicians gave Vinit quite good points, but that is besides the point but ur analogy was quite intelligent, it will take people atleast 5 minutes to figure out😉

i can understand where those judges were coming from. fwiw, i too was rooting 4 vinit in the earlier rounds- he caught my attention perhaps because i cldnt stand JL's antics, i'd heard Vinit previously with his Fiza song which i found (to borrow that phrase) "mind-blowing", n i found HR standing up 4 a deserving guy. If u'd had the vote then, i wld have been solidly with Vinit. he caught my eye like no one else.

but somewhere later, i began to feel as i do now that Vinit is pretty one-dimensional. His is the 3K-5K frequency range when incidentally good western classical gets down as low as 25Hz. And the more HR hyped him n got his cronies to give him high marks, the more i felt that Vinit was getting a free ride. Some of these later rounds also exposed that uni-dimensionality.

my experience with debo has been quite the reverse. he started above average n today i truly feel he is the best. sure, if u want to be really analytical, he has his shortcomings. but in terms of what the ears can take for hours on end without tiring, his voice is almost as smooth as they come. no harshness. not a note of shrillness. n i am a strong believer in any case that art n music n beauty, indeed most of life, is not subject to mathematical logic of perfect sur or taal or perfect nose or eyes. it's more sublime n 4 some rational/ irrational reason, i found that in debo's singing. (n this bit of irrationality coming from a guy trained in the rational disciplines of business & finance!)

of course, my views may change tomorrow, as they have 4 vinit. ur likes n dislikes n ur tastes r not guaranteed to stay the same. so who knows abt tomorrow. u might yet find me someday in vinit's camp. but he's not there now.😉

Originally posted by: karans22

Vinit if you win this event please try to learn more about music . Till now you have not master M . U S I C is still there to learn .

I dont know how you are getting such bif votes .

Debo dont worry you are 10 out of 10 . The Kishore Kumar of tomorrow.

😆WHAT A JOKE!I CAN'T STOP LAUGHING!WHAT AN INSULT TO KISHORE KUMAR AND VINIT!

Originally posted by: vishucool

😆WHAT A JOKE!I CAN'T STOP LAUGHING!WHAT AN INSULT TO KISHORE KUMAR AND VINIT!

Insult to uski hoti hai jiski koi ijjat ho, Vinit ko charitraheen hai😆

I would rather give vinit 5.5 out of 10 . Tell me why the grace mark of .5 .

Hey hennahaider have you mastered music to beleive Vinit has mastered music?

Originally posted by: hennahaider

EXACTLY!!!!!!!!!!

music appreciation does not require you to be a master. just like you do not have to be a picasso to appreciate abstract art. what you do need is some education to appreciate the tradition of music, its history, relationship with culture and politics, breadth and scope, principles, elements, intruments, styles, and so forth.