ID should answer this

During Nihira's elimination(one of the worst elimination)vinit and Nihira were at danger level,He said "Aap log yahan kaise aa gaye"?

He liked Himani very much so it was very clear that He dint want her to b out..

Now he is telling that Debu is equal to kishoreji and is comparing Hemu to SPB,Hariharan.. So whom did he want to be out?

Originally posted by: bangboy

During Nihira's elimination(one of the worst elimination)vinit and Nihira were at danger level,He said "Aap log yahan kaise aa gaye"?

He liked Himani very much so it was very clear that He dint want her to b out..

Now he is telling that Debu is equal to kishoreji and is comparing Hemu to SPB,Hariharan.. So whom did he want to be out?

He meant it with Nihira. He couldn't believe it and even asked "kya sachmuch bahar ho gayi" You know when you are really hurt, sometimes it is difficult to think and right words don't come out.

We all know how upset he was after he realized it that Nihira is gone. He really liked her don't put ifs and buts on that. He was very proud of her.

Originally posted by: bangboy

During Nihira's elimination(one of the worst elimination)vinit and Nihira were at danger level,He said "Aap log yahan kaise aa gaye"? He liked Himani very much so it was very clear that He dint want her to b out.. Now he is telling that Debu is equal to kishoreji and is comparing Hemu to SPB,Hariharan.. So whom did he want to be out?

He had complemented Himani's performance in an earlier episode (remember that or are you purposely trying to confuse people). ID has a big heart and if anybody performs well, he does not feel insecure like HR. He praises them with his whole heart. Remember when he also gave 50 bucks to Vineet. Does that mean that now he wants Vineet to stay and not Debojit. Thats immature and preponderous talk. Think before posting comments like this.

Yes thats true.He was very upset about Nihira's exit.

But when the result wasn't out, and only Nihira and Vinit were left, He asked this question?(that means he was thinking that someone else other than Nihira and Vinit shld have been out)

Originally posted by: onlyinindia

He had complemented Himani's performance in an earlier episode (remember that or are you purposely trying to confuse people). ID has a big heart and if anybody performs well, he does not feel insecure like HR. He praises them with his whole heart. Remember when he also gave 50 bucks to Vineet. Does that mean that now he wants Vineet to stay and not Debojit. Thats immature and preponderous talk. Think before posting comments like this.

I dint quote anyone's name,Either he wanted Hemu or Debu to be out which is contradicting his present statement

Originally posted by: bangboy

I dint quote anyone's name,Either he wanted Hemu or Debu to be out which is contradicting his present statement

How do you know that he did not want Himani to be out? Its also possible that he wanted anybody to be out except Nihira? Stop hypotheisizing on whom he wanted to be out and whom he wanted to be in! If you cannot stop thinking than be consistent with your thinking. Right now he wants Vineet to be out. So will you support ID on that????????

its very disheartening to say that id's behavior has undergone a drastic change since this show has reached the finals
he was the only one tolerable from the mentors
but now he has also started behaving like the other mentors only

Originally posted by: bangboy

Yes thats true.He was very upset about Nihira's exit.

But when the result wasn't out, and only Nihira and Vinit were left, He asked this question?(that means he was thinking that someone else other than Nihira and Vinit shld have been out)

Ofcourse, some-else should have been out and not Nihira. Because all the rest of them were not better then Nihira. Nihira actually deserved to be the winner after that song called SAATHI RE BHOOL NA JAANA.....

Ask himani to attempt this song and she would have been a big ZERO.

Originally posted by: saregama

Ofcourse, some-else should have been out and not Nihira. Because all the rest of them were not better then Nihira. Nihira actually deserved to be the winner after that song called SAATHI RE BHOOL NA JAANA.....

Ask himani to attempt this song and she would have been a big ZERO.

I agree 100%