Don't you think Shann is little partial t - Page 2

what i believe is we need to see the talent and support me being a south indian always voted for Nihira,Debojit and of course Hemu(as Hemu has real talents in him)

Originally posted by: Iron

I am From UP but had tenanats & neighbours as friend and in US to I have quite Bengali friendss.And I am always impressed with their rich culture and ofcourse they are very intelligent.We have bad/good,rich/poor, Intelligent /Stupid people everywhere so to judge whole state based on few people is wrong..No matter what overall Bengal culture has been more advance and gave us wonderful actors,singers,poets,writer.. We still cannot comaper ShantiNiketan.


So to continue this thread ia a insult of a very rich culture. Pl do not bad mouth anyone as it does not show a good culture in you either

then ask others also to not to comment on other cultures..
as they keep on pullin vinit an gajendra..
as i also do share the same surname..

Guys why are you taking this discussion on wrong track.

When Shantanu Moitra said he wish to give 11 points to Vinit & Bhumika wish to give 101 points to Vinit is that mean they also think the same about DEBO? Why Shann embarrassing them by asking what they think about DEBo & was they want to give him 10 or more than 10 points.
I am still great fan of Shaan but I think Shaan is now emotionally attached with Debo & stop thinking practically.

singh nilima- bengalis are crack.....
you are a crack....better check the contribution of BEngalis to India and then say....

Most of all the greats that you can thiink of are bengalis- BTW- have you heard of Rabindra nath Tagore, Sarat Chandra Chatterjee, Satyajit Ray, Amartya Sen....

well i am sure sure you have not heard ...because you seem to be totally unpar and gaawar......

Remember Tilak said "What BEngal does today- India does tommorrow".
Check all details before making these stupid comments- go and check the history of teh Great Singh's and their contribution....
"BTW- i am a mumbaikar myself",,,,,but its sad a fellow mumbaikar is such an idiot....

Shan has no business to be Partial towards any contestant.

Shan was partial to DEBO in that episode where HEMA got elimated.

He stated that if the votes from the Eastern Zone had to be taken out then the votes from the Southern Zone also should be taken out & the otes from the Western Zone & Northern Zone only should be taken into account.

Shan showed his stand here. Vinit belongs to UP which falls in the Northern Zone.
So, even those votes should not be taken into account.
If that had be the case then, Debo got the least votes from the Western Zone & so he should have been eliminated & not HEMA.

By making such a bad statement Shan only showed everyone that he is favouring DEBO & not HEMA.

Anyway, who cares for Shan's preference.

Everyone knows HEMA was THE BEST. Do you think a person like SUBASH GHAI will support HEMA if he was not GOOD & offer him a chance?
As well said by AS Subesh Ghai is good & knows to pick the right person.

Originally posted by: knsa

Shan has no business to be Partial towards any contestant.

Shan was partial to DEBO in that episode where HEMA got elimated.

He stated that if the votes from the Eastern Zone had to be taken out then the votes from the Southern Zone also should be taken out & the otes from the Western Zone & Northern Zone only should be taken into account.

Shan showed his stand here. Vinit belongs to UP which falls in the Northern Zone.
So, even those votes should not be taken into account.
If that had be the case then, Debo got the least votes from the Western Zone & so he should have been eliminated & not HEMA.

By making such a bad statement Shan only showed everyone that he is favouring DEBO & not HEMA.

Anyway, who cares for Shan's preference.

Everyone knows HEMA was THE BEST. Do you think a person like SUBASH GHAI will support HEMA if he was not GOOD & offer him a chance?
As well said by AS Subesh Ghai is good & knows to pick the right person.

Hey man what's got into to you. Did you know that if Shaan had not stood up for debu, then that rascal AS would have started a another crap fight about that debu got 3rd in the west. the decision would not even be taken if it was not for shaans answer back. Serves AS right that he got out. i don't miss at all.

Originally posted by: knsa

Shan has no business to be Partial towards any contestant.

Shan was partial to DEBO in that episode where HEMA got elimated.

He stated that if the votes from the Eastern Zone had to be taken out then the votes from the Southern Zone also should be taken out & the otes from the Western Zone & Northern Zone only should be taken into account.

Shan showed his stand here. Vinit belongs to UP which falls in the Northern Zone.
So, even those votes should not be taken into account.
If that had be the case then, Debo got the least votes from the Western Zone & so he should have been eliminated & not HEMA.

By making such a bad statement Shan only showed everyone that he is favouring DEBO & not HEMA.

Anyway, who cares for Shan's preference.

Everyone knows HEMA was THE BEST. Do you think a person like SUBASH GHAI will support HEMA if he was not GOOD & offer him a chance?
As well said by AS Subesh Ghai is good & knows to pick the right person.

Are you crazy or what😡 Shan said that only to make a point that if you want to take NE votes ouit and see where Debo stands, then you should do it for all three contestants, i.e., take everyone's homeground votes out. Shan has never ever being partila......he even told Hema that hema's Preyasi song was the best in SRGMP to date. Please stop maligning Shan and incurring regional insults on fellow fiorum memebers. By the way, I am from UP.....not Bengal or NE but I love my country.......we are special because we have soooo maanyy languages, religions, and cultures. Please stop being crabs and pulling each other down

Shan just replied to "Bias "AS" confusion" . Definately he is not Bias. We should not waste our time in this stupid topics.

Originally posted by: knsa

Shan has no business to be Partial towards any contestant.

Shan was partial to DEBO in that episode where HEMA got elimated.

He stated that if the votes from the Eastern Zone had to be taken out then the votes from the Southern Zone also should be taken out & the otes from the Western Zone & Northern Zone only should be taken into account.

Shan showed his stand here. Vinit belongs to UP which falls in the Northern Zone.
So, even those votes should not be taken into account.
If that had be the case then, Debo got the least votes from the Western Zone & so he should have been eliminated & not HEMA.

By making such a bad statement Shan only showed everyone that he is favouring DEBO & not HEMA.

Anyway, who cares for Shan's preference.

Everyone knows HEMA was THE BEST. Do you think a person like SUBASH GHAI will support HEMA if he was not GOOD & offer him a chance?
As well said by AS Subesh Ghai is good & knows to pick the right person.

let me guess- u're one of hema's "neutral zone" supporters from the south, right? the same folks who gave 18L votes to hema and just 3L to the other two, yet r so "unbiased"?

btw, nothing wrong with what shaan said or did. do u expect him to be a wallflower n just parrot things? even his logic was correct if u'd only bother to understand it- if u want an analysis on that, wld be happy to provide. to summarize, even if u removed RESPECTIVE home town votes for each contestant, hema wld have been out.

re. what SG wld do, looks like he has also "sathiyaod". first vivek oberoi in kisna n now this.

Originally posted by: Nilsat

Don't you think Shann is little partial towards DEBO, is it because Shaan is belongs to North East India.

please don't drag Shaan into the mess created by HR, AS and GS.😡

He is a decent guy. He cannot be partial towards anybody.

He does whatever been told to him by GS.

Bhaiyya, Shaan ko to baksh do.😆