All 5 Comparison Scores (by Anurag) - Page 2

Originally posted by: srianne

I do understand the meaning of "SARCASM", probably you didn't know where to use those 😉.

There is no point in fighting over this stupid reason. I still believe what I believed yesterday.

Originally posted by: bigmac

Friends

I listened to each song sung by Hemachandra, Debojit, Vineet, Himani and Nihira, that have been posted thus far on both the following sites:

http://www.voiceofambition.com/voa/content/view/24/50/

http://as01.cooltoad.com/go/music?user=dizzybanana21x& go=1

After listening to each song on a hi fidelity headphone, I gave the song a score (1 to 10) based on a multitude of factors:

Musicality

Voice Quality

Tone

Sur

Variations

Difficulty

Technicality

Style

Pronunciation

Average Scores from All Songs (Out of 10): Highest to Lowest

Debojit: 7.79

Nihira: 7.30

Hemachandra: 7.12

Vinit: 6.72

Himani: 6.71

Based on the above individual song results, I think I feel safe to vouch for Debojit from my view. I am suprised to discover this but a audio-only healdphone analysis revealed what I had not noticed on the TV show.

The scoring was done unbiased and entirely based on the "audio-only" and not on video-and-audio.

If you disagree with my scoring, I respect that. This is only my opinion although I have been completely unbiased and objective in the evaluation.

As regards, my qualifications to adjudicate, you can check them out and listen to sound bytes for whatever they are worth) at: www.AnuragHarsh.com (personal hyperlink)

Please don't shoot me personally if you disagree. Obviously you are entitled to your opinions and I respect that. Should you wish to inquire about why I gave a particular score to an individual song, feel free to message me. For lack of real-estate online, I didn't bother posting a song-level commentary, but have posted my scores instead.

Here are my song level results:

Song (Debojit)	Score		Song (Hemachandra)	Score		Song (Vineet)	Score
Ai Subah	8		Aao Twist Kare	8		Haan Yehi Rasta	8
Aaja Ve Mahi	5		Ande Ka Funda	6		Aaja Ja Main Hoon Pyaar Tera	7
Ae Mere Pyaare Watan	6		Anewala Pal	9		Aapki Kashish	7
Ae Zindagi Gale Laga Le	8		Anewala Pal Janewala Hai	8		Aashiq Banaya	7
Ai Zindagi Gale Lagale	9		Bumbroo	7		Aashiq Banaya - Final 6 Contest	9
Badi Sooni Sooni Hai	7		Channa Ve	8		Ab Tumhare Hawale (Kar Chale Hum Fida)	8
Dil Kya Kare	8		Channa Ve Ghar	6		Bulla Ki Jaana	7
Ek Chatur Naar	7		Chhod Do Aanchal	6		Chale Chalo	8
Ek Haseena Thi	9		Come To Me	8		Diwani Meri Jaan Lag Di	6
Humma Humma	7		Ek Ajnabi	6		Fiza	6
Juda Ho Ke Bhi	8		Gustakiyan	8		Is Pyar Ko Main	6
Kaate Nahin Katte	9		Haan Yeh Rasta Hai	6		Jeene Ke Hain Char Din	6
Main Hoon Jhumroo	10		Kudiyan Nu Bach Ke	8		Kitna Pyaara Wada	7
O Habiba	8		Lekar Hum	8		Kya Hua Tera Wada	8
O Humdum Suniyo Re	8		Main Aisa Kyon Hoon	8		Kyo Kisiko Wafa Ke	6
Oh Ho... Ishq Tera	7		Mera Karma Tu Mera Dharma Tu	6		Nain Lad Gaye Hain	7
Rim Jhim Gire Sawan	9		Mitwa	7		Parda Hai Parda	7
Salaam Namaste	8		Mujse Shaadi Karoge	8		Patta Patta Boota Boota	6
Sanam Mere Humraaz	9		My Dil Goes Mmmm	6		Sandese Aate Hain	7
Suno Gor Se Duniyawaalon			Nahi Saamne	7		Satrange Re	7
Tadap Tadap	7		Saathiya	7		Tera Jadoo Chal Gaya	5
Tumhe Jo Maine Dekha	9		Tanhaiyee	6		Tu Mile Dil Khile	5
Woh Lamhe Woh Batein	7		Tere Mere Beech Mein	6		Yeh Dil Deewana	6
Yeh Haseen Waadiyan	8		Vande Mataram	6		Yeh Dil Deewana (Final 3)	6
Yeh Ishq Ishq	6		Woh Lamhe Woh Batein	9		Zindagi Maut Na Ban Jaaye	6
			Yaadein	7
AVERAGE FOR DEBOJIT	7.79		AVERAGE FOR HEMACHANDRA	7.12		AVERAGE FOR VINIT	6.72

-----------------

Song (Nihira)	Score		Song (Himani)	Score
Aaja Ve Mahi	6		Aaj Ki Raat	6
Aiye Meherban	9		Ab Jo Mile Hain	8
Chup Chup Ke	6		Ae Zindagi Gale Laga Le	8
Dheere Dheere Is Dil	6		Aitraaz (Rock Me Baby)	7
Didi Tera Devar	8		Baghban Rab Hain	8
Dufli Wale	8		Baras Jaye Badal	8
Ek Bhagiya Mein	6		Bhaage Re Mann	6
Ishq Khudaii	7		Chale Jaise Hawa	7
Kajra Re Kajra Re	7		Chitthiye	8
Kala Shah Kala	6		Der Na Ho Jaye	5
Main Sitaron Ka Tarana	5		Hulle Hulla	6
Pyar Hua Chupke Se	8		Huzoor-e-wala	6
Rahen Na Rahen Hum	9		Jiya Dhadak Dhadak	7
Roz Shaam Aati Thi	9		Kaise Paheli Zindagani	7
Saathi Re Bhool Na Jaana	8		Main Yahan Tu Wahan	6
Sara Jahan Kahe Ishq Hai Jhoota	7		Mast	6
Tere Bina Jiya Jaye Na	9		Morni Baaga Mein (Chudiyan Khanak Gaye)	6
Chalka Chalka Re	8		Ni Main Yaar Mananani	6
Ikadajeba	6		Que Sera Sera	6
Kuch Na Kaho	8		Rangeela Maro Dholna	8
			Rangeela Re	6
			Sabki Baraate Aayi	7
			Saiyan Dil Mein Aana Re	6
			Tere Bina Nahi Jeena	7
AVERAGE NIHIRA SCORE	7.30		AVERAGE HIMANI SCORE	6.71

with all due respect to anurag harsh and his qualifications, this is an entirely futile execise. (i also wonder how he gets so much time. i would have thought somebody of his caliber would spend time on much better things. but that's none of my business).

as harsh pointed out in his earlier mega-post in which he gave definition of raga, it ultimately boils down to what sounds good to your ears. and i really appreaciated and agreed with that definition.

a person who understands this truth but still goes on to put performaces in statistics is surely confused.

i believe harsh is a nutcase with identity crisis.

I think very unbiased analysis, and that is why ID gave hema low marks, I always told this that Hema songs do not touch your heart with the exception of last two. Nice analysis Anurag.