Vote for the most deserving person

ranig thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Let's vote for the right and deserving singer. From the beginning the most consistent and quality singers have been Vinit, Himani and Nihira. Hemchandra is a good singer too and times Superb, but he has not been consistent and he primarily was good in songs composed by AR Rehman. If you watch carefully that's all he sang throughout the show. He is definitely a good singer but unfortunately not been totally consistent. However, he should have definitely been in the top 4 and not Debojit. It would have been great to see either Himani or Nihara. A lady singer would have been nice for once.


Anyway, Lets not include the mentors in our biases. They all have been sadly miserable and immature when it came to presentation and discussion. Definitely they are the true musical maestro's of our country. But unfortunately they have to learn to be better speakers. Ismail's crazy reaction and the poor way in which he has been talking, Himmesh's excessive hype and letting people know of Vinit's love life and forcing him to wear the stupid cap, and Adesh's comments and indirect insults to other participants was all sick to watch. Why blame a good talented singer for the behavior of their mentors. Sadly the young singers have behaved more appropriately.

Historically, Assam is a region which has had many issues around regional separation with the rest of india. It's like having a singer who has come from Kashmir so they have a political agenda along with their support to Debojit. I'm not saying Debojit is terrible, but he is basically average and not exceptional. If you watched the show carefully you would have noticed that the mentors almost never gave the guy a 10. These are the greatest music directors of the country who are crude in talk but definitely talented musicians. They based their votes on Talent. Nihira, HImani and Vinit are the only participants who got 10's by the opponent mentors in almost very show. Not one of them has gotten lower then 9 or maybe 8. In all fairness, Atleast the Oppenent mentors where very fair when it came to praising others.

Assams bid to make Debojit the voice has knocked down 3 much better singers and now Vinit Will probably be killed too. Assam will make it's point, but we will be guilty for letting this happen. Our country must start making decisions based on logic not on emotional stupidity. We will never progress if we continue in this way. Why do you think it was so easy for the British to take over india? Our regionalism is our biggest weakness. Hopefully, we will reach a point where a person from the south can support someone from the north, the north the east , the east the west, etc. A muslim a hindu, a hindu a christian, a christian a budhist. Only then we will progress. Let's open our minds and respond logically. If we cant then Srgmp Should go back to the old system. We already have gunda raj in many other aspects of our life. Do we want it to reflect in every aspect?
I hope people will think about this. Lets support talent because we are all Indians first and foremost. Only then will we progress!!!!! Jai HInd!!!!!

Edited by ranig - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

475

Users

4

Frequent Posters

aashiq2005 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

with all due respect RANI, all this lofty speech is a little late in the game. The best have been lost, now it is a fight between the worst. Now whether the buffalo wins or the cow does is quite immaterial.

Of course I must add, you are certainly geographically and politically challenged. Please work on that and improve your knowledge about India.

Edited by aashiq2005 - 19 years ago
arch1209 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
i agree now the competition is between bad and worse. And i think everyone is put of by SRGMP becoz of the way it is promoting regionalism. I really dont care now whoever wins now.
Renuka Patani thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
For the three singers left now on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa, it is really sad to ntoe that instead of the singers competeing it clearly shows on the TV that the judges are competeing with thier slanderous remarks they are making in the show for all the world to see. The singers are just going on with thier steady strenght and making thier outcome stronger and better performers.
I feel the Debouji is rather an average singer and Nihira could have been better. Himesh is also an average singer and it feels that Vineet who has been projected as a Romeo by his mentor and loudmouthed Vineet in every show is also poor. I jsut wish janta can see through all this do the right thing by choosing the right person.
aashiq2005 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Renuka Patani

For the three singers left now on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa, it is really sad to ntoe that instead of the singers competeing it clearly shows on the TV that the judges are competeing with thier slanderous remarks they are making in the show for all the world to see. The singers are just going on with thier steady strenght and making thier outcome stronger and better performers.
I feel the Debouji is rather an average singer and Nihira could have been better. Himesh is also an average singer and it feels that Vineet who has been projected as a Romeo by his mentor and loudmouthed Vineet in every show is also poor. I jsut wish janta can see through all this do the right thing by choosing the right person.

Renukaji,

Instant Quiz:

1. Who are the three singers?

2. Is Himesh a contestant?

3. Did you wake up after a week's Nidraasan?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".