analysis by disciple of Pt. Bhimsen Joshi - Page 3

Great article. Thanks uselogic!

If only judges were introduced from at least top 5 - oh Nihira and Hem!

Now I think they have changed the pattern to suit Vinit as Debo will be the clear winner if gone entirely by public voting.

ANURAGJI IT IS REALLY NICE POST OF YOURS AND HAS DEEP STUDY. ONLY THING I COULD NOT UNDERSTAND WHY HAVE YOU NOT INCLUDED FEMALE SINGERS ?

IT WOULD BE VERY NICE IF YOU ALSO PUT YOUR COMMENT ON FEMALE FINALISTS, ESPECIALLY NIHIRA AND HIMANI, SINCE MOST OF THE FORUM MEMBERS HAVE BEEN FIGHTING ON WHO IS THE BEST! COULD YOU PLEASE THROW SOME LIGHT ON FEMALE FINALISTS PERFORMANCES, THE WAY YOU HAVE DONE ABOUT MALE SINGERS IN THE CONTEST ? IT WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL FOR MEMBERS TO KNOW ON THIS ISSUE, SINCE MOST OF THE MEMBERS ARE OF THE OPINION THAT GIRL SINGERS WERE BETTER THAN BOY SINGERS.

SINCE YOU HAVE STUDIED THE SINGERS SO MINUTELY, COULD YOU PLEASE PUT YOUR TWO CENTS ON WHO WAS THE BEST SINGER AMONG THE FEMALES AND WHO IS OVERALL BEST (MALE/FEMALE PUT TOGETHER)? EARLIER ZEE TV HAD ANNOUNCED THAT THERE WILL BE TWO WINNERS, ONE MALE AND ONE FEMALE, BUT LATER ON THEY CHANGED IT TO ONLY ONE SINGER BEING WINNER OF THE SHOW AND SURPRISINGLY IN FINAL THREE, THERE IS NO FEMALE SINGER!

YOUR OPINION ON THIS SUBJECT WILL BE APPRECIATED. THANKS

It is always a pleasure reading through critical analysis from a qualified person. In fact, I listened to their earlier performances on the show, very carefully. Thanks a ton, Anurag ji and Uselogic.

What actually should have happened was this kind of unbiased analysis should have been given by mentors after each performance and technical imperfections in the performances should have been reflected in the points awarded by the mentors. Unfortunately that did not happen (not on the show at least).

Such articles should be published, so that these lessons are learnt and inputs are taken for the next shows.

Thanks again.

Originally posted by: leonhartzz

For someone who writes about maintaining decorum and not maligning contestants on non-musical issues, you sure do take liberties when it comes to your commenting on Vineet. And FYI, if you read through Anurag's article, he mentions that both Vineet and Debu (not Vineet alone, please note) go besura a lot of times. Very conveniently, you seem to have ignored Debu's flaws while highlighting Vineet's.

By waxing eloquent about Debu and bashing Vineet, you are not really proving yourself to be any different from those "Vineet fans" that you despise so much.

Cheers

adwarkarnath i dont wanna hurt u but from what i am seeing in the last few days u r displaying two totally opposite sides of ur personality

i just read ur 'lets grow up' post and i actually agreed wit some of ur points though i did not support u putting the blame entirely on vinit fans

but then i thought maybe some vinit fanwould have hurt u

but in this and some of the other thread u r behaving the same way for what u hurt this so called baccha party of vinit fans

first of all u have no right to call insult vinit fans while calling them bacchas

why do u wanna invite vinit fans to have a fight wit u and the peace of this forum be destroyed

ur above post clearly suggests that U R NOT A PEACE LOVER AT ALL.

sorry but WHATEVER RESPECT I HAD FOR U HA COMPLETELY VANISHED because u r also behaving in the same way as some bacchas u r so against!!!

so its very easy to search for a fault in some one else but one should concentrate of removing his faults first!!!

SAME IS THE PROBLEM WIT U!!

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Right...if you had actually bothered to read that article fully, you'd have noticed that I had taken debo and all other fans to task too.

I m\am calling for the bachcha party because I am yet to see one intelligible technical post from them supporting their statements. But all we see is - debo suckz, vinit rckz, debo is a train singer etc. tell me, isn't that disturbing peace?>

i agree with u that some people r deatroying the peace of this forum but that doesnt mean that u too do the same

what will u get by inviting vinit fans to pick up a fight wit u and make such a wonderful post into a debo/vinit mahabharat

would u like it if this post also turns into nonsense just because of ur fight wit vinit fans

there r numerous posts where statements degrading vinit and hr too

i think vinit bashing over here is much more than debo

but if matured people like u having so much knowledge also behave in the same way and pick up fights wit people then peace can never be established right???

sorry if i have hurt u but i was very upset to see u behaving like this

hope u understand!!!

[quote= Anurag]music is not about using devices [or experts] to adjudicate quality. As long as it evokes the feelings, it works. [/quote]

i made a minor addition to an almost perfect statement. be they "technically" correct/incorrect, singers must touch the heart. who defines technique anyway? what is the so called "good" or "bad" music? sab kuch dimaag mein hi hain. sab ki pasand alag alag hain. baat khatam.

gosh... here we go once again god ...isn't a healthy discussion possible anywhere or what ..

hello .. we shld thk uselogic for posting this.. Mr.anurag... wooowww.. that was a long one but very interesting .. thk u too..

i am still waiting for anurag to respond 😭

That is an excellent analysis, which is what I was trying to say since I am trained also, but couldnt put it so eloquently.

I think singers like Hariharan, Shankar or Lata Mangeshkar could have been brought in for judging, since they have seen best of both classical and film music theywould be able tojudge. By the way is HImesh classically trained. I recently saw his aashiq banaye song, his voice is so nasal, is that his real voice???
I thought they might atleast call ARR for final show

Why SRGMP is bringing judges like Tabu, who does not know much anything about music. They should bring judges like classical singers who are also playback singers like Lata, Asha, Kavita etc. Whats wrong with Z TV and GSji? Everyone should have raised the hell in the very beginning when there were 10 final contestants itself, now it is kind of late. We are stuck with Vinit & Debo. Vinit is still bachcha and his voice is not completely matured and as Anuraagji mentioned he needs coaching by good Pundits, so I would like to see Debo win because his mentor will definitely groom him as he is already in classical music training and has matured voice.