Exclusive Updates : 02-02-06 - Page 11

Originally posted by: jay_delhi_guy

As always very well said USELOGIC..👏

Dear Royadav/Shaun: We dont have any problem with HR/Vinit, but the way they are polluting this healthy competition is really shameful and cowardly..Vinit isnot at all convincing to the people of North India so that people will vote him to make him the voice of India...

I find Debu much deserving than him....so what I am from Vinitz zone..I will vote for Debu as doing for the last 2 months.....

Delhi_Guy

Delhi_Guy

Well you are already voting for Debo for last two months which tells that is your choice. Then why Vinit is getting maximum number of votes for NORTH ZONE. Only 5.5 Lakhs vote is in favour of Debo. I do not think that HR/VINIT is polluting the competition. VINIT is giving good fight to DEBOJIT If Debo is your deserving candidate does not mean the whole north zone opinion is same as yours

Originally posted by: royadav

first of all mr. uselogic try to use some logic and put forward some logical views ... this is a contest and only one of them is going to win ... as far as the singing talent is concerned every one knows that all the last seven finalists were almost equally talented but only one has to win ... now here comes the funda of making mark on the public and this can only be done through the way it is being done... i think there is no harm in it ... as all of them are famous now and all have a bright future...

you say that the hype whichis created by HR is not good .. then let me ask you ... whether the "chumma" hype by ID was right ??

if the first is wrong then the latter is also wrong..

well. as again thanks for replying..

"if the first is wrong then the latter is also wrong.. ".. well two wrong things doesnt make a thing right.. you mean to say if i say id did wrong than HR' wrong is justified.....which in a way you are accepting that HR is wrong but since ID did chumma thing thats why HR is also right...

Ok when ID gave chumma to DEBO, he really sang the song well. Well we could debate that whether givining chumma was a decent thing to do or a hug would have done..may be right may be wrong...debatable... but yesterday he just said because he wanted to say something...he also gave a 50 rs note to vinit..i can say that is hype.. but have u ever heard ID saying votes to debo because i gave chumma to him... he can deviate a little, but he will stick to music..but HR says, make vinit a winner , so that he can gets his love..this is WRONG..inevst in vinit and invest in india as he is the biggest patriotic..Please do something free of cost..what is this nonsense..let him say vote vinit because he is a good singer..period..had he done it, vinit would have been the topmost vote getter...even if vinits sings good, he will say vote him because he want to get his love..this is not going down well with the public...

hype your contestant. do it... but just because it is a comptetion, u can't go down to any level..No Strict NO. it is music...it is matter of worship for so many people...how can he malign it..people remeber their gurus, god before they go for singing..lata ji used ot be barefooted while recording her song...this is devotion...you need to maintain some decency....

Hotcat/Royadav,
It seems you r very new to this forum..please dear donot take it otherwise.. Read the previous threads in this forum carefully before making comments..
The analysis by USELOGIC is a very neutral one and people are here to appreciate and discuss that. I donot want to fight with anyone's fan. Be someone's fan and support his good things and criticise his bad stuffs thats how your star can be the choice of others also..Otherwise the results show (I dont need to explain).

royadav,

Well said, at last I'm finding some person who is speaking logical. Lot of people here seem to be getting irritated by HR/Vinit hype. But as you have pointed out "Chumma of ID" is equal hyping for Debo.

I would say that Hemu's voice is the best of all, while Debo would be the next. Vinit's voice as somebody has said is yet to be matured. But if we see the consistency in sur & taal then Vinit is better than Debo. Hemu is no doubt the best amongst the three.

Actually when the finals started (when there were 12 of them) I was hoping & had a belief that Hemu was the best male singer & Nihira was the best female singer. However, as usual, when you leave to public voting then " Gadha bhi Ghodha ban jata hai", classical case is the choice of Fame Jodi (Qazi & Rup Rekha), who are nowhere near the final 12 selected in SRGMP.

Anyway, this program has given a lot of entertainment, drama & all, & we should really give a nice clap to GS & Zee TV.... 👏

Originally posted by: royadav

Delhi_Guy

Well you are already voting for Debo for last two months which tells that is your choice. Then why Vinit is getting maximum number of votes for NORTH ZONE. Only 5.5 Lakhs vote is in favour of Debo. I do not think that HR/VINIT is polluting the competition. VINIT is giving good fight to DEBOJIT If Debo is your deserving candidate does not mean the whole north zone opinion is same as yours

Originally posted by: uselogic

well. as again thanks for replying..

"if the first is wrong then the latter is also wrong.. ".. well two wrong things doesnt make a thing right.. you mean to say if i say id did wrong than HR' wrong is justified.....which in a way you are accepting that HR is wrong but since ID did chumma thing thats why HR is also right...

Ok when ID gave chumma to DEBO, he really sang the song well. Well we could debate that whether givining chumma was a decent thing to do or a hug would have done..may be right may be wrong...debatable... but yesterday he just said because he wanted to say something...he also gave a 50 rs note to vinit..i can say that is hype.. but have u ever heard ID saying votes to debo because i gave chumma to him... he can deviate a little, but he will stick to music..but HR says, make vinit a winner , so that he can gets his love..this is WRONG..inevst in vinit and invest in india as he is the biggest patriotic..Please do something free of cost..what is this nonsense..let him say vote vinit because he is a good singer..period..had he done it, vinit would have been the topmost vote getter...even if vinits sings good, he will say vote him because he want to get his love..this is not going down well with the public...

hype your contestant. do it... but just because it is a comptetion, u can't go down to any level..No Strict NO. it is music...it is matter of worship for so many people...how can he malign it..people remeber their gurus, god before they go for singing..lata ji used ot be barefooted while recording her song...this is devotion...you need to maintain some decency....

well my dear Uselogic you have again used the wrong logic and wrongly interpreted my statement just concentrate on my first word "IF" this word itself says the whole story and your interpretation shows the amount of logic you have ... nowhere in my statement i said that HR is wrong ... this is all because of your biased thinking against HR....

ID said that he gave chumma to Debo then too i'm not saying it wrong and apart from chumma there are many other things which has been said by id to create debo's hype .. viz .. his dad is ill, his wife is earning livihood for him etc.. this is all to gain the sympathy of the voters .... but i don't say he did wrong because this is a competition and every mentor feels his candidate is deserving one and so they are marketing their candidates in their own way and i dont see any harm in it ... as far as something free of cost is concerned .. you also know the voting is being done through the sms which is not at all free of cost ... to vote for any contestant you will have to invest .. so HR did not do anything wrong in praising his candidate this is his style of marketing ... at the same time ... AD and ID have their own style of asking votes for their candidate.... and they do the same ....

one more thing which you mentioned in your blog about the some mentors' going down to any level because of the competitiveness is totally illogical .... just tell me how much low level is attained by each mentor .. and moreover you are nobody to decide the level .. it's only your mental level has gone down .. none of the mentors, in my opinion, has gone to so called low level...

you talk about devotion .. then let me tell you each individual has his or her own way of showing devotion ... how can you compare these guys to great Lataji.. this shows the mental level you have attained ... no body can be compared to lataji or rafi saab by winning mere one singing competition ... grow up use logic...

Originally posted by: ds_kamath123

royadav,

Well said, at last I'm finding some person who is speaking logical. Lot of people here seem to be getting irritated by HR/Vinit hype. But as you have pointed out "Chumma of ID" is equal hyping for Debo.

I would say that Hemu's voice is the best of all, while Debo would be the next. Vinit's voice as somebody has said is yet to be matured. But if we see the consistency in sur & taal then Vinit is better than Debo. Hemu is no doubt the best amongst the three.

Actually when the finals started (when there were 12 of them) I was hoping & had a belief that Hemu was the best male singer & Nihira was the best female singer. However, as usual, when you leave to public voting then " Gadha bhi Ghodha ban jata hai", classical case is the choice of Fame Jodi (Qazi & Rup Rekha), who are nowhere near the final 12 selected in SRGMP.

Anyway, this program has given a lot of entertainment, drama & all, & we should really give a nice clap to GS & Zee TV.... 👏

thanx kamath ..

for the first time in this discussion some one has recognised the real voice

i appriciate your thinking mr. kamath...

USELOGIC,

We all are eagerly waiting for your tonight's update..
Only 4 Hrs left as per Indian time..
ADWARKNATH ji ka to jawab nahii ..but you are tooo good in those Updates...

Thx,
Delhi_Guy

royadav,
Again well said.
This is all competition & we all know that everything is fair in Love & War. These people are doing the best to encourage & win their chelas.. nothing wrong in all this hyping business. In fact I enjoy each and every part of it.
And to say the least, this competition is not the end for all the participants. I'm sure all the 12 finalists were gems & they would definitely shine in future & we would be seeing it in coming future.... So whether Hema wins or Debo wins or Vinit wins.. I feel that Music has won & we are having lot of talent unfolded in front of us who could glorify Indian Music in the coming future & that is good !!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

thanks royadv...

well looking at your writing , it looks you are more trying to settle scores with me rather than talking on the main subject :):):):) every time u mention that i said this and that, and when others also did the same thing... thats the problem. we generally evaluate a statement not just on the merit and demerit of the statement but also involve the merit and demerit of the person who said it..that is where we stop using reasoning and get emotional about things...

anyways every individual has view point and i respect that...


wow what a gyan....thanks royadv anyways... ek doha yaad aaya , hoe u understand hindi.. by kabir

"nindak niyare rakhiye, aangan kuti chawayee//
bene paani sabun bina nirmal kare subhai"

try to understand, what i meant by this doha

one more thing..kamath ji and royadav...

i just see u guys joining late and very few posts..looks like you havent gone thorugh lots and lots of posts...i would appreciate , if you can go thorugh all of them...they are really intresting...you can anyways skip mine :)