Why ID’s mouth was shut today? - Page 4

mademoise11e : I am very curios to know your age...

Pressure is one thing in which even the greatest people collapse... We are talking about 17 year old kids who are on stage and millions of people are watching them. These kids who were singing in their bathrooms and gullies are now in stage in front of millions. everyone knows them, they sign autographs...Think about the pressure when some experienced guy(not naming anyone in particular), who is famous comes and tells you that this is the way you should do to be famous....You should revolt against the voting system, it is not fair.....blah blah... Any amatuer is bound to get influenced and I am sure Mademoise11e you would too., even if you were 60 and it was your first time on stage. I am not trying to attack you but trying to be in their shoes and think.

Now everyone please stop blaming and cursing the kids. The people who are blaming them are for sure either less than 17 years of age or their brains are really young...

I totally agree with Iron, a bunch of 17 year olds cannot come up with such a plan. I am ready to have a one on one with anyone who believes so.

Stop blaming the kids and even Debo, its not his fault that the people from the NE are voting for him.

Enjoy the music, vote for talent and again stop cursing the contestants.

Originally posted by: MadhuD

ID looks intelligent untill he does not speak.

I completely agree with you. Wow! great statement.

SRGMP is drawing its inspiration from WWE wrestling matches where everything is scripted.
In last two episodes everything was scripted.
What gives !
These are kids ; what is their bargaining power ; walkouts can only be executed by contestants with chips.
They were not even able to express their ideas.
No body walks out of a competition unless scripted.
Their body language gave away everything. And what did they accomplish. Except creating sensationalism and ruining a sublime show. This show is becoming an incredible concoction of sopa-opera+game show+wrestlisng show+reality show+ Crass shouting match
And finally the producers should desist from divisions based on REGIONS. Are'nt there enough divisions already.

I totally agree with you Iron, the reason i joined this forum was to talk about music and discuss about the nitty gritties of music and discuss songs sung by the contestants...

But this forum is just people who like one guy and are blind (rather deaf) to other peoples talents...

Debo fans think that Debo is the best (thats ok) but other guys do not deserve to be in the competition)

Same goes for Vineet fans...

Nihira fans hate everybody and are really mad because she lost and have started bashing other contestants especially Himani... (I liked Nihira the best, but never ever thought the others werent good.)

Some Hemu fans who actually liked him for his voice, have left him because he did a walkout...and they will now vote for Debo, all Nihirafans will vote for debo, All NE fans will wait for Debo (i donot object to that at all)...

But by all this does the music win..

Say In the finals Debo gets 90% votes and Hemu gets 10% votes,... how many of the 90% votes to Debo are because he is more talented than Hemu...I dont know???

I am fed up of Sa RE Ga Ma but I will have to watch it for the music still left in it...When that dies I will switch over to Indian Idol. ;)

Originally posted by: selsynch

will u pls. provide the link to this article? i could not get it on rediff

http://in.rediff.com/movies/2006/jan/25ismail.htm

Originally posted by: god_bless_the_w

I go with ID's reaction....

yes, he had every right to show how upset he was with their act

Originally posted by: Kaschif

he did the right thing, if you watched, Himani said Sorry to him (not to HR or AS), there was some reason behind this. we saw only edited version of all the drama. shooting was halted for more than 5 hours according to news. if any wrong was said to ID in-between then he did the right thing.

Himani realized her mistake and confessed to ID back stage. She along with the other two chickens told that they did every thing on someones indication (it seemed to be AS). She begged for ID's forgiveness. ID told her that what ever she does should be with her own mind and not someone else's direction. This is posted in a news letter.

ID was too bitter to say anything after such attitude shown by Himani. It was not wrong on his part. He has praised Himani's performance more than once from his heart, even when his own contestant Nihira is such a good singer. What Himani said in front of the audience was an insult to ID's student and hence an insult to ID. Its good that she realized later and apologised. Anyway, I think that it was not planned by HImani, Vinit and Hemu but by HR and AS. But Himani and Vinit sounded quite arrogant when they carried out the plan laid out by their mentors. Hemu seemed to get trapped in this vicious plan and forced to play his part. But being a nice, cultured guy he could not play his part well and did not sound arrogant and convincing.

Originally posted by: blueman

ID was too bitter to say anything after such attitude shown by Himani. It was not wrong on his part. He has praised Himani's performance more than once from his heart, even when his own contestant Nihira is such a good singer. What Himani said in front of the audience was an insult to ID's student and hence an insult to ID. Its good that she realized later and apologised. Anyway, I think that it was not planned by HImani, Vinit and Hemu but by HR and AS. But Himani and Vinit sounded quite arrogant when they carried out the plan laid out by their mentors. Hemu seemed to get trapped in this vicious plan and forced to play his part. But being a nice, cultured guy he could not play his part well and did not sound arrogant and convincing.

Infact Hema has said later that he was surprised on few of the comments Vinit make. He was not party to it.

I believe that ID was repeating the same action as done by himesh n aadesh...remember, when nihira was voted out, none of these 2 mentors said anything ...they both remained quite...dat time, the only mentor sympthaising with nihira was id...mayb thats y id too did the same wid himani...and da thursday episode too added to his fury...