flowerYY thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

I would like to do a case study on the Mentor & Participants Behaviour of various gharanas.

HEMU & AS:

Right from the beginning i have noticed that AS is so proud of his gharana. For your kind information AS, its your luck that you got participants who are well trained in music and all you had to do is just mould them. So not a big deal...

Also whenever ID's gharana people sing, he shows faces as if he is there wasting time. I wonder if he has anything better to do at all.

He was the one who started all the stunts by fighting with ID and pulling up a big drama. Still the vengeance is lingering in his mind.. thats why he behaves like that towards ID & his gharana participants.

HEMU.. what to say about you? Initially i thought you were the most decent guy .. but you fell cheaply for AS & Himani's (Vinit's) conspiracy. Whats the point being a silent spectator? Always fight for the truth... even if your guru is the culprit.

Conclusion: AS is full of arrogance and poor HEMU got into the wrong gharana ...

VINIT & HR:

HR was good initially (may be pretending to be good), with encouraging words for all the participants. But later realised that he had lost all his participants except VINIT. So he got into the 'AISHWARYA' drama and once he got BRAHMASTRA he conveniently forgot AISH also..

And started VINIT's love drama.. how could he stoop so low, i wonder!!! Also whenever other gharana participants are performing he has a stony expression on his face .. but when it comes to VINIT then he shows all kind (funny ofcourse) expressions.. please note that too when the camera is focussed on him. such cheap publicity.. SHAME ON YOU. For him only VINIT exists in the world.

VINIT.. falling in love and making that a big thing at this age, i wonder if you ever be able to reach the pinnacle in your life. And the way you sing, its monotonous. Whenever other participants were eliminated you didnt care a bit .. but for Himani you made a fuss.. for what???

Conclusion: HR & VINIT will do anything for cheap publicity and care more about love (that too for publicity) rather than music and singing.


DEBO & ID:

What can i say about ID ? He was so naive and kept appreciating good singing irrespective of the gharana and failed to back up his singers. By the time he realised this, NIHIRA (the one and only well behaved person in SRGMP other than Shaan) was out of the competition. I think that guilty feeling (that he didnt back up his singers like AS & HR did) only made him to walk out.

DEBO.. a decent guy. Attempted different variety of songs. Thats what ID & his gharana people always focussed on.. MUSIC and MUSIC only...
Like his mentor he also speaks from his heart. Always took the elder brotherly role whenever other contenstants were voted out.

Conclusion: ID & DEBO are true lovers of music and also very true people.


Recommendation: May the truth win even in this Kali Yug. And a word to the mentors.. please always accept defeat in a graceful manner and thats the foremost thing that you should have taught your disciples.


Personal comment: And last but not the least, i would like to see Vandana (DEBO's wife) shed tears.. of course that of joy onthe final day....then i think i can forget all the bad things that happened in SRGMP 2005 and eagerly await SRGMP 2006 (ofcourse with No Mentors......😛)


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".