THis is india's voice, NOT Regional voice - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

110

Views

7.7k

Users

35

Frequent Posters

sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: gulachi

Hi...I agree with you, Debo was horrible today, riding on the wave of sympathy votes, talking about his ailing father or passed away mother, every contestant has a dream and their parents too but they do not try to cry "sympathy" all the time as Debo does, hope Indians choose a really good voice together rather than someone who just tries to create sympathy....

DEBOJIT IS NOT WORTH IN COMING EVEN IN TOP 10 , PERIOD.

Also even Debojit has told on show that there are people who are doing SMS of Rs 2000. What does that means. It means One single person is trying to vote as many times for Debojit. Isn't this BIASED, REGIONALISED. Have they voted even once for Nihira. I didn't hear from Shaan that Nihira received any % from NE. Can you explain why ? Wasn't Nihira. I am not biased to her, I have heard her and I think she was the best. She will definately have bright future ahead. But what happened because of Regionalised voting is one talented person got thrown out. The system itself is WRONG.
Which is what we are against of anyone who does that. I don't like HR's strategy of Vinit either. It's so cheap.
this is singing competiton best on talent. Debojit should not get votes from emotional or he is from NE and considering person from NE region has never reached at such stage. Does that take away the abilities and talent of other person.
Be reasonable rise above territories, go beyond religion, countries. Think as Rational i.e human. Throw away this "Regional Biased" cap you are wearing and then appreciate people who are talented. See how much better you will feel and how beautiful the world will be.

the "Regionalized Biased Voting" has stretched so much, that we are loosing talented people. Debo is good singer but I don't think he even deserved in top 10. That's my opinion I may be wrong. I think the lady meant being "This is India's Voce because" the other person said this is "Assam's Voice". She meant that the show is of whole India not only of Assam. Off course there can be many interpretations and she only knows what she said and we people can SPIN her statement as we want. But again this is not the point we want to concentrate.

If we don't voice (crying as you termed it) the system will not improve. Through this discussions we know what other people think, we get an idea. I have not heard/read single person here that Nihira was bad. I also think Himani is better then Debo. Vinit, he sings well. But I don't like HR's sentimental begging.
I am not against of Debo or anybody, I just like to see talented people getting success. If talented people are not selected and other people get selected based on Regionalism and Emotional basis, it will not put a good precedent. What will happen is in the next challenge the contestants will use those biased things to win. Thus they will not concentrate on talent or talented people would not participate, as they know they can't win. So look how the system is going to form. That's why we have to raise the voice. It's better to be Late then never Right?
I am not saying you are stupid, I will never say like that, I can understand what you are saying.

I think its completely wrong about HEMA asking vote on MAAA KA SAPNAA and his relatives spending lakhs on SMS. Nihira ,Hemani & Sharib should have been in the finals. And you are right about Paresh too. I liked him, I appreciate what tremendous efforts he has taken. We want these kind of people in the competition and not CRY BABIES.

I don't like this "Reservation" system at all. In professional life everything should based on Talent , Honesty and hard work.Sentiments or Emotional factors should not be considered.


Edited by sanbel - 19 years ago
sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#42

NAWAB is RIGHT.........

THESE PEOPLE CANNOT RISE ABOVE REGIONS..... YOU ARE SICK

Edited by sanbel - 19 years ago
sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: sangeetaa

U know I think I have a solution to the regional voting issue. Don't allow the
contestant's region to vote - lets see - Debo is from ne - so we can
eliminate them.

But in all fairness, we can't stop there.
Hema is from South - so anything south of the Vindhyas is out. Himani tho
NCR se hai Vinit Lucknow ka banda hai - ok get rid of entire Northern
region. Ismail-ji or Himesh Gujarat ke hain - vahan ka vote bhi nikal do.

Now - of all the votes that are left - tell me, who wins??

NIHIRA SHE IS THE BEST....ANY ONE HAS ANY DOUBTS ???

ASK NE PEOPLE HAVE THEY VOTED NIHIRA ANY-TIME ????

WHYYYYY ?

sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Pradarshak

ARE YOU SICK ? This is not competiton of UNITY this is SINGING competions based on music talent.

Does DEBO have talent.... WOULD NE PEOPLE VOTED DEBU if he had been from Maharshtra.

What would have happen if Nihira was from NE and got out. NE people would have come for RIOTS.

Why can't NE people vote for good singers? Isn't this biased Regionalism. Do you believe Debu is better then Nihira

sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: friend17

For people who keep harping about the Assam votes, try learning the entire alphabet set without learning the letters A-F.

The reason I made this comment is that it sounds as much contradictory as claming that Assam's voice is not the voice of India where Assam is in fact itself part of India.

Beats me!! 😕

Wowww What a GREAT SPIN of that Lady's statement.

When that supporter said "It's Assam's Voice" , the lady got frustrated (as I was) and said this show is "India's Voice" and not only Assam's voice.

Why are you spinning in way like that. Isn't it true this show is India's Voice. Before that lady to be punished , I think that supporter should be punished.

You have to be rational. Debu is not that good singer at all.

sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: fnew

I don't think i will agree with your observation...I had the show recorded - the show where the 3 challengers walked out...I could clearly see Debu's wife using her hands and feet to give bad words...if you have the recording, watch carefully...she does it for couple of minutes and then you see Vineet's father turning back and replying and then his mother...and you will also see how close Debu's wife was getting to the front row ..and that's when I saw Vineet's mother asking her husband to be quiet..watch the recording again...i am not bias against vineet or hema or Debu...watching the fight from so far away and not being connected to any of the participant directly made me feel sick of that debu's wife ..first of all I didn't know it was his wife..My first openion was who this person is and what is she upto...then my husband said its debu's wife..and then came the other ones parents... and if she did not start the fight , vineet's parents wouldn't have continued it...Am I right? if she couldn't control herself being so young how do you expect 2 elderly people to listen about their son and be quiet...I don't think you would have... over all it was wrong on everyone who were abusing each other...c'mmon you have not gotton into the challenge to fight and get it...you are supposed to over power everyone with your voice and grab it...Whether its vineet, hema or Debu....they need to perform and win the hearts and not immotionally black mail or come to the stage with attitudes...

You are absoulutely Right!!! Look at the way the supporters for Debu behaved.

When Nihira was out...You should have seen how gracefully she and her mother accepted it , even though they knew SHE IS THE BEST. This is called good manners.SIMPLICITY!GREATNESS!!!

And I bet if anyone has any argument on that statement.

She got out just because of "Regionalism"

Edited by sanbel - 19 years ago
sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: friend17

For people who keep harping about the Assam votes, try learning the entire alphabet set without learning the letters A-F.

The reason I made this comment is that it sounds as much contradictory as claming that Assam's voice is not the voice of India where Assam is in fact itself part of India.

Beats me!! 😕

Friend17 Can you answer my questions...Please

blueman thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#48
akm_nawab_718 and others.. Do you know there was a talent contest SRGMP fame 2005 held early in 2005. This contest was judged by eminent musician judges. AND DEBOJIT beat VINIT to win the contest. Pandit Jasraj was the judge. Do you guys understand music more than him? Think hundred times before saying that Debojit is not a good singer.
sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: blueman

akm_nawab_718 and others.. Do you know there was a talent contest SRGMP fame 2005 held early in 2005. This contest was judged by eminent musician judges. AND DEBOJIT beat VINIT to win the contest. Pandit Jasraj was the judge. Do you guys understand music more than him? Think hundred times before saying that Debojit is not a good singer.

Dear Blueman,

It might be just one of that day, and you are still hanging on that.

Nihira performed every show contestantly, even those judges said nihira is the best and you tell how come Debojit is in final. I have watched him he is OK but not CONSISTENT.

His luck is good, he begs for sympathy votes even Viinit does that. I don't like Vinit either. But if I have to choose between these two I will choose Vinit.

sanbel thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: sp-kohinoor

I don't think it is injustice that debu got votes from his region. That is just normal. If he can't get votes from his region then where else is he going to get them from. And no debu is not my favorite, and i don't live in the NE, I just don't think it is wrong to get votes from your region. And some people don't like debu. That is an opinion, and i think we should respect others opinions.

So you agree that NE is regionalising the voting system. Ask them have they voted for Nihira or Himani ? Is Debu better then them ?

This is all Based on Region/Sympathy "Maaa Ka Sapnaaa". All stupid and not on talent this.

If you agree this, the discussion is OVER.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".